8 Store-Bought Frozen Pies To Add To Your Cart This Fall

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

Fall is upon us, and that means it's time to make room for the season's coziest desserts. As the weather gets chillier, a sweet, oven-baked pie is the perfect way to round off a meal, and there are plenty of classic fall flavors to consider. A homemade pie is, of course, the gold standard, but there isn't always time to whip up a dessert from scratch, and that's where the freezer aisle comes in. Store-bought frozen pies make it easy to bring a warm, seasonal dessert to the table without spending hours rolling dough and preparing fillings, and many of these premade options give from-scratch versions a run for their money.

Frozen pies can vary pretty dramatically in terms of flavor, texture, and overall quality, so we set out to compile a list of standout products that are actually worth adding to your cart. By scouring online reviews, we picked out eight customer favorites that deliver flaky crusts, generous fillings, and a welcomed dose of comforting fall flavor. So, if you're in the market for convenient seasonal sweet treats, these store-bought pies are most definitely worthy of a spot in your freezer.

Marie Callender's offers a wide selection of sweet frozen pies, with options ranging from fruity and zesty to creamy and chocolatey. However, there's one product that's especially fitting for the fall table — the iconic Dutch Apple Pie. This is one of two frozen apple pies sold by the brand, and while the classic lattice version is topped with strips of traditional flaky crust, the Dutch Apple Pie is finished with a sweeter, crumblier streusel-style topping. This makes everything look and taste that bit more indulgent, giving the pie a rustic, ultra-comforting feel.

When we ranked five popular store-bought apple pies, the Marie Callender's Dutch Apple Pie was a clear winner. Our taste tester noted the pleasant textural contrast between the crunchy streusel and tender, cinnamon-spiked fruit, as well as the chunkiness of the apples, and customers agree that this pie is a winner. On the Walmart website, one shopper wrote, "I am literally addicted to this pie!! I think it's almost as good as homemade," while another added, "The crust alone is worth talking about, perfectly baked, with that crumb topping that just takes it to another level."

Another top pick in the Marie Callender's lineup is the frozen Pumpkin Pie. This dessert takes a classic approach, with a flaky, crimped crust and a custardy, warmly spiced pumpkin filling. It's a simple case of popping the pie straight into the oven, then letting it cool a little before slicing. And, much like the homemade version, the pie will go down a treat served with generous swirls of whipped cream.

This shortcut pumpkin pie has received thousands of five-star reviews on the Walmart website, with customers praising the rich, creamy texture of the filling and crunchiness of the crust. Many say it's equally delicious served warm or cold, and that the level of spice is just right, so this really is a fantastic option if you don't have time to craft a pie from scratch but still want that homemade taste. One fan put it simply in their review, stating, "This pumpkin pie is outta this world delicious!" before noting that "the crust is the star." Another shopper talked of searching high and low for the ultimate store-bought pumpkin pie, commenting, "I found this one and I couldn't be happier unless I made it myself!"

Pecan pie has long been a festive favorite, and you can absolutely enjoy that signature sweet, nutty flavor without spending hours in the kitchen. The Edwards Georgia Style Pecan Pie consistently impresses customers with its homestyle taste, and the prep couldn't be simpler. This dessert can either be thawed and enjoyed cold, or warmed in the oven for a cozier experience (especially when you add a scoop of vanilla ice cream).

Edwards is well known for its selection of delicious frozen pies. When we ranked seven of the brand's products, the Georgia Style Pecan Pie earned a very respectable second place, beaten only by the (slightly less fall-coded) Lemon Crème Pie. The pecans on this pie are caramelized, which means they pack a serious crunch while adding an extra layer of sweetness. And the nuts contrast beautifully with the gooey, buttery filling and melt-in-the-mouth crust. 

The customer feedback is overwhelmingly positive here, too. "After tasting these, I'll never buy a bakery made pecan pie. These are delicious! They don't disappoint," shared one reviewer on the Walmart website. A second shopper shared the sentiment, writing, "This is absolutely the best pecan pie I've ever eaten," and confirming that it tasted "just like what mom used to make!"

If you're looking to keep your fall dessert gluten-free, this Apple Cranberry Nut Pie by The Maine Pie Co. is an excellent choice. It takes the familiar fan-favorite apple pie and gives it a nutty, sweet-tart upgrade, with cranberries, golden raisins, and pecans making the filling particularly flavorful and festive. The crust features real butter and a blend of rice flours, tapioca starch, and potato starch, and it delivers plenty of golden, flaky richness without the need for gluten.

