5 Store-Bought Cream Cheese Frosting Brands, Ranked
We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.
When baking at home, the frosting that you use on top of your cakes, cookies, or whatever else you might create can be just as important as the creation itself. While some people may opt to make their own classic cream cheese frosting, there's something incredibly convenient about being able to pick up a container of ready-made frosting at the grocery store. I decided to head to the grocery store and buy every cream cheese frosting brand I could find so that I could rank them from worst to best.
Now, not all cream cheese frostings are created equal — something I quickly learned during this experiment. Ultimately, my highest-ranked brands offered the best balance of sweetness and truest cream cheese flavor, rather than tasting like a tub of sugary frosting. Going into this test, I thought this wouldn't be such a difficult standard to achieve, but I was proven wrong fairly quickly. With that said, let's dive into the tasting.
Prices are as of the date of publication and may vary based on region.
5. Miss Jones
Miss Jones, which sells a relatively delicious gluten-free cake mix, was unfortunately my least favorite cream cheese frosting brand. In all honesty, I had a pretty difficult time getting through even one spoonful. Right away, I noticed how thick it was. The consistency was completely different from the other frostings I sampled, and not in a good way. It had a dense, pasty quality that made it difficult to enjoy. I couldn't even imagine attempting to spread it on top of a cake.
The flavor was even more disappointing. I struggled to identify any cream cheese taste, which is kind of the entire point when you're buying cream cheese frosting. Instead, it tasted like what I imagine clay tasting like. I know that's not exactly a glowing review, but it's genuinely the closest comparison I could come up with. Interestingly, there was a slight hint of saltiness, which I appreciated in theory. A little salt can be a great way to balance the sweetness in frosting and make the overall flavor more interesting. But it wasn't enough to save the experience.
Ultimately, I just didn't enjoy this frosting, which sells for $6.89 for an 11.29-ounce container on Amazon. The thick consistency, unusual flavor and complete lack of recognizable cream cheese taste made it a pretty easy last-place choice. If I'm buying cream cheese frosting, I want something creamy, tangy and delicious. This didn't deliver on any of those things for me.
4. Betty Crocker
Betty Crocker's Rich & Creamy Cream Cheese Frosting, which sells on Amazon for $1.96 for a 16-ounce can, was another major disappointment, although for a very different reason than Miss Jones'. When I first tasted it, I was hoping for that familiar, creamy, slightly tangy cream cheese flavor. Unfortunately, I didn't get that. The frosting didn't have a particularly recognizable cream cheese taste, and the odd, lingering aftertaste stood out the most.
I had a hard time describing exactly what I was tasting, but it felt almost chemical. It settled toward the back of my throat and left behind a strange sensation that I really didn't enjoy. And when you're tasting frosting by itself, there's nowhere for those flavors to hide! I think that's what made this one especially disappointing. Frosting should be sweet and enjoyable, and ideally, it should make you want another bite. Instead, I found myself wanting to clear the taste of this one from my mouth.
I usually reach for Betty Crocker's frostings when I need a plain chocolate or plain vanilla, which is why I was even more disappointed by this flavor. I urge you to steer clear of Betty Crocker's Rich & Creamy Cream Cheese Frosting.
3. Duncan Hines
Duncan Hines landed right in the middle of my ranking. I sampled both its Creamy Cream Cheese Frosting (available for $1.76 for a 16-ounce container on Amazon) and Whipped Cream Cheese Frosting (priced at $1.76 for a 14-ounce container on Amazon). Interestingly, their flavors were nearly identical, so I decided to group them together rather than rank them separately.
My biggest issue with both was that I couldn't quite figure out what flavor I was tasting. It wasn't exactly vanilla, but it also didn't have a distinctive, tangy cream cheese flavor, either. Both frostings tasted unusual, which made them difficult to rank. The sweetness was also pretty strong. I could see these frostings working reasonably well on a cookie or cake, where the other ingredients might help balance everything out. But since I ate them straight from a spoon, I wished they had a more recognizable cream cheese flavor.
That said, the two varieties had different textures. The Creamy version was a little denser, while the Whipped version had a lighter consistency that I enjoyed more. The airiness felt more pleasant on my tongue and helped it edge out the Creamy version. Overall, Duncan Hines wasn't terrible, but it didn't offer what I was looking for. If you're planning to use it as a topping for baked goods, it might work just fine. But if you're hoping for that delicious, cheesecake-like flavor, I'd recommend looking elsewhere.
2. Pillsbury
Many people know and love Pillsbury's canned products. Its Cream Cheese Frosting, which is sold at Walmart for $2.18 for a 16-ounce can, was a pretty enjoyable surprise, although I wouldn't necessarily say it tasted exactly like cream cheese frosting. The flavor started with a more traditional frosting sweetness, leaning toward vanilla, before a little burst of cream cheese came through in the middle.
I actually liked the progression. It gave the frosting a familiar sweetness, while still introducing enough cream cheese flavor to distinguish it from a standard vanilla variety. It wasn't particularly tangy or complex, but there's enough happening to make it enjoyable. The texture was another positive. Its consistency was smooth and pleasant on the tongue without being overly thick. I didn't notice any strange aftertaste either, which was a big plus after sampling the lower-ranked options.
My biggest criticism is that I want more cream cheese. If you're buying a product specifically because it's labeled "cream cheese frosting," that flavor should be the star of the show. With Pillsbury, it sometimes felt like the vanilla frosting was doing most of the work, while the cream cheese played more of a supporting role.
1. Philadelphia
Philadelphia Cream Cheese Frosting, available for $3.93 for a 16-ounce tub at Walmart, was the clear winner for me, and honestly, it wasn't even a difficult decision. When I tasted it, I felt like I was biting into a homemade cheesecake. It had that unmistakable, creamy, and tangy cream cheese flavor that I was hoping to find throughout this entire taste test.
What really impressed me was how well balanced it was. There was definitely sweetness, as you'd expect from a frosting, but it was never overwhelmingly sugary. Instead, the cream cheese flavor remained front and center, giving it a richness that made it taste much more like an actual cream cheese dessert than a tub of frosting. The texture was another major highlight. It was perfectly smooth and creamy, so much so that I genuinely wanted to keep eating it by itself. If I was craving a sweet treat straight out of my fridge, I'd be happy just diving straight into this tub.
Philadelphia stood out from the rest of the brands. Some of the other frostings were perfectly acceptable as cake or cookie toppings, but they didn't necessarily make me crave another bite. Philadelphia was different. It had the flavor, texture and sweetness that made it enjoyable all on its own. If you haven't given this brand a try, trust me, it's worth it.
Methodology
The execution of this tasting was quite simple. I tasted each frosting straight from a spoon, sampling the brands back to back and cleansing my palate with water between each one.
I focused on how authentic the cream cheese flavor was, the balance of sweetness, the consistency and smoothness, and whether there were any strange chemical or artificial aftertastes. My ultimate goal was to find the frosting that tasted the most like genuine cream cheese, while still delivering the sweetness and texture that you'd expect from any type of frosting.