Review: Wendy's New Holiday Frosty Doesn't Fall Into The Same Trap As Other Chains' Drinks
I've written before about my longtime love of Wendy's and my familiarity with its menu, having grown up in Columbus, Ohio, where the fast food chain was founded. That hometown connection also came in handy when I taste-tested and ranked Wendy's chicken menu items. However, the Frosty, despite being one of Wendy's most recognizable menu staples, is something I haven't explored quite as extensively. I remember the original chocolate version from my high school days, when its primary purpose in my life was serving as a convenient dipping sauce for french fries. Wendy's has expanded its lineup considerably since then, though, introducing a variety of Frosty flavors.
As we move into the holiday season, I heard that Wendy's was offering a special "festive" Peppermint Brownie Frosty Fusion and I got excited. I do love an excuse to indulge while gift shopping, and winter flavors like mint and cocoa always pique my interest. I was invited to try the limited-edition Frosty at a special tasting event in New York, and I'm thrilled to say that I'll be moving the Frosty back into my treat rotation — even though my high school years are far behind me.
Some recommendations are based on firsthand impressions of promotional materials and products provided by the manufacturer. Prices are as of the date of publication and may vary based on region.
Methodology
Wendy's brought a little nostalgia to New York's Flatiron District, creating a pop-up solarium inspired by the sunrooms found in its 1980s- and 90s-style restaurants. On a cold but sunny November day, writers were invited to step inside the throwback space and taste-test the chain's newest Frosty flavor. We were also invited to try the limited-edition Holiday Box, which comes with a Dave's Double cheeseburger, a small order of french fries, and a surprise knit hat. I decided to save that for later, though, opting to sample the new Frosty first so the flavors of the burger and fries wouldn't influence my first impression.
Technically, there are two holiday Frosty flavors: the Peppermint Frosty Swirl and the Peppermint Brownie Frosty Fusion. However, I was only able to taste the brownie version at this event. I was told they are essentially the same Frosty, but one adds brownie bits along with the peppermint syrup. As I tasted the Frosty, I evaluated it on presentation (including the container and the Frosty itself), temperature, and overall taste.
Taste Test
I'm really not a fan of overly sweet desserts that can pop up on seasonal menus, like Chick-fil-A's fall lineup. I tend to find them overwhelming after a meal and made for younger palates in search of a sugar high. I'm pleased to say that the Peppermint Brownie Frosty Fusion, despite having the potential to veer in that direction, was pleasantly smooth, and I definitely enjoyed it as a kickoff to the holiday season.
The base of the Frosty I tried was vanilla frozen dairy. The lighter-colored vanilla made the red peppermint syrup swirl really pop, along with the chocolatey brownie bits — which were small enough to eat in one bite, but large enough to notice. My first taste reminded me of a traditional mint chocolate chip ice cream, or a Girl Scout cookie Thin Mint that had been in the freezer. The peppermint was crisp and fresh, without lingering on my taste buds, and the brownie bites were surprisingly soft and fudgy. The ice cream was cold, but not harsh, and the Frosty came in a branded cup. You can customize this Frosty to have the chocolate base rather than the vanilla, but personally, I thought the milder ice cream helped support the chocolate and mint flavors to shine.
Final Thoughts
While I prefer to have frozen desserts in warmer weather, I could see myself enjoying the Peppermint Brownie Frosty Fusion as part of a festive shopping day. This treat looks like a peppermint stick with brownie bits wrapped in and around it, which is a fun visual.
I ultimately didn't finish the full cup (even though it was a small one) because I wanted to have some food for lunch. But I definitely could have, since it didn't make my mouth feel full of sugar. I will note that some of the swirl landed closer to the bottom of the cup, so I really had to dig down to get the full flavor effect, and I spent some time mixing it all together myself. If, like me, you prefer a less intense bite, you may actually appreciate that the toppings aren't as heavily mixed into the Frosty. Overall, I'd have no hesitation recommending this seasonal dessert to anyone who enjoys the traditional Frosty but wants the holiday twist. It's also worth a try for fans of Wendy's Oreo brownie Frosty, a chocolate-forward treat that has earned its own following.
Price/Nutrition/Availability
The new Peppermint Brownie Frosty Fusion is available at Wendy's locations nationwide, just in time for the holiday season. The Peppermint Brownie Frosty Fusion starts at $4.19, and you can add extra brownie pieces for an additional $1.20.
A small Peppermint Brownie Frosty Fusion, loaded with peppermint swirl sauce and brownie bits, has 500 calories, 22 grams of fat, and 9 grams of protein. The ingredients include milk, cocoa, sugar, and corn syrup, along with additional ingredients used in the brownie pieces and peppermint sauce to deliver those familiar sweet, seasonal flavors.
If you'd rather skip the brownie, Wendy's small Peppermint Frosty Swirl has 450 calories, 20 grams of fat, and 8 grams of protein. It starts at $2.99, making it a less expensive way to get your peppermint fix during the holidays. You can also add extra peppermint sauce for approximately 50 cents to either Frosty.