12 New And Returning Costco Bakery Items You Won't Want To Miss This Fall
Fall is full of opportunities to celebrate, and Costco is here to make hosting easier with an impressive lineup of autumnal items in the bakery. Whether you're gathering for brunch or you volunteered to bring dessert — or just want to cozy up with a cup of coffee and a treat — there's something for every occasion. In fact, we found a dozen bakery items you won't want to miss — and they're only here for a limited time.
From seasonal favorites like the can't-miss pumpkin pie to brand new options like maple pecan coffee cake, Costco has plenty of must-buy baked goods for you to add to your shopping cart. We scoured the (virtual) store and dug deep into online reviews to highlight the rolls, cookies, cakes, and pies that Costco fans are loving this fall. Happy shopping, and bon appétit!
Prices are as of the date of publication and may vary based on region.
Shortbread with Belgian Milk Chocolate
A lot of fall bakery items are returning favorites, but these chocolate-studded shortbread cookies are brand new in 2026. "My God are those fantastic, chocolate chip giant shortbread cookies," a Reddit user describes. This buttery twist on chocolate chip cookies uses Belgian milk chocolate for a sweet and creamy addition to the crumbly shortbread.
Purchase a 15-count of Shortbread with Belgian Milk Chocolate for $13.99.
Cookies and Cream Cupcakes with Buttercream Icing
Cookies and cream cupcakes may not be a typical fall dessert, but it's nice to have a little variety on the menu among all the pumpkin, maple, and pecan flavors. These cupcakes feature white cake swirled with cookie pieces, topped with cookies and cream buttercream. "These are maybe the softest cupcakes I've ever had from Costco," says a reviewer on Instagram.
Purchase 12 Cookies and Cream Cupcakes with Buttercream Icing for $8.99.
All Butter Dinner Rolls
Not all seasonal bakery favorites are dessert items. Costco has brought back the beloved All Butter Dinner Rolls just in time for holiday gatherings. Made with real butter, whole milk, and eggs, these golden rolls are ideal for everything from accompanying a cheese board or sopping up gravy to assembling leftover turkey sliders. "My favorite. We buy [them] every Thanksgiving and Christmas!" says an Instagram user.
Purchase 24 All Butter Dinner Rolls for $6.99.
Corn Muffins
While we may never get over the massive overhaul Costco's muffins went through, at least we still have these sweet and crumbly goodies to look forward to every fall. "HANDS DOWN BEST CORN MUFFIN ON THIS EARTH," says a TikTok reviewer. Pro tip: Split the muffins, butter them, then toast them in a pan for a crispy, nutty upgrade.
Purchase eight Kirkland Signature Corn Muffins for $6.99.
Maple Pecan Coffee Cake
It's hard to plan a Thanksgiving morning brunch with so much cooking ahead of you, and Costco has solved the problem with a new Maple Pecan Coffee Cake in the bakery section. "Might be my favorite Costco bakery product yet. It's like a pancake, a doughnut, a cake and a pie had a baby," describes a satisfied customer on Reddit. Another Reddit user recommends warming it up a bit before enjoying.
Purchase the Maple Pecan Coffee Cake for $14.99.
Gooey Cinnamon Rolls
Another must-have brunch centerpiece is back for the fall and winter season. Six massive cinnamon rolls, slathered in cream cheese icing, come in a foil pan that's perfect for popping into the oven to warm the rolls before eating. "They're actually better than some I've baked myself," says a Reddit reviewer, who notes that they're just as good two days after opening.
Purchase a tray of six Kirkland Signature Gooey Cinnamon Rolls for $12.99.
Pumpkin Cheesecake
Fans were thrilled to see Costco's Pumpkin Cheesecake make an early return in late August. Each slice includes a layer of graham cracker crust, pumpkin cheesecake, pumpkin-flavored whipped topping, and graham cracker crumbles. If a 70-ounce cheesecake sounds like too much for you to handle, a fan on Reddit recommends slicing it and freezing the individual slices to enjoy one at a time.
Purchase the Kirkland Signature Pumpkin Cheesecake with Whipped Topping for $21.99.
Pumpkin Bar Cake
The newest addition to Costco's pumpkin-flavored lineup is this fall-themed take on what we named the best cake in Costco's bakery, the chocolate tuxedo mousse cake. The pumpkin bar cake has layers of spiced pumpkin sponge, pumpkin mousse, and airy whipped cream on top. "It's not as rich as their other long cakes. It's not overly sweet either," mentioned a fan on Reddit, who noted that, because it isn't so rich, it is easier to eat a lot.
Purchase Kirkland Signature Pumpkin Bar Cake for $16.99.
Pumpkin Pie
It's hard to beat this fall classic. Costco's pumpkin pie weighs in at 3 pounds, 10 ounces — which the warehouse retailer says will feed 12, though those would be pretty hefty slices after a big holiday meal. "Nearly 4 pounds of pie for under ten bucks is the most reliable joy in retail," says a Reddit user. Those stacks of pies truly mark the beginning of fall, and Costco sells millions of them every fall and winter season.
Purchase the Kirkland Signature Pumpkin Pie for $5.99.
Lattice Apple Pie
Why go through the work of carefully weaving a lattice pie crust when you can pick up a perfectly latticed apple pie on your next Costco run? Our reviewer actually ranked the apple pie above the pumpkin pie in a taste test, preferring the structure of the crust and enjoying the balance of tart and sweet in the filling. Surprisingly, this pie is also vegan. The crust is made with vegetable oil shortening, not butter, so it's completely dairy-free.
Purchase the Kirkland Signature Lattice Apple Pie for $12.99.
Buttermilk Biscuits
Free up oven space by swinging by Costco to pick up buttermilk biscuits for your bread basket. And they're good for more than dunking in cranberry sauce. "Had them for sandwiches, sausage gravy, just with butter and jam, slapped every time," says a satisfied customer on Reddit. Critics note that these biscuits are made with palm oil and palm kernel oil, not butter or shortening.
Purchase 10 Kirkland Signature Buttermilk Biscuits for $6.99.
Pumpkin Streusel Muffins
Craving pumpkin bread with your coffee? Breakfast favorite pumpkin streusel muffins are back in the Costco bakery for the fall season. A tender, spiced pumpkin muffin is topped with a crumble that takes it over the top. "The streusel on top added a nice buttery, cinnamon texture and more of a spicy flavor to these muffins," says an IG reviewer.
Purchase eight Kirkland Signature Pumpkin Streusel Muffins for $6.99.