9 Discontinued Fall Grocery Items That Deserve A Second Chance
We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.
From specific brands' takes on iconic fall foods to more unique items that play with various autumnal flavors, the season that bridges summer and winter is home to a lot of delicious treats. Some are available year-round and just get more popular during the autumn months, while others are only around while the leaves are changing and the temps are dropping, and they don't return until Mother Nature does that whole song and dance again the following year.
Unfortunately, some fall items don't end up coming back when the fall season itself does. Maybe they were only around for one certain autumn season and were never actually intended for an encore. Or perhaps they were only given a few fall seasons with which to gain a following and didn't sell well enough to justify a perpetual return. Either way, all of the items on this list have either been officially discontinued or have now failed to come back during so many successive falls that it's safe to assume they aren't ever going to.
More importantly than all of these items being gone is the fact that none of them deserve to be. And we hope they can come back for a future fall season. Or better yet, surprise us by popping up in the last few weeks of the current one. You never know — there's still a decent amount of time left before everything switches to gingerbread, peppermint, and eggnog.
Trader Joe's Apple Cider Fruit Spread
The list of discontinued fall Trader Joe's items that stop returning after a season or two seems to grow longer all the time, and the grocery chain is going to likewise be heavily represented in this article. First up is TJ's Apple Cider Fruit Spread — not quite apple butter, not quite jelly, and not quite apple pie filling. Rather, it represents a gloriously delicious intersection of the Venn diagram between those three, with chunks of sweet apple in a thick, jam-like spread flavored with cinnamon, ginger, and other classic fall spices.
It's tough to know why it went away, since it seemed to very much be a fan favorite while it was available. Next to a picture of a completely cleaned-out jar of it, a member of the Wichita Trader Joe's Facebook page raved, "We don't often use up jarred condiments to the last drop like this, but the Apple Cider Fruit Spread was a huge hit at our house!" And since it's been gone — which seems to have happened in 2023 — people have taken to coming up with and sharing recipes on social media that attempt to specifically replicate TJ's Apple Cider Fruit Spread because they miss it that much.
Pillsbury Pumpkin Pie Toaster Strudel Pastries
Though Pillsbury's Pumpkin Pie flavor of its frozen Toaster Strudel Pastries were labeled as limited edition from the start, there was still the hope that this just meant limited to the fall season. Plenty of seasonal food items that purport to be limited edition do indeed return later on. Sadly, that wasn't in the cards for the Pumpkin Pie Toaster Strudels, which launched in the fall of 2014 but were discontinued in either 2015 or 2016 (unfortunately, there isn't always concrete historical information about such things, and anecdotal evidence is all we have to go on).
Contained within the standard flaky pastry and drizzled with the included vanilla icing typical of most regular Toaster Strudel varieties, it was the sweet, creamy pumpkin pie filling that made this seasonal Toaster Strudel unique. A comment on an Instagram post about the defunct flavor said wistfully, "Pumpkin Pie was one of the best fall flavors I've ever had." For what it's worth, the Frosted Pumpkin Pie Pop-Tarts are still in seasonal rotation. Though, pretty much anyone who has directly compared the two has proclaimed the Pumpkin Pie Toaster Strudel as superior.
M&M's White Chocolate Candy Corn
Our list of the discontinued M&M's we wish would return includes several seasonal favorites, a few of which are specifically fall-coded. While many people mourn M&M's Pumpkin Spice Latte flavor, we tried not to have pumpkin products completely dominate this list. So instead, we are highlighting the White Chocolate Candy Corn M&M's flavor, which first popped up in the early 2010s but hasn't been seen since well before that decade ended.
While more in-depth reviews of this seasonal candy indicated a fairly subtle white chocolate note among what were overwhelmingly candy corn-flavored M&M's, people still seemed to love them. In a Reddit post asking others if White Chocolate Candy Corn M&M's were as "magical" as the original poster remembers them to be, the comment section reaffirmed the poster's nostalgia. "They were amazing," one reply stated simply. "My all time favorite M&M. I would buy all the packs I could find when they were making them," gushed another Redditor. And one fan questioned the decision to stop making them, insisting "they always sold out" while they were still being made.
Trader Joe's Pumpkin Rolls
Here we have another Trader Joe's fall item that people mourn the loss of — this time, something from the chain's bake-at-home cooler section. TJ's tubes of ready-to-bake Pumpkin Rolls had a much longer run than most of the items on this list, lasting almost a decade before 2023 saw them not return during their usual fall window. And they haven't been back since.
While most pumpkin roll recipes call for cream cheese frosting, one of the most unique elements of Trader Joe's Pumpkin Rolls is that they included pumpkin spice icing instead. That doubling down of pumpkin flavors might not be for everyone, but it had enough fans to justify it coming back for a whole bunch of fall seasons before TJ's finally pulled the plug — to the bafflement and frustration of said fans.
In fact, it seemed so unlikely the Pumpkin Rolls were actually gone that several Trader Joe's employees have speculated on Reddit that they'd probably return either with different packaging, a tweaked recipe, or with some other minor change — none of which has happened thus far. In one of the most pointed replies underneath another Reddit post complaining of TJ's retiring its Pumpkin Rolls, one Redditor snarked, "Trader Joe's is continually making it easier for me to not want to shop there."
Trader Joe's Pumpkin Pie Spice Cookie Butter
Trader Joe's Speculoos Cookie Butter Spread is already one of the best cookie butters not made by Biscoff. So, it stands to reason that a seasonal variant of TJ's Cookie Butter would also be both high quality and delicious — and both are true of the Trader Joe's Pumpkin Pie Spice Cookie Butter. Using the same base as its regular version of Cookie Butter, the Pumpkin Pie Spice Cookie Butter not only has all the usual pumpkin spice spices but also contains actual pumpkin. One food writer compared the taste to if a pumpkin pie had gingersnap cookies as its crust. Does that sound delightful or what?
