Every Dave's Hot Chicken Heat Level, Ranked
There's no mystery regarding what Dave's Hot Chicken is famous for selling (hint: It's not bland beef). Of course, if your only knowledge of the spicy fried chicken chain comes from its very forthright name, you might not know how hot the chicken actually is from Dave's. In fact, with seven different heat levels available to customers, ranging from Not Hot to the terrifyingly-named Reaper, even regular patrons may be wondering how the various spice levels stack up against each other.
To properly compare Dave's Hot Chicken heat options — which don't appear to be tossed in a sauce but are instead covered in a spice blend rub of sorts — I ventured to the nearest location and ordered a tender at every available heat level. I then tried each one in ascending order, starting with the Not Hot plain chicken tender. While the flavor profile (i.e., whether it tasted good) of each was a key factor, I largely focused on whether a heat level's spiciness was a boon or detriment to the eating experience. In most cases, I wanted the burn to be noticeable enough that it made a physical impact without overshadowing the taste.
After trying the seven spice levels offered by Dave's Hot Chicken as of this writing, I can say some (but not all) options are tremendously delicious. Keep reading to see where the various spicy options from Dave's Hot Chicken ranked.
7. Reaper
I'm a big fan of spicy foods, so I was excited to try every Dave's heat level, including Reaper. Presumably named for the Carolina reaper, which was once the hottest pepper in the world, I assumed the store's digital disclaimer (which absolves Dave's Hot Chicken of responsibility for any personal pain and suffering endured after eating the Reaper flavor) was merely a marketing gimmick. But after nearly 30 minutes of profuse sweating and chugging milk trying to stave off the relentless burn scorching my mouth? I wasn't laughing — and I knew which heat level belonged at the bottom.
If a spicy food results in nothing beyond searing agony, what's the point? I greatly enjoy hot foods and will never shy away from a spicy dish, but there has to be some redeeming culinary qualities surrounding the heat. That simply wasn't the case with the Reaper, which scorched my mouth and throat within moments of ingesting it, and continued to punish me for far too long after it was down my esophagus.
It may not have impacted me as much as my wife, who conducted the taste test with me ... and literally spent an hour on the floor crying after trying the tiniest Reaper bite possible. But I can't say I enjoyed anything about the Reaper, so it comes in last place among heat levels (and remains a Dave's Hot Chicken item to skip rather than order).
6. Lite Mild
To be completely honest, I might have been more disappointed by the Lite Mild tender than any other heat level. My expectations weren't sky-high, of course, given a hot chicken chain is generally less likely to nail the less-spiced varieties. So while it's an admittedly tasty tender — side note: Literally every piece of chicken I ordered was moist and toothsome — I still wanted just a bit more beyond the absolute lack of heat I experienced with the Lite Mild level.
Now, if you're particularly sensitive to spicy foods but don't want a plain tender from Dave's Hot Chicken, this might be a good option. I didn't dislike it by any means, and certainly enjoyed the very subtle paprika-and-chili-powder-centric heat from the rub (Dave's doesn't appear to disclose the ingredients in its heat levels, so I'm going off my own guesses).
Yet I can't help but wonder if the Lite Mild should even exist in the first place. After all, the super-slight nudge of heat on the back end is nearly indecipherable from the standard mild option. It may be the first heat level I enjoyed, but the lack of distinctiveness keeps it near the bottom given the better options above it.
5. Not Hot
Of the bottom three heat levels, I enjoyed the Not Hot plain chicken tender the most, hence its ranking. Like I previously noted, Dave's sells a delectable piece of poultry, and with no physical torture to endure with this one (à la the Reaper), I was plenty pleased from start to finish. It's the most straightforward chicken finger-esque option on the Dave's menu, and presumably appeals to younger diners. But, well ... it's the Not Hot option at an explicitly hot chicken restaurant, so it can't climb higher than fifth place.
I don't have many thoughts about this Dave's Hot Chicken heat level, because there's no heat to analyze. Even if I'm willing to rank it above the Lite Mild option — because, unlike that one, this doesn't pretend to have a nearly non-existent spiciness — the fact remains that I could have gone anywhere for something akin to the Not Hot tender.
