8 Gluten-Free Cake Mixes, Ranked Worst To Best
If you've tried bad gluten-free cakes in the past like I have, you've likely worried that every gluten-free boxed cake mix is a waste of time and money. But after my wheat allergy flared up again recently, I found myself wanting to try — and then rank — gluten-free cake mixes to find out if any are worth it. Luckily, a gluten-free cake that tastes like a standard cake is actually within reach and affordable.
Now, those of us who have to eat gluten-free are looking for what anyone else is in a mix: A cake that tastes good even without loading it up with frosting. I want a gluten-free cake to be soft and fluffy rather than dry, dense, or grainy, without compromising on the flavor. Granted, just looking at the ingredient list sometimes tells you what to expect; for instance, ones made with almond flour are likely to be grainy, but could still rank highly if they weren't too dense and have good flavor overall.
While I began this taste test worried I was looking for a unicorn, after trying multiple gluten-free cake mixes? I actually ended up finding several that provide an experience that's just as nice as a wheat-flour-based cake. If you don't have the patience to try box after box of cake mixes yourself, keep reading to see how I ranked these 8 gluten-free cake mixes.
8. Aldi gluten-free yellow cake mix
I love that Aldi has many gluten-free items available, but the Aldi gluten-free yellow cake mix is definitely a pass. It only makes 12 cupcakes, but it was the cheapest on the list and tasted like it. Neither the flavor nor the texture impressed me in the least, and I'm not sure it could be improved upon with extra ingredients or frosting like some of the others.
The ingredient list looks promising enough, as it's made with quality ingredients, like cane sugar, rice flour, tapioca starch, a rice-starch-based emulsifier, and xanthan gum to help with structure. After adding the additional ingredients to the mix, you end up with a batter that's easy to spoon into cupcake liners without making a mess. Unfortunately, being easy to put into cupcake liners is the only positive thing about this mix.
The first hint that the texture wasn't going to be great was how many of the tops crumbled when I tried to move them out of the pan. The texture is thankfully not grainy, but they're very dry, with a mouthfeel that's not what you want in a cake. The worst part, though, was the flavor. Despite being in a bag inside the box, the cupcakes tasted like a box. Plus, there was an aftertaste that I associate with having too much baking powder, so it comes in last.
7. Simple Mills almond flour chocolate muffin & cake baking mix
The only reason the Simple Mills almond flour chocolate muffin & cake baking mix didn't end up last on my list was because I think it could be improved with some chocolate chips or frosting, unlike the Aldi option. It's fairly expensive for a boxed mix, as well, so I really can't recommend this one at all.
While it has an impressively simple ingredient list, being made with almond flour, coconut flour, and coconut sugar makes it very grainy (I personally think almond flour is better for making gluten-free bread crumbs than cake). Some of the other ingredients are arrowroot and cocoa, but the chocolate sadly isn't pulling up the rear with a good flavor for this cake.
My first impression when I took my first bite was that it tastes more bitter than chocolatey. As I expected from the ingredient list, it was also very grainy. In fact, it's so grainy that I found myself tearing down some of the grains left in my mouth with my front teeth. Neither the texture nor the flavor will inspire another purchase.
6. Simple Mills almond flour vanilla cupcake & cake baking mix
The Simple Mills almond flour vanilla cupcake & cake baking mix is an improvement over the chocolate version, but not enough to rank higher. The price I paid was especially high, considering the mix only makes 12 cupcakes. Additionally, the texture and flavor sadly make it seem like a consolation prize for someone who has no other choice.
Like Simple Mills' chocolate cake, the vanilla one has a simple ingredient list that might appeal to someone with specific allergies. However, the almond flour, coconut sugar, and coconut flour do make it very grainy. Arrowroot is a smooth ingredient, but it doesn't help make the texture any better. While the mix has vanilla beans in it, you also have to add a tablespoon of your own vanilla. Once you're done, you're left with batter that's runny and unappealingly brown.
The ingredients and brown batter didn't inspire a lot of flavor hope, and it unfortunately didn't surprise me by being good. Overall, it's dense, extremely grainy, and very eggy. The vanilla flavor doesn't really come through strongly, and I feel like this might be a passable option if you're seeking really simple whole ingredients. It might also work as a base for a cake like carrot cake that already has lots of texture.
5. Miss Jones Baking Company gluten-free classic yellow vanilla cake mix
While Miss Jones Baking Company gluten-free classic yellow vanilla cake mix is loads better than the Aldi and Simple Mills offerings, it's more forgettable than cakes I ranked higher. However, it's the first one on the list you wouldn't know was gluten-free unless someone told you. Interestingly, it came in at number eight on our list of 12 best boxed yellow cake mixes, ranking above some yellow cake mixes with gluten. It only ranks at number five here because it doesn't taste quite as special as some of the others, and because of its aftertaste.
The mix includes cane sugar, a gluten-free flour blend with two kinds of rice flour (sweet white and brown), two types of starch (potato and tapioca), as well as sorghum flour and xanthan gum. Plus, it contains cream of tartar. Once prepared, the batter has the perfect consistency for scooping into cupcake liners without making a mess.
Basically, it's a cake that tastes like cake, and also has a hint of sweet vanilla. The texture is on point, too, as it's not remotely grainy. However, it didn't rank higher because I won't remember how it tastes in five minutes. Plus, the cream of tartar aftertaste is much better in Snickerdoodles.