The reviews for this pie say it all. On the Sprouts Farmers Market website, one happy customer shared their thoughts. "Absolutely loved this scrumptious gluten free pie. It's the perfect balance between sweet and slightly tart and the gluten free crust was delicious, too," they gushed, noting that guests would never know the pie was gluten-free. In a separate review, a shopper highlighted the delicious combination of flavors, saying they "loved every bite" and would happily purchase the dessert again.

Sweet potato is another pie filling we see frequently come fall, and while the resulting dessert bears many similarities to pumpkin pie, sweet potato brings a naturally sweeter taste and denser consistency. The Sara Lee Sweet Potato Pie really nails this hearty, indulgent approach, with its velvety filling and crisp, buttery crust.

A taste tester from our sister site, Mashed, rated this pie highly. In a ranking of 11 store-bought frozen pies, which covered a variety of flavors, the Sara Lee Sweet Potato Pie took second place. The dessert was praised for its balanced, subtly spiced flavor, which apparently pairs brilliantly with a swirl of whipped cream. Other shoppers have mentioned the irresistibly creamy consistency of the filling, and the satisfying combination of sweet and savory notes. Plus, the pie has received dozens of five-star reviews on the Influenster website, further cementing its reputation as a reliable crowd-pleaser.

You can rely on Marie Callender's to deliver classic, comforting flavors in a convenient frozen format, and this Southern Pecan Pie is no exception. This is another thaw-and-slice wonder, with no baking required, though you can pop it in the oven if you prefer to serve your pecan pie warm. There's an "extra-flaky" crust, as the brand puts it, a smooth, caramel-like filling, and a generous layer of those all-important crunchy, toasty pecan pieces.

This store-bought Southern staple has countless fans, as confirmed by a sea of rave reviews on the Marie Callender's website. "Very Good! Tastes just like your mother made it. Maybe even better," was the verdict from one customer, while another five-star review read, "I just tried this Pecan pie today. It is the best I've ever eaten in my entire 62 years of living!" The filling has been described as "rich, sweet, and packed with pecans," while the crust is crisp and buttery. Even one self-proclaimed pecan pie skeptic was won over by the Marie Callender's version, having admitted that it tasted fantastic served warm.

While this fuss-free pecan pie is great enjoyed as is, you can easily amp up the indulgence with a scoop of ice cream or dollop of whipped cream. Or, try transforming the pie into a decadent trifle, by chopping it up and layering the pieces with creamy mascarpone and whipped topping.

When it comes to pumpkin pie, The Village PieMaker is another brand that gets it right. Made with zero artificial preservatives or trans fats, this handmade pie is a wholesome pick with heaps of sweet, warming flavor. Available at major chains like Wegmans, Meijer, and Vons, the pie comes frozen and ready to bake, though it might just have your guests thinking it was homemade.

It's worth noting that this pie costs around twice as much per ounce than the Marie Callender's version. However, the general consensus amongst online reviewers is that The Village PieMaker Pumpkin Pie punches well above its weight for a frozen dessert. For example, on the Wegmans website, a customer called the product "far superior to other grocery store pumpkin pies, and frankly better than many restaurant pumpkin pies," adding that it was "well worth the money." A second shopper was just as complimentary, describing how the pie had been a major hit at Thanksgiving dinner, even amongst those who don't typically enjoy pumpkin pie. 

Banquet's single-serve apple pies remove the hassle of cutting perfect slices and dealing with leftovers, and their miniature size makes them undeniably charming. These are ideal for a solo night in, or for serving individual desserts at your next dinner party. You can even cook the pies in the microwave for the ultimate convenience, all without sacrificing that moreish flaky crust.

Reviewers say the Banquet Apple Pie offers excellent value for money and heaps of cozy, fruity flavor. On the Walmart website, a satisfied shopper wrote, "I'm not kidding when I say that the frozen apple pie tasted just like the ones my grandmother made for dessert on Sundays——sooooooo good." Others suggested dressing the pies up with ice cream or even slices of cheese for an elevated, sweet and salty finish. One particularly enthusiastic customer, who proclaimed that "you cannot go wrong with these," recommended adding a large dollop of whipped cream and drizzle of caramel.

To identify the best autumnal pies in the freezer aisle, we consulted online feedback from real customers. The review sections of grocery store websites, such as Walmart, Wegmans, and Sprouts, served as valuable sources, as did the opinions of other reputable food publishers. This final selection showcases eight products that consistently receive praise for their flavor, texture, and value, making them reliable picks for a hassle-free fall dessert.