14 Things To Add To Turkey That Aren't Gravy

Add Tasting Table on Google:
Google Discover

Turkey has never been the most exciting protein. Not as inherently flavorful as steak, and not as versatile or easy to work with as chicken, it often gets overlooked in our day-to-day meal planning (because who wants to cook a whole turkey on a Tuesday night?), yet features heavily in holiday celebrations.

Traditionally speaking, gravy is what goes on top. Know why? Because most people make the mistake of overcooking their turkeys or forget to rest them, season them, or brine them. That thick jacket of gravy poured over the top? It can cover a multitude of culinary sins. But gravy does not have to be your only option. As a matter of fact, it should really be your last resort. Before you go digging in the cabinets for grandma's gravy boat this holiday season, consider this: turkey's essential banality and lack of pizzazz can actually be its greatest strength because, with no personality of its own, it can act as the perfect vessel for whatever flavors you want to add to it. 

From the simplest cranberry sauce to fancy mustards, scratch BBQ sauces, pepper jelly, or fruit chutneys, turkey acts as a perfect, unassertive base protein. It is whatever you need it to be. Whether you're talking whole birds, thick-cut slabs of breast meat, or leftovers assembled into hasty sandwiches on the day after Thanksgiving, the options for fancying up your turkey with more than just gravy are virtually endless.

Cranberry sauce and stuffing

After gravy, a cooked turkey's two best friends are cranberry sauce and stuffing. While gravy exists to smother mistakes, cranberry sauce is there to elevate what's already good about turkey and balance its delicate flavor with a nice, bittersweet tang. Stuffing is just there for everyone to lean on.

A sandwich made with all the holiday friends — sliced turkey with gravy, cranberry sauce, and stuffing — is the ultimate day-after-Thanksgiving indulgence. If you're from Wawa country, you already know this creation by its proper name, the Gobbler, and it is one of the greatest sandwiches of all time.

Compound butters

This one feels almost like cheating, but if you want to roast a turkey that won't need any gravy when it hits the table, compound butter is the secret weapon you're looking for. Soften some butter, add thyme, sage, rosemary, a little garlic, then rub that generously under (and over) the turkey skin before roasting. Tasting Table actually has a whole list of ways to upgrade your turkey, and compound butter is just one of them, but it is an excellent place to start.

Apple butter

Apples pair well with turkey because their sweetness and slight acidity match the mild flavor of the meat. When you're roasting, quarter some sharply flavored apples (like Fuji or Pink Lady) and throw them in the pan with your onions and carrots. Then, when the turkey is almost done, use apple butter as a glaze on the skin and serve with a dollop of apple butter on the side instead of gravy. Apple butter also works well as a sandwich spread for grilled or pressed turkey sandwiches with a nice, sharp cheddar.

Miso butter

Want something non-traditional for your turkey meal? Try adding a dab of delicious miso. If you're looking to add a punch of umami to your bird (because that's something that turkey sadly lacks), go with either a straight white miso butter or a soy-miso mix. Rub it under the skin or use it as a baste with a pastry brush. You can also turn the miso butter into a sauce with a little chicken stock and roux for that extra oomph.

Bacon jam

Remember back in the 2010s when everyone went insane and started putting bacon in everything? Ice cream, cheesecake, cocktails — it was everywhere. One good thing that came out of that bacon mania was bacon jam: that magical, salty, smoky gloop made of chopped bacon, brown sugar, and vinegar that made it possible to put bacon on things that were never meant to have bacon on them. Smearing it on slabs of roast turkey or using it as a condiment on turkey sandwiches are both rather tame applications, but that doesn't mean it isn't tasty.

Chimichurri

With its lean saltiness and solid (if bland) flavor, what turkey really wants is a high, singing top-note to really set it off. Chimichurri is perfect in that role. Just slice your turkey, fan it out, then spoon this uncooked herb sauce right over the top. Though traditionally used on steaks, chimichurri brings the sting of vinegar, savory notes from garlic and parsley, and a tiny touch of heat from crushed red pepper flakes, all of which will lend your turkey an unexpected punch.

Chili crisp

Everyone already knows that chili crisp goes with almost anything. It adds crunch, a heavy umami flavor, some savory garlic notes, and a sharp razor of bright, slightly smoky heat to whatever it touches. It's a killer addition to fried chicken, so why not try it on your turkey? Bonus: if you absolutely insist on having gravy with that bird, stirring in a spoonful of chili crisp will add layers to the flavor and do wonders for making it seem like a deliberate, purposeful addition to the table.

Mushrooms as a sauce, or all on their own

Good mushrooms (like chanterelles or oyster mushrooms) sauteéd in butter and a little salt are a great topper for thick-sliced turkey breast. Simmer them with cream, fresh herbs, shallots, and a shot of wine or cognac, and you've got a mushroom sauce. Or better still, chop a mix of mushrooms as fine as you can and turn them into a duxelles, which can be put under the skin while the turkey is baking, or used as the filling in a turkey roulade.

Fruit chutney

Sticking with the idea that game meats and fruit are a classic combination, adding a simple apple (or apple-cranberry) chutney cooked down with brown sugar and butter is an easy way to elevate any dry or bland turkey. You could also take it further by mixing up the fruit combos. Try out a peach chutney with cinnamon, ginger, cider vinegar, and chili flakes for some sweet heat. Or, go with pears and raisins for some texture, sweetened with a dash of maple syrup.

BBQ sauce

Unless you're smoking your turkey, those thick, tomato-heavy BBQ sauces probably won't work well. However, a Carolina-style sauce with its sting of vinegar and peppers will. It works either as a marinade or a finishing sauce because those elements complement the turkey's natural flavor without overwhelming it. 

Another interesting pairing? An Alabama white sauce. Mayonnaise-based and shot through with apple cider vinegar and garlic, it's great on turkey sandwiches or drizzled over sliced breast meat. Add a little hot sauce if you want to really make it sing.

Porchetta seasoning

Pork roasts aren't usually on the dinner table alongside turkey, but you can still take inspiration from it. If you're looking to completely switch things up for the holidays, try making a turchetta. It's basically porchetta, but made with a butterflied and rolled turkey breast instead of pork. A classic porchetta spice mix is made with fennel, rosemary, sage, black pepper, garlic, and thyme, all processed into a paste with olive oil and used as a filling for a tightly rolled tenderloin covered with perfectly crisped skin.

Mojo sauce

Spice it up! Making a turkey marinated in Cuban mojo is a good way to guarantee that you'll have no use for that gravy boat in the first place. However, the real win here is that even an unmarinated whole bird or roasted breast can be sliced and slathered in a mojo sauce made with sour orange juice (OJ mixed with lemon or lime juice), cumin, oregano, and lots of garlic for one of the best turkey sandwiches ever. 

Red pepper jelly

If mojo feels too citrus-y for you, and chili crisp seems too spicy, red pepper jelly is an excellent way to split the delicious difference. Yes, it still packs a lot of heat, but that works when balanced against the lean flavor of turkey (especially smoked turkey), and the sweet, jammy notes are very much forward, adding a surprising depth to both thick slabs of sliced turkey breasts at the holiday table and leftovers the day after. 

Traditional mustard sauce

Know what goes great on a turkey sandwich? Plain yellow mustard. Know what works really well to elevate slices of roast turkey without resorting to store-bought brown gravy? Any one of a hundred versions of a classic French mustard sauce. A simple coarse-grain-and-cream sauce with shallot is the standard. Honey-Dijon also works well if you hate getting mustard grains caught in your teeth. You can do it as a pan sauce with a little lemon and a shot of cooking wine, or as a glaze with maple syrup for added sweetness. 

Recommended