One Of McDonald's Best Seasonal Treats Is A Fall Delight Deserving A Full-Time Spot On The Menu
Nothing gets folks in the holiday mood more than the seasonal treats that pop up at our favorite fast food chains. Whether it's candy canes in our cold brew or pumpkin spice in our pancakes, we love those tasty reminders that the holidays are upon us. And even more than a Spirit Halloween store popping up in an abandoned mall, the McDonald's Pumpkin & Crème Pie signals the beginning of fall.
McDonald's, unlike Starbucks, doesn't go too crazy on seasonal menu items, so this dessert is notable. Part pumpkin pie, part creamy pastry, the handheld dessert combines both fillings in a sugar-coated baked crust. It's quite a departure from the year-round Baked Apple Pie, and its limited availability is part of why it's a fall favorite that Mickey D's fans eagerly await. It's no wonder we named it one of the best pumpkin fast food items in 2025.
This autumnal treat is basically a turnover with two distinct fillings: one side is a pumpkin pie filling, while the other is an oozy, vanilla-flavored crème filling. That contrast is what sells it, both visually and texturally. The pumpkin side obviously brings in those familiar fall flavors of real pumpkin and warm spices, while the crème provides a custardy counterpoint. The balance of the two flavors keeps the pumpkin from overpowering, which is a familiar complaint for those who don't like pumpkin pie in general. It's why one TikTok fan remarked: "Perfect ratio of pumpkin and cream."
Customers love McDonald's Pumpkin & Crème Pie
McDonald's first introduced a pumpkin-filled pie in 2011, but that one lacked cream. The Pumpkin & Crème as we know it arrived in 2015. In recent years, the Golden Arches have brought it back around late August or early September, usually for a limited time while supplies last. It's also not available at every restaurant, as it can vary by franchise and market.
Fan reactions online reflect the cultish following that makes the pie worth keeping year-round. YouTuber "SomethingNew" proclaimed in his video: "This right here is on another level ... the flavors have an intention to blow your whole head back" before rating it a 10/10. It's not that an impractical idea, either. McDonald's already sells baked pies throughout the year, so it wouldn't require any adjustment in the kitchens or an entirely new dessert format. And given that we think its apple pie is actually the worst fast food dessert pie out there, maybe the pumpkin version should replace it entirely.
But of course, part of the appeal is that it doesn't stick around. Limited availability always creates anticipation, and McDonald's does offer a solid rotation of baked pies throughout the year. Still, there's always a good argument for giving it a longer run, as well as making it available at every location. A dessert this good shouldn't have customers begging their local Mickey D's to participate.