4. Mild
If I were ranking the heat levels purely by flavor profile, the Mild option might take the cake. It contains an incredibly tasty spice blend, and a few moments after you take a bite, a slight but noticeable warming rolls across the tongue as expected. However, that late-arriving heat isn't nearly as intense as I prefer, even for a mild option, which is why it can't crack the top three.
It might be unfair to critique a chicken tender labeled as "mild" for not being bolder in the spice department. But what can I say? I didn't think this would be so completely mild, with absolutely no desire to go wild on customers' mouths. I will say it's tremendously good when it's been dipped in the unique Dave's sauce. Then again, I only evaluated the heat levels sans dipping sauce, so that couldn't help elevate this above the middle of the rankings.
3. Extra Hot
The Extra Hot heat level was very similar to the standard Hot option in my estimation, but my wife's experience illustrated a clear distinction exists between levels. While I was enjoying the genuinely burning aftertaste that overtook my entire mouth (as I did with the regular Hot option before this), my wife ran to the fridge a minute after eating it to pour a fresh glass of milk while whimpering.
Now, I certainly felt the thunderous arrival of barely tolerable heat throughout my mouth soon afterward, as well, which is why it ranks above most other heat levels. But as I mentioned before, it really wasn't any different from the regular Hot heat level, which was a little bit of a letdown. I didn't need it to rival the Reaper's scorched Earth demeanor or shatter the Scoville scale. But I still wish there had been more of an uptick in genuine heat from Hot to better bridge the gap on the way up to Reaper.
As it stands, the Extra Hot option is a decent flavor that does the burning-my-mouth job quite well. But considering it was almost identical to the step below on the heat ladder, it loses some points overall and comes in third.
2. Medium
If it seems like I'm being a hypocrite for placing a not-super-painful-or-burning heat level in second place on this list, well, you're not necessarily wrong. But while I've undoubtedly penalized other flavors for that very characteristic, there wasn't a complete lack of spiciness with the Medium level — it just wasn't legitimately painful like the Hot and higher options. I actually thought it was fun to feel the burn without the actual burn while chomping on a chicken tender as good as this one taste-wise, so it earned the silver medal in these rankings.
Of course, even if I'd consider the Medium option nearly perfect as a Dave's order for any time of day, I still can't place a heat level that doesn't leave me in any physical pain in first place. It's plenty good enough to take second, but there's a Dave's Hot Chicken level that topped Medium in the end.
1. Hot
The classic option that presumably started it all, there's no better heat level for your Dave's Hot Chicken order than the Hot option. The entire eating experience with this one was precisely what I would want from a hot chicken joint, with a delicious spice blend that led to a genuinely painful-yet-pleasant burning throughout my mouth. The burn lingered for maybe 10 or so minutes after I finished eating, which was exactly what I was hoping for from the first-place heat level.
Now, if I had one quibble with this, it's that the jump from Medium to Hot was a legitimately painful leap. The virtually non-existent burn from the Medium option meant my guard was down for this level, leading to a somewhat shockingly fiery afterburn from the Hot. Still, the burn is delightful, and comes amid a nicely balanced blend of spices around a still-delectable piece of chicken. So you can add this to the facts to know about Dave's Hot Chicken: The Hot variety is the best heat level offered by the chain.
Methodology
I purchased a single tender at all seven heat levels from Dave's Hot Chicken for this article and conducted a taste test (with my wife) by taking a single bite of each chicken tender at spaced-out intervals, trying them in order from least to most hot. I wanted to ensure I could judge each spice level on its own merits, so I also sipped on milk between each level to cleanse my palate and reduce any lingering heat in my mouth (because dairy can help temper overly spicy dishes and items).
Since this was a ranking of heat levels from Dave's Hot Chicken, I looked beyond the actual flavor profile when determining the ranking order. While the actual taste of each spice level was considered, the physical experience — as in, was there a legitimate burning sensation, and how intense was it — was a huge factor, as well. If a heat level was too painful to be genuinely enjoyable or wasn't hot enough to make any real impact, it was taken into consideration.