4. Pillsbury gluten-free Funfetti cake mix
Confetti cake mixes are always a fun treat, and when we ranked 7 confetti boxed cake mixes, the regular Pillsbury Funfetti cake came in first. However, this one came in last, so I wasn't feeling very hopeful to try it. But I thought the Pillsbury gluten-free Funfetti cake mix was barely distinguishable from one with gluten. I'd never know it was gluten-free unless you told me, which is why it ranks fourth on this list.
This cake contains normal ingredients for gluten-free cakes, like sugar, rice flour, potato starch, and tapioca starch. Plus, there are less-expected ingredients like pea fiber, cellulose, canola oil, and canola lecithin. I do want to note that the confetti pieces contain ingredients that might cause you to pause, like palm and palm kernel oil, as well as five different artificial colors, but it makes a very thick batter once prepared.
I didn't find this gluten-free cake to be gummy or dense at all. It's a little grainy, but you can imagine it's sugar crystals, and it has a nice vanilla buttery flavor. The only negatives are that it's eggy and there's a slight artificial color aftertaste from the Funfetti pieces, which slightly hurt its ranking. Besides that, it tastes like a classic confetti-style cake.
3. Pillsbury gluten-free classic yellow premium cake mix
Pillsbury gluten-free yellow cake mix is another one that I wouldn't be able to tell is gluten-free without someone telling me. Not only does it have name recognition going for it, but it's really quite good. I found it available at Walmart, and it's an easy grab if you want a familiar brand that has a yummy flavor and great texture.
The ingredient list starts out fairly normal for a gluten-free cake mix, with ingredients like sugar, rice flour, potato starch, tapioca starch, and xanthan gum. However, it also has some more unusual ingredients like pea fiber, cellulose, and canola lecithin. One negative, though, is that, instead of using natural ingredients for coloring it includes two types of artificial colors.
This mix yields a very thick batter, and has a classic birthday cake flavor, which is buttery and vanilla. It's not dense and the graininess isn't much different than having a sugary crunch. I had a difficult time choosing between this and the Pillsbury Funfetti one because they're similar. However, this one doesn't taste as eggy and has more of a buttery flavor that I like a lot. The only negative was that I can taste the artificial flavors slightly, but it's not enough to knock it below third.
2. King Arthur Baking Company gluten-free classic yellow cake mix
The top two list entries were indistinguishable from ordinary boxed cake mixes to me. In fact, I feel they're at the top of what I've experienced from any boxed cake mixes. King Arthur is often my go-to for baking information, as it's written several indispensable baking cookbooks. So, I wasn't surprised that the company has mastered gluten-free baking mixes. I was able to find King Arthur Baking Company gluten-free yellow cake mix locally at Whole Foods and it's a more expensive mix. But those extra dollars are well worth the amazing quality of this mix.
The ingredient list includes rice flour, tapioca starch, and a rice-starch-based emulsifier as main ingredients, with xanthan gum for structure. Additionally, the instructions had me adding 8 tablespoons of butter, 2 tablespoons of vegetable oil, four eggs, and ⅔ cup milk in a very specific order.
While it was a little more complicated to make than the others, it came out with an absolutely perfect texture –- not too dense and not grainy at all. The flavor is exactly what you think about when you think of a yellow cake. It's a little eggy, which is why it didn't come in first, but the cake is a standout to me. I shared it with several friends and family members who don't normally eat gluten-free, as well as one friend who does, and everyone loved it.
1. King Arthur Baking Company gluten-free chocolate cake mix
Finally, we have the best cake on the list: the King Arthur Baking Company gluten-free chocolate cake mix. I was excited to try it since it came in at the number two spot on our list of 13 chocolate cake mixes, beating out a lot of regular chocolate cake mixes. It was elusive, but I was finally able to locate it at Natural Grocers — and the chase was worth it, because this gluten-free boxed cake mix wowed me from the first bite.
This mix makes 24 delightful gluten-free chocolate cupcakes. The ingredient list is complex, but it stars delicious cocoa and cane sugar. Other main ingredients include rice flour, tapioca starch, and a rice-starch-based emulsifier. Plus, xanthan gum provides structure. The batter was very runny and included four eggs, but it doesn't taste eggy at all.
After trying this, I completely understand how it beat out regular chocolate cake mixes in a taste test. You absolutely can't tell this is a gluten-free cake. The chocolate is like eating a good chocolate bar and isn't bitter at all. The cake isn't remotely grainy either, and stands alone beautifully even without frosting. It had me going "mmm" from the first bite. Everyone I shared it with loved it, too, so maybe I wasn't searching for a complete unicorn after all.
Methodology
For this, I purchased eight gluten-free cake mixes. Each mix made a different amount of batter, so I decided to turn them into cupcakes rather than make full-sized cakes. I followed the instructions exactly to get standard results, using fresh eggs, unsalted sweet cream butter, whole milk, and vanilla extract, and opted for vegetable oil as my neutral oil to avoid a strong aftertaste. I also used a different-colored cupcake liner for each mix so I wouldn't get them mixed up when doing taste comparisons.
I wanted to avoid one of the common gluten-free baking mistakes by letting the wet mix sit too long, so I was sure to get the cupcakes in the oven as quickly as possible. While some gluten-free doughs become less grainy when you let them sit and moisturize, Robyn's Gluten-Free Baking Courses noted you'll lose the spring in your cake if you let gluten-free cake batter sit too long after liquid has activated the baking soda in the mix.
Taste and texture were the biggest things I was looking for, but I included some main ingredients in my reviews, as well, because they can tell you a little about what to expect from the flavor and texture. The more the cake tasted like a regular cake and had a soft texture like a regular cake, the higher it rated. Having a negative aftertaste or being grainy always brought the ranking down.