5 Duncan Hines Brownie Mixes, Ranked

Add Tasting Table on Google:
Google Discover

While some desserts carry an intimidating reputation that many baking enthusiasts would rather leave to the professionals, brownies feel distinctly homey. I've baked many batches of brownies from scratch in my day, but as good as from-scratch brownies can be, boxed brownie mixes can save time and energy, while still producing a delicious end result — something bakers of any experience level can appreciate.

It's been a minute since I've baked brownies using a boxed mix, so I was honestly surprised by how many different types there were on the market, even within a single brand. For example, I tried five Duncan Hines brownie mixes: Milk Chocolate, Dark Chocolate, Chewy Fudgy, Double Fudge, and Keto Friendly. The sheer range of mixes piqued my interest in many ways. I've always used semi-sweet chocolate, so what would dark chocolate or milk chocolate taste like? And what's the difference between Chewy Fudgy and Double Fudge? Is one chewy but not fudgy, and the other sufficiently fudgy but not chewy? Further investigation was required. 

What I wanted overall was a good, satisfying brownie that delivered homemade vibes. A rich, chocolate flavor is a must, as is a thick, fudgy center, with edges that are perfectly chewy without being burnt, and a delightfully crackly top. There's a little more to my methodology, as well as the procedures I followed for baking each brownie mix, but I'll get more into that at the end.

5. Duncan Hines Keto-Friendly Brownie Mix

Going into this, I wasn't expecting the Keto-Friendly mix to be the best of the bunch (or even rank higher than dead last), but I still wanted to test it to see if it could produce an acceptable treat, or at the very least set a baseline. Unfortunately, as soon as the ingredients hit my stand mixer, the batter didn't look very encouraging. It was extremely thick and strangely grainy-looking without much of a chocolate aroma. Fresh out of the oven, these brownies didn't look particularly brownie-like, and when I gently tapped the top, it felt bouncy, like a cake.

There's no sugar-coating it: These brownies were awful. The chocolate taste was rather weak, and the strongest flavor I got came from the coconut and almond flours in the mix. The chocolate notes you do get have a slightly bitter edge, and I took a gulp of water right after to get the taste out of my mouth. The internal texture was confusing because it wasn't exactly cake-like, but it didn't feel very dense or chewy either. Though quite moist, the brownie wasn't very substantial, and the edges had virtually no chew to them whatsoever.

These brownies did excel in some ways, however. They held together the best of any of the mixes, and I was able to cut the batch into tidy slices with nice, clean lines. It's certainly possible to achieve keto brownies that are fudgy and delicious, but these aren't it.

4. Duncan Hines Milk Chocolate Brownie Mix

I was apprehensive about this brownie mix from the jump, because as much as I like milk chocolate for some things, I didn't think it could deliver a flavor that's rich enough for a satisfying brownie. Sadly, while the Milk Chocolate mix is better than the Keto-Friendly mix by miles, the chocolate flavor was severely lacking in these brownies, landing them at number four.

This one mixed up into a batter that was far more brownie-like than the Keto-Friendly mix, but the color was distinctively lighter than any of the other mixes I tested. It was clear from the moment I cut into the cooled batch that these had more of the classic brownie texture than the Keto-Friendly variety. As such, it was a little messier slicing these brownies into pieces, though they sliced more neatly than some of the other brownies higher on this list. The internal texture of this batch hit the mark with a nice fudginess, and they were decidedly not cake-like. 

However, as I suspected, these brownies had a sadly mild chocolate flavor that seemed especially sweet without any hint of bitterness to provide balance. The flavor overall was bland and one-note, which is a disappointment. The edges of these brownies were by far the best part because of their nicely chewy texture and a slightly more complex flavor that comes from increased exposure to heat on the side of the baking dish.

3. Duncan Hines Chewy Fudge Brownie Mix

I was pretty hopeful for these because "chewy" and "fudgy" are some of the best descriptors you can give a brownie. Ultimately, this mix produced mid-level brownies that were good but not great, landing them at number three.

The batter for this batch was thick and rather greasy, maybe due to the two eggs and ⅔ cup of oil the mix requires. The oiliness made me a little apprehensive, but they baked up nicely, with an alluring crackly top, chocolatey aroma, and a darker color than the Milk Chocolate mix. The texture of this batch was fantastic, really nicely fudgy without crossing into underdone territory, and the edges were also the absolute best of any of the five mixes (it could actually be all the oil that kept the edges perfectly chewy). This mix made some of the most cohesive brownies of the bunch, with pieces that sliced neatly and didn't fall apart when handled.

