13 Sheetz Bakery Items, Ranked Worst To Best
Sheetz made-to-order (MTO) food is a hot topic of conversation. Why? Well, probably because it's convenient and because it rivals the grub at most fast-food restaurants. From its long list of fresh-made Subz and Burgerz to its endless Appz and Sidez, it has some seriouzly impressive options. You don't see that everyday at a gas station, which I think warrants a little fanfare. But it doesn't stop at the hot food ordering kiosk. The chain also offers a range of grab-and-go items, including a smorgasbord of baked goods.
You can kick off your morning with a donut from the case, or a cup of Shweetz mini muffins. Your commute could be a little shweeter with Shweetz cookies, which come at a dime a dozen, or a Shweetz Gobbz, which lives in a category all its own. Since Sheetz got its start in Pennsylvania, you can see some Mid-Atlantic and even Midwestern influences sprinkled throughout its sweet offerings, too. That was actually what got me most excited about raiding the Sheetz bakery section in the first place.
I rounded up a good sampling of Sheetz treats, ending up with 13 total to try. As I ranked each one, I was looking for high-quality options tasty enough to have come from a true gourmet bakery. Maybe my expectations were a little too high, but given its hot food reputation, I had confidence that Sheetz could deliver.
13. Shweetz Cinnamon French Toast Donut Holes Cup
Sheetz has an entire bakery case full of full-sized donuts — more than what you would find at some grocery stores. But it also offers donut holes in convenient individual-sized cups. At least, I would call them individual-sized cups, though others might deem them shareable. I counted five different flavors of donut holes, but I stuck to just two (for sampling purposes). I picked up the Birthday Cake cup and this one filled with Cinnamon French Toast donut holes. It was a pretty unique flavor for a donut hole, but these didn't end up being my favorite.
Now, I was intrigued enough to pass over the more classic vanilla and chocolate options for this, but maybe I should have stuck to what I know. I'm not entirely sure where the French toast part comes into play, but they were intensely cinnamony. They were also very dense, with a texture closer to a cake donut than a light and fluffy yeast one. The biggest problem was that they leaned a little dry and even somewhat chalky. These left me pining for plain ol' vanilla, so this Sheetz bakery item comes in last.
12. Shweetz Gourmet Chocolate Chip Cookie
I thought the price for this was a bit steep for a gas station cookie, especially when you have a sandwich shop like Subway selling them for half as much. But when you see the size of these in person, it starts to make sense. It is a big cookie, for sure. Unfortunately, bigger doesn't always mean better. There's something strange going on here, which is why this ends up near the bottom.
The base of the cookie is very crumbly rather than soft and chewy or crisp and golden, and it doesn't have much sweetness to it either. In fact, it's actually a bit salty and just bland overall. The semi-sweet chocolate chips help, but only so much. They can't carry the entire cookie, no matter how big or frequent they are.
I took the opposite approach here as I did with the donut holes, opting for the most standard of cookies. But in this case, I don't think that was the right decision (I really can't win, can I?). Next time, I'd definitely go for one of the other five cookie varieties instead.
11. Shweetz Rainbow Snack Mix Cup
Holy moly: This treat is a kaleidoscope of sugary chaos. It's like something you'd find in a unicorn's lunchbox. The Rainbow Snack Mix Cup is described as a blend of white-coated cereal and pretzels with rainbow nonpareils and marshmallows. To further clarify, the cereal in question is Cheerios and Chex (or at least the off-brand counterparts), and the marshmallows are just like the colorful ones you'd find in a bowl of Lucky Charms (which are officially called Marbits). Everything besides the marshmallows is blasted with a white chocolate-like coating, and while this sounds like a fun treat, it wasn't particularly well executed.
I see the vision, but everything feels just a bit stale underneath its white, sugary shell. And the marshmallows are even worse. They didn't crunch, but just squished down into a weird chewiness. So while I did get more enjoyment out of it than the chocolate chip cookie or cinnamon donut holes, I still don't necessarily think this stale, rainbow-colored cup of cavity is worth buying from Sheetz bakery.
10. Shweetz Sugar Cookie Gobbz
I wanted to like this bakery item so badly because it sounded (and even looked) so scrumptious. It's called a Gobbz, which is just the gas station's way of Sheetzifying the word "gob" — AKA Pennsylvania's name for a whoopie pie (with its disputed history). It seemed like a winner, and also seemed like a steal since it cost less than $2. However, it ended up being too sweet for my liking.
