Chocolate Cherry Black Magic Halloween Cocktail Recipe

When it comes to themed cocktails, there's no better occasion to go all-out and lean into the festivities quite like Halloween. Of course, a good Halloween cocktail manages to balance both spooky appeal and delicious flavors, resulting in a drink that looks like it packs in plenty of tricks, but really just tastes like a treat. This chocolate cherry black magic Halloween cocktail recipe definitely fits the themed bill, as it looks like a deep, dark, mysterious elixir, but ultimately is a perfectly balanced concoction with a nice mix of fresh lemon and cherry flavors, a subtle cocoa note, and the clean flavor of vodka.

To achieve that jet-black opaque hue that makes this cocktail as visually intriguing as it is delicious, I use activated charcoal and simply add it right to the cocktail shaker with the other ingredients. A little charcoal powder goes a long way in establishing that black magic appeal, though you could also use black vodka instead, if you're able to find it. The chocolate and cherry elements come into play by way of cherry juice and creme de cacao, and fresh lemon juice adds just enough zestiness to work along with the tart cherry juice to keep the cocktail from becoming cloying. The resulting drink is a suitably spooky sipper to charm your Halloween guests.

To make this cocktail, start with vodka, tart cherry juice, creme de cacao, fresh lemon juice, and activated charcoal powder. Note that black vodka would work well here, if you happen to have a bottle in your bar cart, and you can skip the activated charcoal if you use this specialty ingredient instead. If you prefer your cocktail on the sweeter side, have optional simple syrup on hand as well.

The last two ingredients are technically optional garnishes, but ones I recommend for optimal visual appeal. First, dark cherries skewered on picks help provide a cue as to what the cocktail will taste like. Finally, a sprinkle of gold luster dust (make sure it's edible glitter, not the stuff you'd find at a craft store) adds a nice, vibrant contrast against the jet-black liquid. 

Combine the vodka, tart cherry juice, creme de cacao, lemon juice, and optional simple syrup (if you prefer a slightly sweeter cocktail) in a cocktail shaker; swirl to mix.

Add the activated charcoal powder.

Add ice to fill the shaker ⅔ of the way.

Cover and shake vigorously for 10-15 seconds until the exterior of the shaker is frosty.

Strain into two glasses.

Sprinkle each cocktail with luster dust.

Garnish with a dark cherry, and serve.

• Easy 3-Ingredient Chocolate Covered Cherries Recipe
• Chocolate Bourbon Cherry Cookie Recipe
• Baked Brie Jack O'Lantern Board Recipe
• Spooky Spicy Graveyard Bean Dip Recipe
• Smoky Pumpkin Deviled Eggs Recipe

There are two distinct ingredients you could use to achieve that striking dark hue in this cocktail recipe. The first option is black vodka, which, as the name implies, is a spirit with added coloring agents, transforming the typically transparent liquid into something opaque. Black catechu, which is a type of tree bark extract, is a common black vodka inclusion that helps provide that deep dark color. Depending on the brand, however, you may find various other botanical agents in the mix. Though it can be slightly tough to source, if you can find black vodka, it's a great spirit to keep in your repertoire for all things Halloween cocktails and beyond.

If you can't source black vodka, you can still make this Halloween cocktail using regular vodka and activated charcoal. This black, powdery ingredient also comes from plants or natural sources, like coal, wood chips, or tree bark. Odorless and mostly tasteless, activated charcoal powder has become popular in the food scene and beyond, offering a way to achieve a notable jet-black hue without the need for excessive food dye. There are some concerns to consider before you add activated charcoal to cocktails, specifically if you're taking certain medications or vitamins. Also, keep in mind that a little bit goes a long way in foods and drinks. This cocktail recipe calls for a mere ¼ teaspoon of activated charcoal, and that really is all you need to get the job done for two cocktails. 

Since this black magic Halloween cocktail is no ordinary drink, naturally, you might want to get a bit creative with the food pairing options. First, it's worth considering how sweet you want to make your batch of cocktails. Without the simple syrup, the cocktail has a light sweetness but mostly just boasts a distinct tart cherry-lemon flavor and a hint of chocolate. Savory appetizers like a charcuterie board (make it a Halloween-themed one for extra fun) or crostini would pair well with the less-sweet version of the cocktail, especially if you're sipping on them to kick off a night as opposed to ending it.

If you want to enjoy these black magic cocktails towards the end of the night, as more of a dessert cocktail (and adding the optional simple syrup in this case), then you can lean into a more sugary approach with the food pairings. Naturally, both chocolate and fruity desserts, especially ones with cherry, will complement the flavors of the cocktail. Think chocolate-dipped cherries, chocolate cherry cake, or even chocolate cherry cobbler as sweet treats that directly mirror the flavor notes in the drink. Other Halloween treat favorites would also work here, of course, like candy apples, cupcakes, brownies, or cookies.

• Pumpkin Spice Mai Tai Recipe
• Gingered Pumpkin and Rum Cocktail Recipe
• Vampire's Kiss Halloween Cocktail Recipe
• Tipsy Witch Halloween Cocktail Recipe
• Extra Spooky Corpse Reviver Cocktail Recipe