Marie Callender's Vs Stouffer's: Which Frozen Meal Brand Makes Better Mac And Cheese?

Add Tasting Table on Google:
Google Discover

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

Stroll through the frozen aisle at your local grocery store and you'll have no shortage of mac and cheese options. Among popular brands like Marie Callender's and Stouffer's, one Tasting Table writer had a clear preference. After sampling and ranking 18 frozen mac and cheese brands, our writer placed Marie Callender's at number 11 and Stouffer's at number 15, giving Marie Callender's the edge. 

Plenty of fans note that Marie Callender's offers a solid dish. "Nice flavor, and super creamy cheese," wrote one user on Reddit, who also described an ideal cheese-to-pasta ratio. "Quality is consistent, texture is perfect and no prep time makes it quick and easy for me to eat," added another shopper on Amazon, where a package is sold for about $3. 

The pasta comes in a creamy Vermont white cheddar sauce and offers 20 grams of protein per serving. Our writer described the dish as a middle-of-the-road experience, with average noodles and flavor, though the breadcrumb topping stood out for adding a welcome bit of texture . Stouffer's, in contrast, was described as the kind of meal that could be easily forgotten in a freezer, tasting similar to Michelina's mac and cheese, offering only slightly better noodles. Our writer called this product a "hard pass" and wondered whether Stouffer's other mac-and-cheese options might fare better. 

Both brands have fans

Though neither Marie Callender's nor Stouffer's landed at the top of our ranking of frozen mac and cheese, both have fans. Marie Callender's frozen meals have earned a solid reputation. The Vermont cheddar mac and cheese bowl landed fourth in a separate ranking of 16 meals, with a different Tasting Table writer noting its nice cheddar flavor and comforting taste, even if the noodles turned soggy once heated. One Amazon shopper was even more enthusiastic, writing, "I haven't found another frozen mac and cheese that comes close."

Stouffer's, too, has a committed fanbase. Sold for less than $3 on Amazon and made with real cheddar cheese sauce, it is a routine purchase for some shoppers. "I've tried quite a few frozen and refrigerated macaroni and cheese meals over the years, and this is still the one I keep coming back to. The pasta stays tender, and the cheese sauce is creamy and flavorful," wrote one Amazon shopper, praising its tender pasta, creamy cheese sauce, and convenience.

If either option isn't to your liking, you can upgrade these frozen meals the way you would boxed mac and cheese with extra ingredients. Try adding a drizzle of barbecue sauce, extra cheese, a splash of buttermilk, or a handful of grilled protein to make each bowl more satisfying.

Recommended