The Best Fast Food Bakery Items, According To Reviews

Fast food isn't all about pizza and burgers. Many popular chains also offer a tempting selection of sweet bakery items to help you round off the savory portion of your meal, and these treats often come just as highly rated as the main menu items. Gooey-crisp cookies, fruit-loaded pies, and cozy, cinnamon-spiced bites all have their place among the chain's most-loved offerings, perfect for bringing an extra touch of indulgence to your order.

Much like savory menu items, fast food chain desserts can be hit and miss, but there are plenty of standout picks that should absolutely be on your radar. We've compiled an irresistible lineup of bakery treats, all of which have earned high praise from customers thanks to their crave-worthy flavors and satisfying textures. These desserts have received countless rave reviews, so if you're looking to satisfy your sweet tooth after your next fast food run, picking something from this list is a safe bet.

Jimmy John's is best known for its selection delicious of sub-style sandwiches, but there's a sweet hidden gem on the chain's menu — the Triple Chip Cookie. This classic chocolate-chip-studded bake boasts a soft, chewy texture and an unmistakably homemade taste. In fact, when we ranked 12 cookies from popular fast food chains, the Jimmy John's Triple Chip came out on top.

The exceptional quality of this cookie is likely down to its unique combination of ingredients. While many fast food chain cookies are made with palm oil or margarine, this Jimmy John's bake contains real butter, which gives it an unmatched richness. The chain also uses premium Ghirardelli chocolate chips, for the ultimate deep cocoa flavor.

Customers agree that this bake is a winner. On Reddit, one ex-Jimmy John's employee admitted to buying whole boxes of the cookies just for themself, and storing the treats in the freezer at home. In another discussion, a fan wrote, "Ever had a cookie at Jimmy John's? They blow away every other sandwich joint IMHO." And, if you fancy experimenting with other flavors, the chains also offers an equally well-reviewed oatmeal raisin cookie, as well as seasonal and limited time items like the peppermint chocolate cookie and PB&J cookie.

The humble sugar cookie is the ultimate crowd-pleasing bake, and Wendy's take on this classic treat is undeniably impressive. It's buttery yet light, with a soft, melt-in-the-mouth texture that's oh-so satisfying, and it'll pair beautifully with a cup of tea or coffee. 

Wendy's bakes its sugar cookies fresh in-house each morning, which is likely a major contributor to that exceptional, homemade flavor. In fact, according to Wendy's employees, any cookies left over at the end of the day must either be discarded or taken home by workers. This ensures that customers always receive the freshest possible cookies with every order.

Customers frequently confirm the moreish taste of this bakery treat, and Reddit is an excellent source of glowing reviews. "It was insanely good, tasted fresh and home baked," shared one user, adding "I tried to savor it as long as I could but now all I want is more of them." Another thread saw the Wendy's sugar cookies described as 10 times better than Target's version, with the original poster proclaiming, "Wendy's sugar cookies are elite, imo."

On the McDonald's dessert menu, there's a seasonal, festive treat that gives the iconic apple pie a run for its money year after year. The highly anticipated Holiday Pie swaps the fruity filling for a smooth creamy custard, that's encased in a flaky, buttery crust, before everything is glazed with a sugary coating and topped with rainbow sprinkles. It's a fun, colorful option with heaps of warming, comfort food appeal, and it's sure to bring some holiday cheer to your order.

This custard-filled treat has been delighting customers since 1999, and it's typically features on the McDonald's menu from mid-November to early January. Every year, fans are reminded just how delicious the pie is, and countless happy customers have taken to Reddit to share their enthusiasm. 

"Everyone needs to run and go get the McDonald's holiday pie," wrote one customer during the pie's 2025 seasonal return. "So so good the crust goes perfectly with the soft custard on the inside," they added. Plenty of others agreed. Other accolades folks calling it McDonald's best pie, and others noting that the dessert is "criminally underrated," while some customers even talked of mashing the pie up with some McDonald's soft serve to make a holiday-themed sundae. Yum!

Another fan-favorite on the fast food dessert scene are Taco Bell's Cinnabon Delights. These bite-sized donut holes are served warm and dusted with sweet cinnamon sugar. Inside, there's a rich cream cheese frosting, which contrasts the fluffy-crisp, golden exterior beautifully. Cinnabon Delights are irresistibly snackable, and they strike the perfect balance between lightness and indulgence. Add some to your order, and you won't be disappointed.

A quick glance at Reddit makes it clear just how much customers adore these sweet, creamy bites. When one user asked for recommendations on the most underrated fast food chain desserts, Cinnabon Delights were the most-upvoted mention. Elsewhere, the treats have been dubbed the "best fast food dessert in the game," while a user in another thread proudly shared that they could "literally demolish a 12 pack."

Over the years, Taco Bell has offered various twists on the traditional Cinnabon Delights, including a decadent dulce de leche version and even ones coated with Cap'n Crunch cereal. Our taste tester was also a big fan of the Strawberry Cinnabon Delights, which were released in May 2026 for a limited time only.

If you're after something rich, creamy, and loaded with chocolatey deliciousness, the Burger King Hershey's Sundae Pie is a must-try. This dessert features a crisp chocolate crust, a smooth chocolate crème filling, plus a decadent garnish of chocolate sauce and Hershey's chocolate chips. Every bite is loaded with rich cocoa flavor, and the combination of velvety and crunchy textures is nothing short of heavenly.