The top and bottom are more like a cross between a sugar cookie and vanilla cake than classic cookies. They're incredibly fluffy and soft, and also studded with sugar granules on top. In between is a layer of cream, which I think is what pushed the whole thing over the saccharine edge for me. It's extra sugary, but also a bit gritty, with a noticeably packaged taste. Honestly, I would happily eat either the top or bottom cookie on its own — just like a muffin top, or a Muffie, as Panera would call it. But as is, it's too much to climb higher.
9. Shweetz Chocolate Chip Mini Muffin Cup
Unfortunately, I didn't find any big muffins at my local Sheetz. I did find this cup full of minis, though, which are very similar to another type of mini muffins called Little Bites (which can also probably be found at the gas station). Either way, these particular muffins are chocolate chip flavored and more on the compact side, and were definitely better than the lower-ranked items from Sheetz.
These weren't exceptionally moist, but they're still tender, with an almost vanilla flavor to them. The mini chocolate chips are plentiful, with a slightly crisp bite to them. They're probably closer to a dessert than a breakfast food, and the calorie and sugar counts would certainly agree with that. They're not the best thing I tried from my bakery haul, but they're poppable and tasty enough to take ninth place.
8. Sh'mores Snack Tray
What a cute little idea. This is just like an oversized version of the infamous Dunkaroos, but with a Sheetz twist, as the snack tray is meant to emulate s'mores. It includes honey graham cookie sticks on one side and marshmallow dip on the other, which is covered in mini chocolate chips. Graham cracker, marshmallow, chocolate: Check, check, check.
Now, I was actually a bit worried these weren't going to be very good. The graham sticks appeared to be underwhelmingly dry and almost like something made with whole wheat flour. But with a touch of sweetness, they actually tasted better than they looked (with the exception of a few that were definitely burnt).
It's the marshmallow dip that's really the best part, though. I thought it would taste like a generic white cream, but the flavor is actually just like marshmallow fluff — the kind you would spread on a Fluffernutter sandwich. It's sticky and delicious, and topped with the chocolate chips, I could happily eat it with or without the mediocre graham sticks (which is largely why this only ranks eighth). Just give me a spoon instead.
7. Muddy Buddies
In my house, we refer to this as puppy chow. Apparently, it's called that because of its resemblance to real dog kibble, which really makes you think twice about grabbing a powdered-sugar-covered handful, doesn't it? So, maybe that's why Sheetz opted for the more palatable name of Muddy Bites. Whatever you want to call it, it's that same Midwestern recipe we know and love.
Sheetz takes toasted corn and wheat biscuits (similar to Chex cereal), wraps it in a chocolate peanut butter coating, and then blasts everything with a liberal amount of powdered sugar. It smells very much like peanut butter as soon as you pop the lid of the snack cup, and it leads into that familiar salty-sweet flavor. It has a nice crunch and that powdered sugar exterior that immediately melts on your tongue.
However, it did seem the slightest bit stale, which is why it felt inferior to the batches we've made at home during Christmastime, and why it didn't earn a better spot in this ranking. I also think this is a risky pick for a gas station snack. That road trip could very quickly turn into a snowy, powdered sugar mess.
6. Shweetz Tutti Frutti Crispy Bites Cup
It seems all of our favorite childhood cereals have a cameo in the Sheetz bakery section. Here we have a two-fer, as this cup contains Rice Krispies treats (that's cereal number one) that are also studded with Fruity Pebbles (that's cereal number two). I've certainly seen treats before that fuse these two breakfast mainstays, but can't say I've had one — and it was honestly a great idea to combine them.
You get all of that marshmallowy, sugary, chewy goodness of a classic Rice Krispies treat, but elevated by the bright and extra-sweet taste of Fruity Pebbles. It does taste more like the packaged Rice Krispies Treats from the brand itself rather than a homemade version. But that was probably to be expected. Now, I liked these, but I could see how others might find those fruity flavors to be too artificial. Essentially, if you like Fruity Pebbles cereal, you'll probably like these bites, and if you don't, you won't.
5. Shweetz Chocolate Peanut Butter No-Bakes
Another Midwestern treasure, and this one really puts me in my nostalgic feels. My great-grandma and my mom used to make chocolate no-bake oatmeal cookies all the time when I was growing up. I remember watching as they went from a sloppy mess of chocolate, oats, and peanut butter to hardened cookies, like magic right before my eyes. It all happened on the kitchen counter with no oven required, which might just be the very best part — and the Sheetz version comes close to those made-with-love cookies.
These have a nice balance between a soft and crumbly texture, but also offer a pleasant chew thanks to a heavy hand of oats. There's plenty of sweet cocoa flavor and a good dose of peanut butter as well for that oh-so-important saltiness. My one qualm is that the peanut butter tastes like it could have come from a powder rather than the real stuff, which brings the overall flavor down just a bit.
