9 Surprising Places To Order Your Wedding Cake

Add Tasting Table on Google:
Google Discover

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

Keeping a wedding under the cost of 10 grand requires not only restraint, but also a fair amount of creativity, so much so that there's a "Weddings Under 10k" subreddit devoted to the cause. In it, folks have frequently reported that, by ordering your wedding cake from the right place, you can save hundreds of dollars and still serve a delicious dessert to your guests. In other words, there's no shame in buying your wedding cake from a grocery store; just make sure it's in line with your catering and wedding venue's rules.

This is your wedding, so feel free to get creative. You might buy an extremely simple cake from a grocery store and have your florist decorate it, or choose a king cake or cheesecake instead of a sponge cake. Or, you could buy a fancy cake from a local bakery for the ceremonial cutting, then purchase a few budget-friendly sheet cakes (or boxes of cupcakes) from a supermarket to serve your guests.

Regardless, it's still a good idea to have your cake reserved a month in advance of your wedding, though some stores on this list can accommodate requests closer to the big day — especially if customizations are kept to a minimum. Furthermore, not all these stores offer delivery, so make sure you assign someone to pick up your cake if you're not able to get to the store yourself. Finally, when ordering a cake with more than two tiers, make sure you trust the bakery staff and see what they've created in the past; there have been some reports of lopsided and tilting cakes online.

Publix

Publix is one of the most commonly recommended grocery stores to buy a wedding cake, not to mention other baked goods like cookies and pies. That's because the cakes are affordable, aesthetically pleasing, and downright delicious.

Of course, one of the more enjoyable parts of wedding planning is getting to sample cake. That's possible at Publix and free of charge. In addition to the cake flavor and the type of icing, Publix's bakery department will also help you settle on the color scheme (which can be personalized to match your wedding color), the fillings, and the size of your cake. You can get a classic vanilla and buttercream wedding cake from Publix, or get creative with fillings like guava, dulce de leche, and fresh banana custard.

Publix advises that you get the ball rolling with a consultation at least six weeks in advance, and order the cake at least four weeks ahead of the event. Then, on the big day, staff will deliver the cake up to 15 miles for an extra fee. 

If you'd rather not go through the wedding cake process, folks have also had success in stacking two round cakes from Publix, then adorning them with frosting and personal decorations. Indeed, this is a cake shortcut that Publix fans swear by, and is ideal for those who have a very specific design in mind and the expertise to execute it.

Nothing Bundt Cakes

Nothing Bundt Cakes is no stranger to weddings; the celebrated cake chain has a designated wedding collection to help couples find elegant cakes that match their theme and taste buds. Some of the most popular wedding cake flavors also happen to be the most highly ranked flavors at Nothing Bundt Cakes. And even better, there's no pressure to choose between red velvet, vanilla, and carrot; folks typically purchase one large cake for the ceremonial cutting, along with a variety of Bundtinis — miniature Bundt cakes — for the guests.

People regularly compliment the excellent flavors and moistness of these cakes, and while the standard frosting is said to be plentiful enough, you can customize your regular-sized Bundt cake with more or less icing if you prefer. You can even order a naked cake that you (or someone you trust) can frost according to your wedding theme. The Bundtinis can likewise be customized with extra frosting or sold naked.

Place a regular Bundt cake on top of a Big Bundt cake, and what do you get? A tiered cake that can serve 26 people. This might be the cake you serve to the wedding party, and you'll likely have some left over to freeze for your first anniversary. Meanwhile, the Bundtinis are bite-sized, so plan for at least one per person. Make sure to have your own cake stand, as well as cupcake stands, for displaying these desserts.

The Cheesecake Factory

Weddings can get cheesy with all the heartfelt toasts, so why not take it one step further with an assortment of cheesecakes from The Cheesecake Factory? Rich, sweet, and a tad bit tangy (just like married life), cheesecake is a dessert that your guests won't easily forget. Redditors report that serving cheesecake from this decadent chain is not only budget-friendly, but also convenient. The cheesecakes can be kept frozen and easily transported to the venue by someone from the wedding party. They need only to defrost in the fridge for three to five hours before serving.

Because the 10-inch cheesecakes contain 12 to 15 servings each, you'll want to get a handful of cakes to feed everyone in attendance. That means this is another perfect opportunity to buy multiple crowd-pleasing flavors. Strawberry, Lemon Meringue, Godiva Chocolate, and Vanilla Bean are all simple, elegant flavors, but don't hesitate to try more unique offerings like Pumpkin Pecan, Toasted Marshmallow S'mores Galore, or Reese's Peanut Butter Chocolate Cake Cheesecakes. Most of these cakes are pre-sliced.

The Cheesecake Factory isn't in the business of customizing and decorating cakes, but a graceful cake topper and a nice cake stand can go a long way in making your cheesecake give off more wedding vibes. There are also plenty of edible flowers you can turn to. If desired, keep accompaniments like whipped cream, syrup, custard, and caramel on hand.

Whole Foods

If you've been eyeing Whole Foods' Berry Chantilly Cake for years, but have never found the right excuse to add it to your cart, here it is. This white, delicate cake is laden with succulent berries, making it a gorgeous and timeless centerpiece for your dessert table. In fact, whenever Whole Foods comes up on wedding cake forums, there's hardly ever another cake mentioned.

The Berry Chantilly Cake has a single tier, and according to a former Whole Foods bakery supervisor, stacking multiple cakes yourself could turn out to be super messy — so don't. Instead, order multiple cakes (circular cakes and sheet cakes are both available), or keep a large cake for yourself and serve your guests the Berry Chantilly Cupcakes. Cake customizations are limited, but you can add text if desired. You can also order the cake with extra berries or ask for them to be skipped entirely.