The Hershey's Sundae Pie is arguably one of the most underrated items on the Burger King menu, and if you delve into fast food dessert recommendations on Reddit, this treat gets plenty of mentions. "Hershey Sundae pie at Burger King has been the best fast food dessert for at least a decade" was the verdict from one user, and they weren't alone in their enthusiasm. Another Redditor simply described the pie as "the GOAT," receiving over 100 upvotes, while a separate thread included the comment, "the only thing I will ever go to burger king for it's awesome."

Fans of this beloved menu item will be delighted to learn that you can actually buy the pie in full-sized format at your local grocery store. The "Edward's Chocolate Creme Pie," which can be found in the freezer section at Walmart and Target, is allegedly the exact same product as Burger King's offering, making it far easier (and more affordable) for your whole family to enjoy that irresistible chocolatey taste.

Jollibee's Peach Mango Pie is another sweet bakery item that consistently impresses customers. This fruit-filled pastry is packed with bright, sweet-tart flavor, and boasts a light, ultra-crispy crust that works fantastically with the jammy filling. This warm hand pie serves as a more vibrant, summery twist on the popular apple-filled versions available at other chains, and it's received an array of positive reviews from Jollibee diners.

One Reddit reviewer called the Peach Mango Pie a "must buy," before advising "you'll regret only getting one." Another taste tester agreed, writing "I ate it so fast I was upset with myself ... don't be like me. Get two." A second discussion began with the question, "What is your favorite hand pie/restaurant pie?" It wasn't long before customers chimed in with comments like "[the Peach Mango Pie] is the only acceptable answer for best (sweet) hand pie" and "Peach Mango Pie is without a doubt my favorite." So, next time you're picking up some crispy fried chicken, grab a fruity treat to round things off, and you'll soon understand the hype.

If you haven't tried the famous Domino's lava cake, you're missing out. This gloriously chocolatey bake is a go-to post-pizza treat for many, offering a gooey hot fudge chocolate center and light, spongy exterior, all dusted with a flurry of sweet powdered sugar. There's no denying the richness of this dessert, but if you love chocolate, you really can't go wrong with this warm, indulgent creation.

In the Domino's subreddit, lava cakes are a hot topic of conversation. "I need them all! No seriously, they are delicious and I wish I had the recipe or a big box of them," shared one user. Another Redditor kicked off a discussion with, "What in the f**k did they put in those lava cakes," and went on to state, "I've had a lot of cakes from fancy restaurants before but literally nothing tastes better than Domino's lava cakes." The sentiment was shared amongst other users, with comments like "they really do seem to be made of happiness," and others mentioning just how habit forming the taste of these cakes can be. 

When our taste tester sampled 10 popular fast food dessert pies, there was a clear winner — the Popeye's Cinnamon Apple Pie. This lightly spiced delight stood out for its crunchy, cinnamon-sprinkled crust, which was described as having an almost churro-like texture. The syrupy apple filling is generous and lets the crisp taste of the fruit shine, while delivering just the right amount of sweetness. And, while it certainly leans into Autumnal flavors, this pie is just as well suited to summertime snacking, especially if you serve it with a scoop of your favorite ice cream.

We aren't the only ones who rate this pie so highly. On Reddit, a Popeye's regular called the dessert "easily the best apple pie in the fast food game," while a straight-talking Facebook reviewer wrote "Popeyes has the best apple pie, I'm not here to argue." Naturally, this dessert often gets compared to the famous McDonald's apple pie, but many agree that the Popeye's version outshines the competition. This is likely in part due to the cooking method. While the McDonald's product is baked, Popeye's deep fries its cinnamon apple pies for the ultimate crisp, golden finish. 

Head to Jersey Mike's, and you'll find what might just be the most impressive chocolate brownie on the fast food scene. It might seem like a basic choice, but this bake delivers on all fronts, and it's become something of a cult favorite amongst customers. The chocolate-chip-studded brownie provides that all-important ooey-gooey texture and deep cocoa flavor, and it's the perfect treat to follow a hearty, meat-packed sandwich.

When presented with the question "Which Fast Food Restaurant Has The Best Brownies?" one Redditor was quick to recommend a trip to Jersey Mike's. Clearly, these brownies offer universal appeal, because over 100 users upvoted the comment. Another customer added, "I can't get a sub without one!" Some Redditors offered up their go-to serving techniques. "A Jersey Mike's brownie warmed slightly with some vanilla ice cream is amazing!" was one recommendation, while others suggest serving them chilled for the ultimate fudgy consistency.

Selecting this mouth-watering lineup of fast food favorites required careful research. We dug into online reviews to pick out the most-raved-about bakery items, that had attracted glowing feedback from plenty of happy customers. Our primary source was Reddit, where we found countless useful insights on the flavor, texture, and overall quality of these treats. Social media sites like Facebook also proved valuable for gauging customer feedback, while previous Tasting Table rankings of popular desserts helped inform our final choices, too. There's truly something for every kind of dessert lover in this selection, and each pick has had the seal of approval from real customers.