Still, you can't beat a price of just over $1 for three of these little guys. And if you want even more no-bake goodness, you can pick up the No-Bake Nubbins Cup, which is essentially just smaller, broken-off pieces of the same cookies (some may call them rejects, but I'd call them perfectly imperfect).
4. Shweetz Birthday Cake Donut Holes Cup
You can get me on board with birthday cake anything, and these little treats certainly do the flavor justice. These were such a better display of donut holes than the cinnamon "French toast" batch, which is why they rank so much higher.
These still have that dense texture that's more cakey than doughy, but there's no semblance of dryness here. They're just soft and moist, like donut holes ought to be. Then there's the flavor, which tastes just like Funfetti cake batter. I'm sure that's exactly what Sheetz was going for, and it absolutely nailed it. It goes beyond a simple vanilla taste, offering something sweeter and a whole lot more nostalgic. Plus, who doesn't love those colorful sprinkles baked right in?
These are also dipped in a sugary glaze, adding even more sweetness — the kind you get to lick off your fingers after every bite. These weren't the only baked goods worth celebrating, and there were a few I liked even more. But I would definitely chow down on these again.
3. Apple Fritter
All the donuts in the Sheetz donut case ring up at $2.49 as of this writing. I carefully selected just two to try out of the six total options, and this apple fritter was one of the lucky ones (in case you were wondering, a fritter is technically considered part of the donut family).
Now, I'm going to be 100% honest with you: This fritter was hard when I first grabbed it from the case, like it had been sitting there for hours. Not a good start. But I gave it a roughly 20-second warm-up in the microwave, and it transformed into one of my favorite things I tried. It has a similar texture to a classic glazed donut, though it's not quite as fluffy as your standard yeast donut from somewhere like Krispy Kreme. There's a little more substance to it than that.
The flavor is also reminiscent of fresh apples rather than anything artificial. It even seemed like there were tiny bits of softened, baked apple tucked into the crevices, and the whole thing was laced with just the teensiest bit of cinnamon for some warm spice. It was absolutely delicious, and such a pleasant surprise after its humble beginnings as a hardened fritter left on the shelf.
2. Shweetz Gourmet B-Day Sh'prinklez Cookie
After the chocolate chip cookie that I did not care for, I was ready to write this one off, as well. But birthday sprinkles triumph again. Maybe birthday-themed treats just have an air of fun and childhood whimsy about them? Either way, this is one tasty cookie.
The label says it's simply a vanilla-flavored cookie with rainbow sprinkles, but I think it's really selling itself short. It's a soft, crumbly, and satisfying sugar cookie with just the right level of sweetness, and that's just the base. Then, you also have those colorful sprinkles for a little something extra and something that the front of the packaging failed to mention completely: cake batter glitter puffy stars. They're little white chunks similar to a confectionery chocolate, but they make the cookie feel like a sugar cookie, cake batter, and frosting all wrapped up into one dessert.
This reminded me a lot of Milk Bar's Confetti Cookie, which is always delicious, too. This is a much better use of your money than the chocolate chip cookie, and only one other Sheetz bakery item topped it.
1. Chocolate Iced Custard Filled Donut
Like the fritter, this donut also needed a little bit of love — and by a little love, I mean a little time in the microwave. Clearly, I didn't hit Sheetz at the right time, when the donuts were fresh at the wee hours of the morning, so that's partly on me. But all is well, because this donut still managed to outshine all its bakery buddies.
It's essentially a Boston cream donut, complete with what looks like a darker chocolate icing on top and some kind of custard filling tucked inside. It's a big donut, with that doughy, yeasty texture that's so hard to resist. There's a surprising amount of custard packed inside as well, and it has that spot-on vanilla pudding-like taste and texture (yum).
It was far better than I ever expected a gas station donut to be. I actually reviewed the Boston cream donuts from Dunkin' and Krispy Kreme recently, and I think this one would have given both a run for their money. In fact, it just might have both donut giants beat.
Methodology
I got the lay of the land of the Sheetz bakery section before heading to my nearest location. You can pre-order baked goods, so I took a look at the options online to get a good idea of what I'd find when I went in. There's a wide selection of cookies, donuts, muffins, and more, so I picked up a good sampling of everything the gas station has to offer and brought a total of 13 items home to try.
First and foremost, as I tasted my way through everything (fighting a sugar rush), I took notes on freshness and flavor. Those were the two most important factors to me in order to rank each treat. I wanted to avoid anything stale, stiffened, or really anything that felt lower quality (texture was a big tell). On the flavor side, I looked for options that weren't cloying or artificial, but still played their role well as a sweet treat. I did briefly consider the price of each item, but only to determine whether the quality and taste justified the cost.