Review: Chick-Fil-A's New Holiday Coffee Drink Isn't Groundbreaking, But It Doesn't Need To Be

Add Tasting Table on Google:
Google Discover

Chick-fil-A is really good at coming up with seasonal fun items that make you want to visit the store more often — such as the addition of waffle sandwiches earlier this year. This time around, the popular chicken chain is bringing the winter spirit with a minty cold brew concoction. I went to the store bright and early to try the Peppermint Cream Cold Brew. I wanted to see how the flavors paired and find out whether it gave me a caffeine boost or a sugar crash (or both). I ordered it as is without any customizations, although there is some room to make changes. 

If you can't get enough of mint and coffee, this likely piqued your interest. I typically like my peppermint coffee drinks hot, just because they feel a little more aligned with the cold weather, but I was really interested in trying this cold brew version. I'll also give you some insights on the price, availability, and some other details to help you determine whether you should place an order. 

Prices are as of the date of publication and may vary based on region.

Methodology

I purchased my peppermint cold brew via the Chick-fil-A app and picked it up in the drive-thru. I didn't make any customizations so I could taste the way the chain designed it. I took a sip as it came to taste the separate layers, then mixed it and had another go. I didn't have any major expectations. Instead, I wanted it to taste as advertised, which is a blend of invigorating peppermint, rich cream, and notes of cold brew. Given that it uses a syrup, I knew sweetness would also be a factor, but I didn't want it to be cloying. It was important to try to taste all the elements in good proportion, without any being too prominent. Let's see how it fared.

Taste test

When I received my drink, it didn't have as much of a distinction between the coffee and cream layers. It looked like it had already been almost fully mixed, so I didn't get to sip on the layers as I'd expected. Even so, when I took that initial sip, I had such a strong visceral reaction, as the entire bottom layer was strong, thick, and exceedingly sweet peppermint syrup. It was most unpleasant, so do not bother sipping on this without stirring. This is purely for show and perhaps even saves staff a couple stirring steps, but don't make my mistake. 

According to the ingredient list, this actually uses a milkshake base of whole milk, cream, nonfat milk, sugar, and several other ingredients. There's coffee extract made with 100% Arabic coffee and water, as well as peppermint syrup and peppermint flavor. That said, this isn't really reinventing the wheel here. I've been drinking peppermint lattes and coffees for many, many years. I'd say the most interesting aspect is Chick-fil-A's use of milkshake base, which makes it feel heavy and slightly thick. 

Other than that, this tastes exactly as expected: a blend of coffee, milk, and peppermint; nothing especially innovative, but it's familiar. I know I can't speak for everyone, but I actually like the taste of coffee, and coffee is the last thing I tasted in this beverage. Initially, there is extreme sweetness, followed by a potent burst of peppermint, a smidge of creaminess, and then a slight fleeting taste of coffee. It tastes good enough, but I wouldn't venture to Chick-fil-A just for this.

Final thoughts

There are several other peppermint options on Chick-fil-A's lineup, including a hot or iced coffee version, the returning Peppermint Chip Shake, and Peppermint Chip Frosted Coffee, if you prefer to go in a different direction. However, the latter two didn't fare particularly well when Tasting Table's writer tried various fast food chain holiday drinks. 

A cold brew, at least in my experience, is a little mellower than, say, an espresso drink. Because of that, I actually would have preferred less syrup or a stronger cold brew base, since the coffee wasn't as intense as I would like in this Chick-fil-A version. As far as I could tell, this only came in one size, and I would've preferred a smaller size. I don't think this is especially successful as a layered coffee drink. Chick-fil-A would need to first mix syrup and coffee and then top it with the creamy layer; instead, the syrup just pooled at the bottom in a thick glob.

I think this is fun and generally tastes okay (minus being too sweet), if you like peppermint. I wouldn't suggest you venture to the chain solely to get it, but it could be worth trying if you're grabbing breakfast there. Clearly, I have some notes on what I would prefer — more coffee, less sweetness — but I can appreciate that this is solely peppermint cream versus peppermint mocha, which seems to dominate the holiday menus. 

Price, availability, and nutrition

The base price of the Peppermint Cream Cold Brew is $5.79. However, my total was $6.27 with tax, which is pretty expensive given that there is nothing too special happening here – no cold foam or even peppermint candy bits, for example. The limited-time coffee is now available at participating restaurants, but you can only get it while supplies last. I even saw a dedicated section for it in the Chick-fil-A app, so it appears to have rolled out fully. The wintry cold brew drink has 480 calories, 17 grams of fat, 77 grams of carbohydrates, 64 grams of sugar, with 8 grams of protein. It truly does not need to be this sweet.

Recommended