10 Almond Butter Brands Made With High-Quality Ingredients
We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.
Almond butter has soared in popularity over the past few decades, and not for nothing. Compared to peanut butter, almond butter is valued for its higher vitamin E, calcium, and iron, as well as its lower amount of saturated fat. Plus, because peanut allergies are generally more prevalent than tree nut allergies, eating an almond butter sandwich in a public setting tends to be safer than eating a classic PB&J. Not to mention, almond butter is delicious in smoothies, salad dressings, simmer sauces, and more. Thus, despite almond butter costing more than peanut butter, many folks find it worthwhile to keep a jar on hand.
Nevertheless, as a certified nutrition coach with a background in food studies, I still approach almond butter brands critically. In curating this list, I've defined high-quality ingredients as those that are nourishing, sustainably sourced, and/or flavorful. Almond butters often don't meet all these criteria at once, but a few on this list do.
In this round-up, you won't find almond butters loaded with added sugar and conventional palm oil — typical ingredients you'll find in the unhealthiest peanut butters on store shelves. Rather, you'll find brands that make an effort to source ingredients sustainably, and those that employ superfoods and sprouting techniques.
I've tasted nearly all these brands and read online customer reviews for those I haven't — so these almond butters are guaranteed to be delicious! For more information on methodology, please refer to the end of this article.
Trader Joe's
Trader Joe's offers many kinds of almond butter, several of which a fellow Tasting Table writer has reviewed in their ranking of Trader Joe's nut butters. The store's crunchy, salted almond butter performed particularly well; my colleague described it as not being excessively oily, and they also reported that the salt helped enhance the natural almond flavor spectacularly.
Indeed, when it comes to texture and flavor, I love the variety of offered by Trader Joe's. Both creamy and crunchy versions sold at Trader Joe's come in salted and unsalted varieties, which is great news for those who are limiting sodium. There's even a raw creamy almond butter if you want to get the most bang for your buck nutritionally.
What are the benefits of raw almond butter, you ask? When almonds are roasted, their polyunsaturated fats can potentially oxidize, especially when oven temperatures are high. Oxidation may then translate to the production of cell-damaging free radicals, and possibly even an expedited rate of rancidity for the nut butter in your hand. Furthermore, when manufacturers roast almonds, the nuts' antioxidant activity typically decreases (a double whammy on the oxidation front).
I love the flavor of roasted almond butter, but I also regularly turn to raw almond butter for these reasons. Thankfully, Trader Joe's can stock customers up with both kinds. Each of the almond butters described contain nothing but almonds and salt where applicable.
JEM Organics
Several years ago, my sister-in-law gifted me a variety pack of JEM Organics nut butters for Christmas, and I fell further in love with the brand each time I opened a new jar. No, these nut butters are not cheap. I've been dropping hints ever since that I want the sampler pack again because most of the 6.5-ounce jars of almond butter cost an astounding $14.49. But trust me: One lick of this silky-smooth almond butter, and you'll be adding it to your Christmas list, too.
One of the most unique attributes of this brand is that all the nuts, including the almonds, are sprouted and stone-ground. There's some debate over how effective sprouting nuts truly is, but some suggest that doing so helps increase digestibility and lower phytic acid levels, facilitating more efficient nutrient absorption. Meanwhile, slowly grinding nuts between stones rather than in heavy-duty industrial equipment can help limit heat. This in turn helps preserve nutrients and flavor.
JEM Organics has won five Good Food awards, and the Cashew Cardamom Almond Butter is possibly my favorite almond butter ever. I'm also a fan of the brand's other unique flavors, such as the Cinnamon Maca Almond Butter (maca is a Peruvian ingredient with alleged positive health effects). And of course, I respect that all the ingredients in JEM Organics nut butters are certified organic and that there's absolutely no palm oil.
Artisana Organics
Here's another raw almond butter (this one R.A.W. certified) to add to your shopping list. Artisana Organics' almond butter is packed with nutrients and contains a whopping 7 grams of protein and 4 grams of fiber per serving. This almond butter is very highly rated by customers, beloved for its creamy, slightly coarse texture, as well as its versatility and freshness. It was one of the first almond butters I've tried, and I agree wholeheartedly with the online consensus.
Artisana Organics' almond butter doesn't come in a million different flavors. However, it does come in single-serving snack packs and both 8-pound and 17-pound bulk pails. It's joined by several other wonderful raw nut butters, including cashew, macadamia, and a walnut cashew mix. I particularly love its coconut butter.
