Better Than Betty: The Best Store-Bought Pie Crust Mix Delivers A Buttery, Southern-Style Finish

Add Tasting Table on Google:
Google Discover

Making pie dough from scratch is no easy feat, but premade pie crusts often lack the homemade taste and texture we seek. Fortunately, store-bought pie crust mixes are typically made with simple ingredients, allow you to add your own butter, and turn out flakier and more tender than crumbly, dried out, or soggy premade crusts. We tasted 5 store-bought pie crust mixes to see how different offerings stack up, and landed on King Arthur Baking Company as the best of the bunch.

While famous cake and dough mix companies like Betty Crocker made the list, none compared to the pie crust mix from King Arthur. This mix required adding butter which, apart from improving the flavor, also made the dough very easy to work with. The dough was nice and thick, aiding in the transfer to a baking dish. Plus, the water content in butter steams the dough as it bakes, making for an extra flakey texture.

The buttery, toasty aroma that emanated from the oven was heavenly and translated to a beautifully golden-brown crust that was, per our reviewer, "airy, flaky, and buttery." Added butter isn't unique to King Arthur's pie crust mix, but the inclusion of buttermilk was compared to the other options tested. A famous ingredient in Southern-style biscuits, the "hint of buttermilk" imparted a subtle tanginess that balanced the savory toasted butter flavor perfectly, launching King Arthur Baking Company into first place in this ranking.

King Arthur pie crust mix is a hit with most customers

The King Arthur website boasts plenty of 5-star reviews that asserted the pie crust mix "turned out just like homemade." Most reviews raved about how easy the pie crust comes together with the help of straightforward instructions. "Easy and turned out just like my mom's pie crust," one reviewer raved. Reviewers thought the crust was as flakey and buttery as can be. In fact, one customer added, "I've baked by scratch for years. And I can say without any hesitation, I won't use anything but this pie crust from now on!"

That isn't to say that this pie crust mix didn't have some detractors, however. There were a few folks who were disappointed with how it turned out. A few one and two-star reviews claimed that the dough was hard to work with and, as one reviewer put it, "made a very tough crust once baked." Others noted that their crust results were dry, crumbly, or overly salty.

Should you trust the positive reviews (as well as our own), you can upgrade your next pie crust with a spice blend. Even a pinch of cinnamon powder is enough to infuse a world of flavor, tasting delicious with fall flavors like apple and pumpkin. Of course, you can further expedite your pie recipe with canned pie filling — we've got a ranking of cherry pie fillings to explore. Whichever flavor you choose to enhance your King Arthur pie crust mix, there are plenty of ways to improve upon canned pie filling, too.

Recommended