This Nostalgic Italian Sandwich From The '60s Swapped Deli Meats For A Sweet Twist

Add Tasting Table on Google:
Google Discover

We tend to treat sandwiches as a savory deal, piled high with deli meats, cheese, tomato, hummus, sriracha mayo — you name it. But did you know there was a classic sandwich from the '60s that was also sweet? Aptly named a sugar sandwich, it was a pretty simple affair: two slices of buttered bread sprinkled with white sugar and stuck together. The butter introduces savory notes, while the sugar adds sweetness. Ideally, both the bread and butter are soft for this snack to really shine, since the texture is part of the appeal — spongy bread layered with cool butter and crunchy sugar crystals. 

This was a simple comfort food that delighted children from the era. Yet, since it is a pretty basic dish, a few twists can liven it up. For example, variations include adding cinnamon or sliced bananas, using brown instead of white sugar, pouring milk over the sweetened dish, or even swapping the butter for mayonnaise or Miracle Whip. You can also use peanut butter sprinkled with sugar, if you don't mind muddying the waters between sugar and peanut butter sandwiches.

Likewise, an Australian open-faced version, called fairy bread, showers buttered bread with sprinkles, while an Irish variation uses jam in place of sugar. Similar yet distinct snacks from the '60s include the still popular cinnamon toast, along with mayonnaise sandwiches, which are just two slices of bread with mayonnaise.

Sugar sandwiches came from necessity

Enhanced or not, the humble sugar sandwich has its roots in many places. In the U.S., they became popular during the Great Depression, when a simpler version without sugar was even regularly eaten. This concoction was well-suited for low-income households since it was inexpensive and required few ingredients. Plus, items like flour and sugar were more affordable at the time than meats or other fancy sandwich fillings. 

It was also known as a poor man's dessert, or a substitute for store-bought cookies or sweet treats. In the U.K. and Ireland, they were eaten before World War II, but gained popularity during and after when rationing occurred. In Italy, they were a popular afternoon snack, called merendas, and could involve softening hard bread with water. These sandwiches were meant to provide sustenance, but given their sweetness, they were especially popular with children. 

Eventually, with growing economic prosperity, more options for groceries, and the rise of convenience food, these sugar sandwiches fell out of favor. Today, we obviously have concerns about limiting the amount of sugar we give to children. However, other popular foods from the Great Depression era are still widely eaten, like sloppy Joes, banana bread, rocky road ice cream, and bread and rice pudding. Nonetheless, if you want to try out this comfort food, you probably have all the ingredients on hand already and the 30 seconds needed for its preparation. Or if you're intrigued by the idea of old-timey lunches, try out a few other vintage sandwich recipes.

Recommended