Strangely, while the Milk Chocolate batch contained the same amount of oil, the Chewy Fudge brownies seemed significantly greasier, and it impacted the taste. Though there was a rich, chocolatey flavor that wasn't as sweet as the Milk Chocolate batch, the oil taste lingered on my tongue after eating these brownies. They were still pretty tasty overall, and solid brownies, just not at the level of the top two brownie mixes I tested. While the Chewy Fudge brownies definitely weren't my favorite, they're still a fine choice. 

2. Duncan Hines Dolly Parton's Fabulously Double Fudge Brownie Mix

I was excited for this batch because the "double fudge" labeling hints at a rich flavor and texture, and if the late, great Dolly Parton endorsed the mix, how could it be bad? And boy, these brownies did not disappoint! The texture was just as fudgy as promised, and the flavor was one of the more complex and layered of all the brownies I tested. These just barely missed out on the top spot, coming in at number two.

One way these brownies stand apart is the additional ingredients; this was the only mix to use milk (just a few tablespoons) and a full stick of melted butter, along with an egg. The dry mix also came with a packet of viscous fudge sauce that got mixed into the rest of the batter, which was so thick, it practically had the consistency of actual fudge.

These brownies came out of the oven with a gloriously shiny, crackly top and a deep brown color. Because of how chewy and dense these brownies were, they actually cut well, and the inside was just the right amount of thick and fudgy, with a melt-in-your-mouth quality. Though the edges were just slightly chewier than I'd prefer, there was a rich and balanced chocolate flavor to these that was more nuanced than the previous three batches. Make no mistake, these are really good brownies, just not quite as good as my number one.

1. Duncan Hines Dark Chocolate Fudge Brownie Mix

It wasn't hard to determine which mix was number one, because the Dark Chocolate Fudge brownies were absolutely the ones I kept reaching for. Though not without their faults (if you're nit-picking, that is), these brownies have a taste that blows the other mixes away.

The batter for these was thick and glossy, with the darkest color of any of the other mixes. Though the middle seemed a little less done than some of the others when baked, the temperature registered at 220 degrees Fahrenheit, so I took them out anyway. This proved to be the right call, and the resulting gooey, but not underdone, texture was just what I wanted in a brownie.

Because of how dense and fudgy the center of this batch was, it was a little messy to cut them into pieces, and they were a bit fragile. However, the flavor of these brownies was unreal, with a super-rich chocolate taste and the perfect sweetness, with enough balance to give you the slightest hint of dark chocolate bitterness. The edges also had a pleasant chew that provided a little more structure to the individual pieces.

If you're really hankering for brownies but don't want to put in much effort, any of the mixes on this list (except the Keto-Friendly) will produce a tasty, enjoyable treat. But in my humble opinion, the Dark Chocolate Fudge mix will give you brownies that have the best flavor and the most homemade feel.

Methodology

To keep variables as consistent as possible, I followed the same protocol for every batch of brownies. I used a stand mixer to make these brownies, but that's mostly because I was making five batches. If you're just making a single batch, you'd be just fine mixing any of these by hand. Each batch was baked according to the directions, in a temperature-tested oven on the center rack, using the same baking dish.

I tested doneness using a toothpick and internal temperature; there are a lot of differing opinions about the perfect internal temperature for brownies, ranging from 165 degrees to 250 degrees Fahrenheit, but any lower than 220 degrees, and my brownies didn't pass the toothpick test, so I aimed for 220 degrees with all five batches. And when it came to tasting the brownies, I tested a middle and an edge piece from each batch after it had cooled.

To judge and rank the brownies, I considered four criteria: taste, internal texture, edges, and cohesiveness. The best brownies had a rich, chocolate taste with depth and a balanced flavor that was not too sweet and not too bitter. Some people prefer cakey brownies, but I certainly don't, so I looked for a texture that was chewy and dense without feeling underdone. The edges of a brownie are sacred, so to rank high on my list, a brownie had to have nicely chewy edges without crossing over into crunchy, burnt territory. Cohesiveness is important as well, so I paid attention to how well they held together when sliced into pieces.

Recommended