The Difference Between Culver's And McDonald's Crispy Chicken Sandwiches
Reality is often complex — so complex that a sandwich bearing the same basic title can taste wildly different from one eatery to the next. When foodies are craving a crispy chicken sandwich, should they swing by Culver's or McDonald's? The answer largely depends on what type of sandwich you have in mind. Both Culver's Crispy Chicken sandwich and McDonald's McCrispy share similar flavor profiles including southern-style breading, briny pickles, and plush buns. From these commonalities, however, the two fast food chicken sandwiches largely diverge.
Culver's Crispy Chicken sandwich starts with whole white meat chicken breast sourced from Springer Mountain Farms. The Blue Ridge Mountain-based facility champions animal welfare as its chief business principle, and only uses 100% U.S.-grown corn and soybeans in its chicken feed. That chicken gets coated in Culver's proprietary breading infused with onion, garlic, and black pepper, and topped with fresh lettuce, tomato, dill pickle coins, and creamy mayo. It all arrives on a buttered, toasted brioche bun for a pillowy juxtaposition to that crispy chicken patty. Here at Tasting Table, we're partial to Culver's Spicy Crispy Chicken sandwich, which amps up its classic chicken sammy with a three-pepper blend for a kick of heat. But, for fans of a tried-and-true platonic formula chicken sandwich, this one more than gets the job done. By comparison, McDonald's McCrispy follows a considerably stripped-down assemblage.
McDonald's McCrispy is a more pared-down sandwich
McDonald's crispy chicken filet uses a similar southern-style breading to Culver's, but arrives less crunchy. At McDonald's locations in the U.S., that chicken is supplied by Keystone Foods, with whom the fast food giant has partnered since the 1970s. Keystone even developed the original Chicken McNugget, and today, the company delivers over 300 million pounds of chicken to McDonald's every single year.
As for the toppings, the McCrispy features only crinkle-cut pickle coins, foregoing the lettuce and tomato elements in Culver's sandwich and trading the mayo for simple salted butter. Subsequently, the result is an overall smaller sandwich. Mickey D's McCrispy clocks in at 470 calories, significantly below Culver's Crispy Chicken at 690 calories, suggesting a less substantial sandwich. Also different is McDonald's use of a toasted, buttered potato roll, which lends a note of subtle sweetness compared to Culver's toothier brioche bun.
Their price tags reflect their respective size differences. At a Culver's location in Cleveland, a Crispy Chicken sandwich currently costs $6.99. McDonald's prices tend to vary by location, but the average price of a McCrispy currently averages around $4.99. Pro tip: If you prefer a heartier sammy — or don't happen to live in one of the 27 U.S. states with a Culver's location – try ordering your next McDonald's chicken sandwich "German-style" (you can thank us later).