The Best Pumpkin Pie-Inspired Treat On Store Shelves Is 10X Tastier Than Entenmann's

Add Tasting Table on Google:
Google Discover

Whether you can't get enough pumpkin pie or you're not that wild about it, you might be looking for pumpkin pie-esque sweets that provide a tasty alternative to the classic fall dessert. Tasting Table ranked several pumpkin pie-inspired treats to find which are worth trying, and the number one spot went to the Overjoyed Pumpkin Praline Cheesecake. This grocery store brand triumphed over more famous snack companies like Entenmann's, whose pumpkin donuts ranked last.

Overjoyed is a baking brand found at chains like Safeway, Albertsons, and Acme, but its Pumpkin Praline Cheesecake is far from the inferior, "store brand" type of product you might expect. It features classic cheesecake batter swirled with pumpkin and topped with crunchy, slightly sticky pralines. Tasting Table's taste tester enjoyed the sweet and indulgent yet balanced flavor.

The Pumpkin Praline Cheesecake had a properly rich, creamy texture, and the crisp praline topping added a unique, tasty touch. On the other hand, the long-standing, fan-favorite baked-good brand, Entenmann's, made a surprisingly poor showing with its dry, artificial-tasting, and grittily glazed pumpkin donuts. They paled in comparison. 

How to make the Overjoyed Pumpkin Praline Cheesecake even yummier

The only qualm with the Overjoyed Pumpkin Praline Cheesecake is that it costs $17.99 to $22.99 in stores, making it far more expensive than the other pumpkin pie-inspired items included in Tasting Table's ranking. However, considering you get a huge 40-ounce cake, and factoring in its great taste, it's still considered a better value than Entenmann's pumpkin donuts. The latter cost our taste tester $6.99, but that still felt too pricey for such a poor performance.

To make the Overjoyed cheesecake an even better value, try dressing it up so it's more fitting for a special occasion. Ina Garten makes store-bought cheesecake fabulous by simply adding a homemade sauce on top. A salted caramel sauce or even some melted peanut butter would work with this Pumpkin Praline Cheesecake. A two-ingredient whiskey dessert sauce would also be scrumptious if you're serving the cheesecake to adults. 

Don't shy away from adding toppings like chopped nuts, pumpkin seeds, crushed graham crackers, or whipped cream for texture. Your customized Overjoyed cheesecake would be a fitting end to a dinner party chock-full of comforting fall recipes. On the other hand, if you're serving the cake on its own, enjoy it with coffee, hot chocolate, chai tea, or even a DIY pumpkin spice latte.

Recommended