4 Of The Best Cakes To Hit The Sam's Club Bakery In 2026 (So Far)

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

When you look at the most beloved Sam's Club bakery items, there are plenty of irresistible cakes on the list, from the chain's Tuxedo Bar Cake to its berry-topped Chantilly Cream Bar Cake and custom birthday cakes and cupcakes. While it's hard to beat these long-standing icons, Sam's Club has dropped some exciting cakes this year that might become your new favorites. Based on customer opinions, we've chosen four of the warehouse store's most delicious bakery cakes to try in 2026.

To put together our list, we looked for Sam's Club cakes with high ratings from shoppers and plenty of good reviews and comments online. All of the following treats are either brand new drops for 2026, or have returned to the bakery section after a long absence. The chain's most exciting cakes of the year are perfect for special occasions, with plenty of visual appeal, crowd-pleasing flavors, and generous portions made for sharing.

With prices around $20, these sweet treats offer great value per serving while tasting more expensive than they are. From tempting cheesecakes to an oversized chocolate delight and an elegant take on Funfetti cake, Sam's has stocked something for everyone this year, so don't forget to pay its bakery a visit on your next trip.

Prices are as of the date of publication and may vary based on region.

The Sam's Club bakery has offered miniature cheesecake assortments before, but its Member's Mark 3-inch Assorted Cheesecakes now come in a new flavor set for 2026: turtle, salted caramel, and strawberry. The turtle cheesecake is a returning flavor with pecans, chocolate icing, and a caramel center; the salted caramel cheesecake features a caramel center plus vanilla whipped icing and crunchy chocolate beads; and the strawberry flavor tops classic New York-style cheesecake with juicy berries and vanilla whipped icing.

It seems like Sam's Club members have found a new favorite in these delectable treats. Reviews praise the beautiful appearance, smooth texture, and delicious flavors of each cheesecake. One shopper was particularly impressed by their size, writing, "These cheesecakes are amazing. They're much larger than you expect, and you probably won't be able to finish your slice in one sitting." Shoppers also say that this assortment is a huge hit at parties, especially since everyone can choose their favorite variety. 

The turtle cheesecake seems to be a fan favorite, with strong chocolate and caramel flavors and plenty of textural contrast from the pecans. But the strawberry and caramel varieties are clearly no slouch, either. The next time you're in need of an effortless dinner party dessert that's still sure to impress, look for this assortment at your local Sam's Club.

Get an 8-count pack of Member's Mark 3-inch Assorted Cheesecakes at Sam's Club for $19.87.

In August, Sam's Club's selection of fall treats got a major upgrade with the new Member's Mark Pumpkin Spice Latte Bar Cake. This dessert layers pumpkin spice cake with pumpkin mousse, coffee caramel mousse, cinnamon whipped topping, and crunchy chocolate pearls on top. It's an exciting and elegant alternative to your average pumpkin roll or pie, and Sam's Club shoppers say the taste lives up to the presentation.

Customer reviews call this Member's Mark product the best pumpkin spice cake on the market today. It's perfectly soft, moist, and chock-full of pumpkin and coffee flavors. If you often find pumpkin spice desserts cloying, this cake could change your mind. "If you are a pumpkin spice latte lover, you need to try this," wrote one fan on Facebook, adding that "The latte flavor is not overwhelming, my husband hates coffee and LOVED this cake." Another commenter on Facebook wrote, "It is SO good! And I love that it's not overly sweet."

At over two pounds, shoppers also appreciate how large this pumpkin bar cake is, calling it absolutely worth the money. Sam's Club says that one cake serves 10 to 14 people, so you can feed a crowd with a single purchase and will likely wind up with leftovers — not a bad thing for a dessert this tasty.

Get the 37-ounce Member's Mark Pumpkin Spice Latte Bar Cake from Sam's Club for $16.47.

Sam's Club released a chocolate lover's dream of a dessert in winter 2025, and after a prolonged absence, it finally returned in spring of 2026. The Member's Mark Brownie Batter Cake was nothing less than a chocolatey behemoth, weighing in at 5.5 pounds. It pairs two layers of dark chocolate cake with brownie batter-inspired filling and icing, topped off with chocolate pieces and a chocolate drizzle.

The decadent richness and sheer size of the Brownie Batter Cake definitely caught the attention of Sam's Club shoppers, who reported that it tasted as sensational as it looked. The cake layers were moist, the chocolate flakes adds a nice texture, and the rich frosting had a slight grittiness that imitates real brownie batter. While the icing's texture was divisive for some customers, others enjoyed it, saying it added to the authentic brownie batter flavor of the cake. "Best tasting cake, it was awesome and worth every penny," said a commenter on Instagram, while another user on Reddit called it "BEYOND delicious!"

Sadly, this seasonal cake has disappeared from Sam's Club's bakery once again, but its return in 2026 suggests it could make another comeback. This is one chocolate bakery item at Sam's Club to look out for in the future — just make sure to have plenty of friends around to help you finish it.

The Member's Mark 10-inch Brownie Batter Cake was priced at $19.98 at Sam's Club.

A classic round birthday cake is well and good, but if you want to surprise someone with a more creative yet still crowd-pleasing treat, try the Member's Mark Confetti Bar Cake from Sam's Club. This dessert is brand new for 2026 and features layers of colorful Funfetti-style vanilla birthday cake with rainbow sprinkles and white buttercream frosting, topped with more confetti sprinkles.

Sam's Club shoppers fell in love with this new treat at first bite, praising its moist cake layers, light, creamy frosting, and welcome crunch from the sprinkles. Even those who normally dislike sweet, simple birthday cake flavors have been surprised by the tastiness of this Member's Mark product. While some customers wish for more frosting, others appreciate the restrained amount, which makes this dessert less sugary than your typical birthday cake. "It is honestly the best store bought cake I've ever had," wrote a Sam's Club member on Facebook, while another commenter called it "sooo goood!!!" adding, "And I don't even like cake."

With its whimsical look and classic taste, this Confetti Bar Cake is sure to be a hit with kids those who are kids at heart. It's also priced under $13 for a 2.5 pound cake that serves eight to 10 people, coming out to just $1.59 to $1.27 per serving.

Get the 40-ounce Member's Mark Confetti Bar Cake at Sam's Club for $12.71.