Which Chain's Tuna Sub Is Actually Healthier, Subway Or Jimmy John's?

Add Tasting Table on Google:
Google Discover

Tuna is a staple offered by basically every major sandwich chain, but not every sandwich is created equal. Jimmy John's and Subway are two of the big three in the world of chain sub sandwiches, along with Jersey Mike's, and we're not just talking about which one makes the best tasting tuna sub, although that obviously matters. The nutrition of each can vary more than you might think as well. While tuna can be a healthy alternative to processed deli meat, it's hard to tell how much mayo or salt is getting mixed in there at each chain. But if your choice between the big three comes down to Subway or Jimmy John's, the latter is probably going to be a slightly better option, depending on your particular dietary needs.

We looked at the nutrition facts of Subway's six-inch tuna and Jimmy John's eight-inch tuna sub to compare. The two are actually quite close in calories, which provided a similar serving size baseline for comparing other nutrition. To make the comparison as close as possible, we removed the standard provolone on the Subway tuna, since Jimmy John's standard tuna sub doesn't include cheese. We also used the standard white bread that is the default for both. With that makeup Subway's tuna has 470 calories, and Jimmy John's has 490.

In some categories, the two tuna subs were almost identical. Subway's has 21 grams of protein and 2 grams of fiber, while Jimmy John's has 20 grams of protein and 4 grams of fiber. Those are both very similar, but the slightly higher fiber content for Jimmy John's gets you closer to hitting your fiber intake for the day even if it does have one gram of protein less than the Subway option.

How Jimmy John's tuna sub edges out Subway's option

The main advantage that Jimmy John's tuna sub has over Subway's sandwich is in fat content. The Food & Drug Administration (FDA) recommends limiting trans fat and saturated fat, and Subway's sandwich is higher in both. It has 1 gram of trans fat, and 5 grams saturated fat, versus 0 trans fat and 3.5 grams saturated fat for Jimmy John's. While some saturated fat is okay in moderation, trans fat is not considered healthy at any level so the fact that Jimmy John's sandwich has 0 grams is a big plus in the chain's favor.

However, if you are watching your sodium intake, Jimmy John's tuna sub is higher. It has 1,170 milligrams, while Subway's tuna has 700 milligrams. That extra 470 milligrams is 20% of your entire day's recommended maximum sodium by itself. For sugar, Jimmy John's tuna is also a little higher, 5 grams to 4 grams, but Subway's lists more added sugar at 3 grams, while Jimmy John's says there is no added sugar in its tuna sub.

The two tuna subs really are close and your decision comes down to whether you care more about fat or sodium. Given trans fat's bad reputation, Jimmy John's sandwich is a bit healthier despite containing more sodium. And it should be noted that if you swap both to the chain's sandwiches to whole grain bread, Jimmy John's also has more fiber with 7 grams to 3 grams at Subway. Ultimately the choice comes down to your unique dietary needs, but both subs are decent sources of protein and can easily fit into a balanced healthy diet as an occasional meal.

Recommended