This brand's almond butter is packaged in glass jars, which does nothing for its price tag, but certainly benefits the environment. This packaging, combined with the organic certification, means a 14-ounce jar of this almond butter costs $19.15 on Amazon. That hefty price tag is the most common complaint among customers, many of whom nevertheless keep coming back for more. Folks report that you won't have to tediously stir this jar as much as other almond butters, and that this product conveys the natural flavor of almonds extraordinarily well, which can't be said about some of its competitors.
Maisie Jane's
Maisie Jane's is one of the two brands on this list that I've not personally tried, but the reviews are clear: These almond butters, though slightly expensive, are lip-smackingly delicious. Even without salt, the Organic Smooth Almond Butter ($18.35 on Amazon) is a fan favorite for being thick and flavorful. The almonds are fire-roasted, drawing out their naturally sweet demeanor. If you prefer it crunchy, Maisie Jane's has you covered there, too. Smooth and crunchy varieties have conventional counterparts with slightly lower price tags.
Meanwhile, the Italian Dark Chocolate Almond Butter might be your new favorite after-dinner treat. It's moderately sweetened with organic brown rice syrup, but still provides some protein, fiber, and healthy fats. Special-edition nut butters like the Gingerbread Nut Butter are also worth checking out.
The unflavored creamy and crunchy almond butters come in bulk pails, and Maisie Jane's also sells convenient squeeze pouches with multiple servings per pouch (I like to pack similar pouches for road trips and camping adventures). Even better, the almond butter squeeze pouches come in a few flavors you won't find in the brand's jars: In addition to plain, there are sea salt, banana, and salted dark chocolate variations.
This brand wins additional points for being pollinator friendly. In fact, you can buy jars of Maisie Jane's honey online, too, and use them to add a little more sweetness to your sandwiches and toasts.
Once Again
Once Again's almond butter comes in organic and classic jars, both containing lightly roasted almonds and nothing else. The latter is marketed as a "natural" variety and is also sold in 9-pound pails. While it might not be certified organic, Once Again is known for its commitment to maintaining sustainable and ethical supply chains. It's therefore likely to be more eco-friendly than other conventional almond butters on the market.
While both these almond butters are brimming with dreamy flavors, one of my fellow writers reviewed a handful of almond butter brands and named Once Again's Organic Almond Butter as the ultimate winner. They appreciated the gently toasted notes of this product, as well as its richness and balance between creamy and crunchy. In other words, it's an awesome candidate for spreading onto toast.
Once Again's almond butter snack packs, meanwhile, come with a special touch: They contain organic hempseed protein powder. However, it's worth noting that this only boosts the protein content by about a gram, from 7 grams per serving to 8. Also, these snack packs, unlike the brand's jarred versions, contain palm fruit oil and cane sugar. That said, both options are organic, and palm oil does seem to be sustainably and transparently sourced, which is rare.
Spread the Love
Spread the Love is another no-frills brand that doesn't get wrapped up in fancy flavors. Instead, it does the basics right with its peanut and almond butters. The almond butter comes in two styles — a smooth version and a crunchy one — both of which are unsalted. In addition to the standard 16-ounce jars, the smooth almond butter is sold in bulk pails and single-serving packets. None of these almond butters contain anything other than dry roasted California almonds.
Spread the Love is the second brand on this list that I've not personally tried, but online reviews are glowing. One pleased customer noted that the smooth version is comparable to homemade almond butter and that it's excellent by the spoonful. This product's texture is also said to be thin enough that it serves as a wonderful candidate for drizzling over oatmeal bowls, smoothie bowls, and parfaits. The crunchy version similarly gets kudos for its winning texture and flavor.
Even though Spread the Love isn't non-GMO certified, there aren't any GMO products in these almond butters. Palm oil also doesn't make an appearance. Because these almond butters are so simple, they work well in a variety of recipes calling for almond butter. But then again, you might just want to pair them with one of Spread the Love's highly acclaimed artisan jams.
Georgia Grinders
A few jars of Georgia Grinders are on my Black Friday shopping list every year, largely because that's when the seasonal Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Butter is available. But I'm also a fan of Georgia Grinders' almond butters, including the delectable Maple Caramel Almond Butter. This flavor features caramelized and dehydrated maple syrup — it's sweet, but not cloying, and still retains a thick, spreadable texture.
Georgia Grinders offers other kinds of almond butter, too, such as the organic creamy almond butter that's made with blanched almonds and a bit of sea salt. This extra step of removing almond skins may help improve digestibility for some people. If that's not a concern for you, though, the Original Almond Butter may be just what you need; it's also made with roasted California almonds from the San Joaquin Valley and sea salt. Unsalted almond butter and a honey-infused almond butter are also available, as well as resealable pouches with a few servings each.