Online chatter seems to suggest that the Pumpkin Pie Spice Cookie Butter hasn't been seen on a Trader Joe's shelf since 2016. And fans have been pretty vocal in their disappointment of that fact. "This was one of my favorite items during the fall season," proclaimed one Redditor. Another person lamented, "I thought it was the best pumpkin spice product I'd ever had and every year I hope and pray it'll come back!"
In a reply to that last post, someone suggested adding pumpkin pie spice into TJ's regular Cookie Butter as a loose approximation of the defunct product. As of now, that sadly seems to be the closest anyone is going to get to having Pumpkin Pie Spice Cookie Butter again.
Shock Top Honeycrisp Apple Wheat
Not all fall products that you buy at a grocery store are intended for the whole family. There are many adult beverages that are enjoyed during the autumn months, some permanent and some as seasonal variations of existing things. And one of the most noteworthy examples of the latter — at least, among things you can't buy anymore — is Shock Top's Honeycrisp Apple Wheat ale.
Shock Top's original Belgian White flavor profile leans more summery, with its notes of orange, lemon, and lime. But when fall rolls around, enjoyers of fruit-flavored beers tend to gravitate away from summer citruses and towards pome fruits, which feel much more autumnal. And that's where Shock Top's Honeycrisp Apple Wheat comes in. However, it only hung around for three autumns in the mid-2010s, after which it was pulled in part due to backlash over its marketing, which seemed to imply it was a hard cider rather than a traditional wheat beer.
But those who didn't feel misled by Shock Top Honeycrisp Apple Wheat seemed to fall in love with it. "I miss this beer terribly. I wish they would bring it back," read one Reddit post, to which another person replied, "I shed a tear every time I walk by a case of shock top that isn't the apple wheat." One fan in that same comment section also suggested it was superior to the similar Busch Light Apple lager.
Duncan Hines Applesauce Raisin Cake Mix
Not every fall product that has come and gone has been a product of the current millennium. In fact, to remember when this nostalgic fall Duncan Hines cake mix was still available, we need to turn the clocks all the way back to the 1980s, which seems to be the last time anyone can remember seeing the Duncan Hines Applesauce Raisin Cake Mix in stores.
It makes sense, given that even at the time, applesauce raisin cake itself was seen as an extremely old-fashioned dessert — 19th-century old fashioned, in fact. When companies first started doing boxed cake mixes in the 1930s, early batches of available mixes were naturally the ones that adults at the time had grown up with. And that would've included various classic cakes that saw their heyday in the late 1800s through the early 1900s, like applesauce raisin. As such, many of those early cake mixes fell out of fashion as those older recipes themselves fell out of fashion.
For its part, Duncan Hines first released its Applesauce Raisin Cake Mix as part of its Early American line in the 1960s. But applesauce raisin cake as a whole shouldn't be lost to time. It's a great combination of fall flavors, a spiced cake with apple flavoring, lined with raisins (which we also feel is an underrated autumn dessert ingredient in and of itself). Sure, you can always make your own, but more people would discover this nostalgic gem if it were once again made available as a simple boxed cake mix.
Kellogg's Apple Raisin Crisp
Speaking of apples and raisins being a bygone autumnal flavor combination that has been pushed aside by pumpkin spice and apple cinnamon, Kellogg's once had an Apple Raisin Crisp cereal that would make a great breakfast for those cool fall mornings. While there is typically a push towards warm breakfasts to kick off cold days, not everyone wants to "make" something in the morning. Even oatmeal can be a few steps too many when you're feeling tired and just want something quick and easy — something like cereal, which is where Apple Raisin Crisp entered the chat.
With box graphics that would've looked right at home in 1980s kitchens surrounded by frilly, cross-stitched hand towels, oven mitts, and placemats, Apple Raisin Crisp deliciously combined apple-flecked flakes with a generous helping of raisins. Unfortunately, not long after its launch around 1983-1984, Apple Raisin Crisp maker Kellogg's found itself entangled in a protracted legal battle with General Mills over that company's similar Oatmeal Raisin Crisp. Long story short, things ultimately went in favor of General Mills, and it appears the success of Oatmeal Raisin Crisp effectively pushed Apple Raisin Crisp off of store shelves shortly into the '90s.
Now that Oatmeal Raisin Crisp is also gone, we feel Apple Raisin Crisp deserves a comeback. But only if it brings back the classic cross-stitch packaging, because otherwise, it just wouldn't feel like Apple Raisin Crisp.
Park Street Deli Pumpkin Pie Dessert Hummus
Among the many different types of hummus, one that is still considered more on the niche side is dessert hummus. Even so, you can get almost every type of sweet flavor you can think of in the form of dessert hummus, and that includes pumpkin pie — which was realized in a delightful mix of fall flavors in the Park Street Deli Pumpkin Pie Dessert Hummus from Aldi, which debuted in the fall of 2019.
As it is, seasonal Aldi items can be a mixed bag in terms of availability, and it's difficult to know when something has truly been discontinued or when it's just difficult to find because stock was very limited and went quickly. But in this case, it seems as though Aldi discontinued all of its dessert hummuses, so that likewise means that the Pumpkin Pie Dessert Hummus is gone, as well. This is especially disappointing as, unlike more common flavors, it's not as though there are a bunch of different companies making something as niche as pumpkin pie-flavored dessert hummus.
Boar's Head does have a Pumpkin Pie Dessert Hummus, but fans of the Aldi version who have tried the Boar's Head one as a replacement have reported that it doesn't live up to it. The Park Street Deli one was described as tasting sweet, like pumpkin pie filling, as opposed to the more savory Boar's Head version.