Other cake flavors that might fit your wedding vision include the Chocolate Eruption Cake and the Red Velvet Cake, though availability varies by store. Meanwhile, for guests with dietary restrictions, Whole Foods offers an excellent array of vegan and nut-free cupcakes, cookies, and brownies.

Walmart

However surprising, while shopping for paper towels and birdseed at Walmart, you could also pick up a wedding cake. As a matter of fact, Walmart has an entire custom wedding cake collection online that you can peruse, with different shapes, sizes, toppings, and piping styles. There's a simple round cake topped with flowers in muted tones, a gaudy two-tiered cake that would fit in with an '80s wedding theme, and a cake topped with blueberries and strawberries for a burst of color. Whether you need a cake to feed 12 people or one to feed 64, Walmart has you covered. You could even order a few cupcake bouquets, each of which feeds a dozen people.

Walmart's cakes are frequently lauded for being moist, flavorful, and affordable. And if you're a last-minute planner, take heart: Folks say that the bakery only needs about two weeks of lead-up time to make a single cake. If you'll be ordering multiple cakes, though, try to let them know a month in advance.

Redditors have a handful of tips for buying a cake from Walmart, all of which might help you in procuring the exact wedding cake you've dreamed about all your life. For example, you might want to browse the pre-made cakes to get a sense of the cake decorators' strengths and weaknesses. When in doubt, see if there's another Walmart nearby that meets your standards.

Sam's Club

Whether it's a small cake, a tiered cake, or a sheet cake, Redditors agree that Sam's Club can give you an elegant and flavorful wedding cake without eating into your budget. One customer explained that they topped their Sam's Club cake with edible pearls, but if you order yours from the wedding and anniversary cake collection, you won't have to spruce your cake up much. The Member's Mark Graceful Radiance Round Double Layer Cake, for instance, features a swirl of gold and white sprinkles alongside exquisitely piped flowers. Sam's Club also sells a matching sheet cake version that can be served to guests. Or, if it's a springtime wedding, you could opt for a cookie cake decorated with pastel flowers.

Don't limit yourself to the wedding cake collection, though. A few Chantilly Cream Bar Cakes might be in order, as could the fruit-topped Tres Leches-Style Cake with Strawberry Filling. And who could say no to a Tiramisu Cake? You've got a lot of options at Sam's Club, including customizable cupcakes and cake pops to serve your guests.

Finally, the Chantilly Cream Bar, which is cheaper than Whole Foods' version and just as delicious, runs the added benefit of being unfrosted on the sides. That puts it in the company of other naked cakes that are currently in vogue at weddings.

Great American Cookies

If you associate cookie cakes with some of your earliest childhood memories, you're not alone. Not only are cookie cakes a hit at children's birthday parties (they're less messy than cupcakes), but Great American Cookies dominated malls in the '80s. If you want to invite a hint of nostalgia into your wedding, if you're not a fan of traditional cake, or if you simply want your dessert table to stand out from those at other weddings, cookie cake is your answer.

Compared to regular old cookies, cookie cakes are arguably more fun and more festive. Great American Cookies' catalog includes designs for birthdays, sports games, baby showers, and holidays. You might choose one of these designs for a whimsical touch; for instance, you could serve a boot cake at a country-themed wedding. You may also find what you're looking for in The Valentine's Day and Love category.

If you don't see anything you like, take advantage of the customization option. You can select a shape, a flavor, colors for the border, a message of up to 30 characters, and the colors for your message. The largest customizable cake feeds 18 to 24 people, while the smallest serves eight to 10. As such, you should plan on ordering multiple cakes. Some Redditors have discussed buying one cookie cake for each table, and even decorating them with numbers to demarcate seating arrangements.

Costco

It may be worth investing in a Costco membership, if only to pull off a budget-friendly wedding. You can order wedding flowers here (which can be delivered to the venue), as well as buy booze for the bar, ice, appetizers, and thank you cards. Oh, and cake. Let's not forget the cake.

Redditors commonly recommend Costco for wedding cake because the options are affordable, tasty, and aesthetically pleasing. The Birthday & Special Occasion cake catalog gives you several options, including a few stunning cakes from The Cake Bake Shop and a Rainbow Cake that's well-suited for a Pride wedding.

Still, you should go into the bakery and speak to a staff member because not all the options show up online. In fact, the more affordable and customizable options need to be ordered in person (check out our other tips for ordering custom cakes at Costco before visiting). One Costco bakery employee recommended visiting early in the morning to catch staff before they leave, and they also noted that having the cake scored can help tremendously when it's time to serve.

Many customers lament that Costco's cake slices aren't sold in the food court. We're not saying that you should have multiple weddings to justify multiple wedding cakes, though. Anniversaries are reason enough, as one Redditor happily reported.

Your local farmers market

We've spent a lot of time going over places to buy affordable wedding cakes because let's face it: Weddings are expensive enough already. But we'd be remiss not to mention that if you have the budget, you might find immense satisfaction in supporting a local baker and getting a highly personalized cake to boot. If this sounds like you, don't forget to pay your local farmers market a visit while wedding planning.

No, you're not going to find wedding cakes for sale at a farmers market. But you will meet highly skilled bakers, including those who work at local bakeries and others that work out of their home kitchens as cottage bakers. Strike up a conversation with these vendors to see what they can offer. Then head over to the flower vendors to see if they have any edible flowers for decorating the cake. It may take a village to raise a child, but it also takes a village to put on a wedding. This is your chance to forge connections in one central place!

And who knows? You might even be inspired to serve an alternative treat like pie or pastries for dessert after sampling all the goods at the farmers market. This is your wedding, after all.

Recommended