These almond butters are slow roasted, which typically helps preserve more nutrients due to lower oven temperatures. They're also packaged in glass jars, not plastic, which gives them a leg up when it comes to both environmental and human health.
Fix & Fogg
Fix & Fogg features creative options like its Almond Butter with Everything jar and some high-quality pantry staples like the smooth and crunchy almond butters. That's not to mention all the brand's peanut butters. If you're lucky enough to visit New Zealand, you can get your hands on a wider variety of products, including Smoke & Fire peanut butter (which pairs Mānuka smoke with spicy cayenne) and Banana Caramel peanut butter.
But let's get back to almond butters, several of which we are blessed to have on American soil. Made with dry roasted almonds and New Zealand sea salt, the creamy and crunchy almond butters reveal how premium, well-sourced ingredients can elevate the flavors of a basic condiment. Nevertheless, Almond Butter with Everything is my personal favorite; it combines almonds with flax seeds, hemp seeds, pumpkin seeds, chia, and more, granting it greater nutritional diversity and a stellar texture. If you're a fan of crunchy nut butter, this one is for you.
Beyond producing mouthwatering nut butters, Fix & Fogg is a certified B Corp with several sustainability and humanitarian initiatives. That makes me all the more likely to buy a jar — which is made of glass and tends to get reused quite a bit in my kitchen.
Big Spoon Roasters
Small-batch nut butters from a small town in North Carolina? Sign me up. If I had to buy one nut butter brand for the rest of my life, this would be it. Big Spoon Roasters is one of the best peanut butter brands made with high-quality ingredients, and the wide range of flavors caters to all kinds of consumers and moods.
I recommend starting with Fiji Ginger almond butter. It combines crystallized, sustainably farmed ginger with Jacobsen sea salt and almonds. Or, if you're shopping during the holiday season, don't miss out on a jar of the Sugar Plum Almond & Hazelnut Butter. I've never had a bad experience with Big Spoon Roasters; I've tried nearly every flavor, and I highly recommend ordering a gift set to satiate your curiosity.
So why do these almond butters taste so spectacular? It largely comes down to ingredients. Big Spoon Roasters never uses palm oil, and the company is extremely intentional about where it sources its nuts and mix-ins. The heirloom Mission almonds, for example, are somewhat unique, pollinator-friendly almonds that pack a flavorful punch. Meanwhile, it's no secret that Jacobsen sea salt is a prime ingredient.
Finally, if you're always packing sandwiches for lunch, listen up: Big Spoon Roasters sells a rotating selection of jams from partner businesses. The company even offers a subscription service that sets you up with a curated almond butter-and-jam pairing every two months. That's what I call thoughtful.
Kirkland Signature
Because I'm not a millionaire, I appreciate the affordability of Kirkland Signature's nut butters. Costco's peanut butter may get most of the attention — which I agree it deserves — but the store's Kirkland Signature almond butter is another terrific product that you should never leave Costco without. A 27-ounce jar of this creamy, roasted almond butter costs less than $10, making it more affordable per ounce than any other brand on this list.
I especially enjoy dark, roasted flavors of this almond butter during the fall and winter, when I regularly use it to top bowls of oatmeal and make salad dressings. There's nothing other than almonds in this product, which makes it great for cooking; you don't have to worry about excess salt or flavorings disrupting the flavors of a dish. Also, it's made in a peanut-free facility if that's a concern for you.
The one caveat I'll add to this recommendation is that oil in this almond butter tends to separate more easily than in some other brands. I've found that stirring the jar immediately upon opening it and then storing it upside down in the refrigerator works wonders.
Methodology
In curating this list, I drew upon my past experience tasting almond butters from myriad brands, while simultaneously examining their labels as a certified nutrition coach. In order to be featured, each brand needed to make its almond butters with high-quality ingredients — which I took to mean ones that are nourishing, sustainably sourced, or flavorful (of course, these qualities often overlap). For the two brands on this list that I've not personally tried, I dove into customer reviews.
I don't usually refer to any one ingredient as bad, but high amounts of added sugar and the use of palm oil were red flags for me in this review. On the other hand, I especially favored brands with eco-friendly initiatives. Growing almond trees can be extremely taxing on the environment, and some brands go out of their way to work with farms that implement sustainability measures. Cost, though sometimes noted, had no determination in whether a brand was featured.