Filet Mignon Vs Top Sirloin: Which Steak Cut Is Actually Healthier?

Add Tasting Table on Google:
Google Discover

If you're a carnivore with a taste for red meat, the last thing you want is something that ruins your steak dinner. Unfortunately, this can happen thanks to factors ranging from your steak being cooked on a dirty grill to a nagging worry over how healthy your meal really is. So, it's worth putting your mind to rest over a perfectly reasonable uncertainty — if you're weighing whether to order the filet mignon or the top sirloin, which cut of steak is really healthier?

Here are the basics of the differences between the two. Top sirloin is cut from the sirloin section of the animal, towards the rear. Because this are gets a lot of activity, this steak is generally leaner than others, but is nevertheless deeply flavorful and tender. Filet mignon, however, is renowned for its melt-in-the-mouth tenderness above all other cuts of steak. Coming from the tenderloin within the animal's ribcage, the filet mignon's soft, smooth texture comes from the fact that the muscle that comprises it isn't used much.

When we think about how healthy a piece of meat is, the first factor that will occur to many will be its fat content. If you've ever looked at a red, raw steak and wondered what the white streaks running through it are, it's fat. This is known as "marbling" — you can check out our complete guide to steak marbling to find out more. In the case of these two steak cuts, top sirloin has slightly more marbling than filet mignon. Filet mignon, however, has more saturated fat. 

Comparing sirloin and filet mignon will depend on what health factors are most important to you

There are other factors to consider for the health-conscious when deciding between these two steaks, and your decision will likely depend on what matters most to you. If you're counting calories, top sirloin clocks in at about 160 calories per three ounces, while filet mignon comes in slightly above that at 185 calories for the same amount of meat. Protein can be beneficial to your overall health, though some people actually consume too much protein. Bear in mind that every three ounces of top sirloin generally contains 26 grams of protein, while the same amount of filet mignon delivers 23 grams. In terms of sodium levels, three ounces of filet mignon has 44 milligrams of sodium, while the same serving of sirloin has 52 milligrams.

Because of these various considerations, declaring which cut of steak is healthier depends on what you are most concerned about. Steak can be part of a healthy, balanced diet – it contains iron, zinc, and vitamin B12. How healthy your steak dinner is will also depend on how you cook it. Pan-searing a steak, whether sirloin, filet mignon, or any other cut, may vary in healthiness depending on the type and amount of oil you are using. If health is your priority, there are precautions you can take, such as choosing this beef grade if you want the leanest cuts of beef you can buy.

Recommended