Pillsbury Grands! Vs Original Cinnamon Rolls: Which Should You Buy?

Add Tasting Table on Google:
Google Discover

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

There's nothing like digging into a rich, sweet cinnamon roll first thing in the morning. Even better if it's served with a hot mug of coffee (especially if you're working with beans from a solid coffee brand). While we love the taste of freshly baked cinnamon rolls made from scratch, the process of making them from start to finish can sometimes be downright overwhelming; in that case, you may want to seek out pre-made cinnamon rolls from the refrigerated section of the grocery store. They make cinnamon roll-baking easy as can be, and you can have a steaming hot dish of them on your table in well under an hour — and they often taste better than pre-made grocery store cinnamon rolls.

Of all the refrigerated cinnamon rolls on the market, Pillsbury is probably the most well-known name out there. But if you're buying from this brand, you'll see two different options: the standard, original cinnamon rolls as well as the cinnamon rolls from the Grands! line. We tried both of them to see how they stack up to one another and hopefully give you a better idea of which variety to pick up the next time you're at the grocery store. Read until the end to find out which we recommend for the most delicious, low-effort cinnamon rolls.

Prices are as of the date of publication and may vary based on region.

Methodology

I picked up both of these cinnamon rolls at my local Stop and Shop and prepared them according to the package instructions. Both packages instructed me to prepare these rolls the same way. I was to heat the oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit and grease the baking pans I intended to use. For the Grands! cinnamon rolls, I used a ceramic baking dish, while I used a metal variety for the original. (This was because I did not have two of either kind of dish.) I oiled both with canola oil.

I baked the original cinnamon rolls for 15 minutes, at which point they looked golden brown on top and ready to come out of the oven. The Grands! cinnamon rolls took 23 minutes to bake completely. I let both cool before applying the icing evenly over each roll. Then, after icing, I tasted each of the rolls, paying close attention to both texture and flavor. I evaluated each variety based on my own preferences for size, shape, and overall impression of the flavor, prioritizing a soft, squishy texture and bold cinnamon flavor. Although these cinnamon roll varieties are very similar, there are enough differences between them for me to prefer one over the other.

Pillsbury Original Cinnamon Rolls

I started by tasting Pillsbury's Original Cinnamon Rolls, which retail at Stop and Shop for $3.99 and come in a tube of eight. The first thing I noticed about these rolls was that they were so small — much smaller than standard for this kind of treat, at least in my personal experience. I also took note of the shape, which lacks the signature "rolled" shape that this pastry usually features. That immediately made me feel like I was getting a product on the cheaper end of the spectrum.

Flavor-wise, these rolls basically just tasted like sugar and cinnamon, without any unexpected flairs of flavor. Although they don't taste as good as homemade cinnamon rolls, they're not bad for a prepared refrigerated product. On the texture front, though, they were much more biscuit-like than I expected, with the same sort of crumbly texture I experienced when trying some of Pillsbury Grands'! biscuit flavors. There's a sort of dryness there that I didn't particularly like, and the lack of a real swirl in the roll made me feel like I was getting a cheap imitation of a cinnamon roll instead of the real thing. The icing on these rolls was sticky and sweet (perhaps too sweet), but it didn't really seem to differ from that of the Grands! cinnamon rolls.

Pillsbury Grands! Cinnamon Rolls

Personally, I like more of a classic cinnamon roll shape. After all, I consider that shape a huge part of what makes a cinnamon roll a real cinnamon roll. That's what you're getting when you snag yourself some Pillsbury Grands! Cinnamon Rolls from your local grocery store. I found these at Stop and Shop for $7.49 for a single tube of five rolls. Taking them out of their tube, I noticed that they offered that special spiral shape, which also gives more nooks and crannies for all of that icing to sink into.

When it comes to texture, I found that these Grands! rolls were a lot richer and more buttery than their original counterparts. The biscuit-like texture is blessedly absent here, and instead, I found that they have the pillowy quality that I associate more with freshly baked homemade cinnamon rolls. The other noticeable difference between the two treats is their size. These rolls were significantly bigger, offering a more substantial snack. However, you only get five in the pack, so you might have to double up if you're feeding a whole crew. When it comes to flavor, though, I didn't notice a huge difference between the two different options. You get that same sweet, cinnamon-forward flavor with even more sweetness from the icing, which tastes basically exactly the same to me as the icing from the original treat.

Final Verdict

There are pros and cons to seeking out each of these cinnamon rolls, but ultimately, I found that the Pillsbury Grands! variety was the better option by my standards. The biggest reason why I liked these cinnamon rolls more is because they had the rolled shape I expect from cinnamon rolls. Additionally, their size was much more on par with what I want from this sort of baked good. And to really bring it home, the texture was just better here, with greater moisture and softness as well as a fluffier texture, making each bite feel more luxurious.

While I can see the appeal of Pillsbury's original cinnamon rolls for when you're feeding a whole crew and want to keep your costs low, I think they're ultimately disappointing if you want that classic cinnamon roll shape and textural experience. Their flavor isn't bad, but their small size and drier, biscuit-like texture make them less appealing. Plus, the absence of a real swirl kind of makes you feel like you're eating a totally different dessert altogether, despite the fact that they taste like cinnamon rolls. If you wanted to elevate either of these cinnamon rolls, though, I'd suggest using a maple icing instead of the standard one provided in the tube.

Recommended