Which Cheesecake Factory Steak Is Worth Ordering: Ribeye Or Filet Mignon?

Add Tasting Table on Google:
Google Discover

A ribeye versus a filet mignon? Phew, that's one heavy-hitting meaty matchup. Both cuts of steaks are prized, but for different reasons. The ribeye, sourced from the rib primal, turns heads thanks to its generous marbling and big, beefy flavor. The filet mignon, on the other hand, hails from the tenderloin area, and tender it is. It has a lower fat content but boasts that melt-in-your-mouth quality that makes you forget all about its steep price tag.

It's hard to champion one cut above the other, and we all have our preferences. Personally, I could lean toward either steak, depending on how well it's done. And that's really the key. Quality, preparation, and grilling make all the difference when it comes down to this heated rivalry. And I was more than willing to put that theory to the test at a chain restaurant like The Cheesecake Factory.

The American chain offers both a ribeye and a filet mignon. I mean, of course it does. Its menu is over 20 pages long. But despite its endless options, The Factory's scratch kitchen still manages to give each dish its fair share of attention. I've learned that firsthand from trying its lineup of Glamburgers and even its specialty cocktails. So, I was expecting that same level of care from two high-profile steaks. The only question was, which one would come out on top of this turf-on-turn competition?

Prices are as of the date of publication and may vary based on region.

Methodology

I found the steaks listed under page-I-don't-even-know of The Cheesecake Factory's book of a menu in the specialties section. More specifically, I found the Grilled Rib-Eye Steak and the Filet Mignon. I ordered the ribeye at a cost of $44.95 and the filet for a slightly elevated cost of $49.95. I requested both be grilled to a nice medium-rare. They both automatically came with a side of mashed potatoes and green beans — although I did swap out one set of green beans for corn just for some variety.

Before the steaks arrived, I tried to save room by not loading up on The Cheesecake Factory's brown bread, supposedly sweetened by a combo of honey, molasses, cocoa powder, and espresso powder. But hey, I'm only human. Then, once the steaks reached the table, the tasting began. I started by sizing up the two steaks, quite literally comparing their sizes as well as their other features. I considered the overall quality of each, including how well it was cooked. That meant checking the temperature and seeing just how juicy and tender each cut turned out. I also took note of the flavor and seasonings used, paying attention to whether they were the same or different between the two steaks. For the ribeye specifically, I focused on its marbling and fattiness, while the filet mignon was more about that all-important texture.

All in all, it made for one satisfying two-part steak dinner. But one cut proved to be a cut above.

Taste test: Grilled Rib-Eye Steak

This was a beautiful cut of meat, with the typical shape you'd expect from a ribeye. It was presented with visually pleasing, crisscrossed char marks and was glistening with juiciness. I didn't whip out my scale right there at the dinner table, but judging by my previous steak encounters, I'd estimate it was around 12 ounces. Maybe that's not an exact measurement, but it was a substantially sized steak nonetheless.

So it was big, but what about beefy? This ribeye hit a lot of the right notes, though it perhaps wasn't the boldest, beefiest cut I've ever had. It was very juicy on the inside and cooked to a pretty spot-on medium-rare (compliments to the chef). Each bite was savory and accompanied by a very light seasoning on the surface. It tasted like a simple blend of salt and maybe a hint of garlic powder — nothing too heavy-handed that would take attention away from the meat itself. There were caps of fat running along the sides of the cut, but inside, there wasn't an overwhelming amount of marbling. Still, I didn't have any trouble chewing through any bite.

It was also a relatively flat cut, rather than a particularly thick one. That clearly didn't affect its juiciness, but paired with the moderate marbling, it may explain why it wasn't quite the rich, buttery flavor bomb I was hoping for.

Taste test: Filet Mignon

The filet mignon came out smaller yet taller than the ribeye, which is exactly what I expected. Its shape was more like a large beef medallion than a wide, sprawling slab of steak. I'd guesstimate it weighed in between 7 and 8 ounces.

The menu calls this out as its "most tender steak." And just by design, it should be. But I decided to be the judge of that. The char on the exterior was similar to the ribeye. There's just less outer surface area, so it doesn't feel as prominent. It also seems that the same understated seasoning was used. So, the two steaks appeared to be prepared in a pretty similar fashion. But once I sliced into the filet, it was a whole new world of steak.

I couldn't have dreamed up a better medium-rare. I mean, just look at that pink. And the color wasn't deceiving. It also led to a texture that was, in fact, pretty darn tender; the meat was especially soft in the center. That area might just have reached melt-in-your-mouth status, and the rest wasn't too far behind. As for the flavor, it had the mild, lean beefiness that I had expected. It did taste just a touch saltier than the ribeye, likely due to the strong concentration of flavor on the outer crust. 

The verdict: Which is the better steak?

For a chain restaurant that isn't a dedicated steakhouse, The Cheesecake Factory serves up two pretty commendable steaks. I would still prefer to get my beef fix from a place like Texas Roadhouse, where the steaks are hand-cut daily (and where the prices aren't so high). But I thought The Cheesecake Factory handled both cuts well, especially when it came to preparation and grilling. Both were cooked perfectly and just as I requested, and the beef itself seemed to be of good quality.

That being said, the one I'd be most willing to fork over $50 for again would be the filet. It really didn't make any mistakes. It lived up to all its promises, both those made by The Cheesecake Factory on its menu and those that come with the weight of the filet mignon name. It was a lean, mean, tender machine with just enough flavor and juiciness. As much as I love the fattiness and richness of a ribeye, the filet mignon managed to outshine it by just a touch. And yes, my husband also agreed that the filet was the better of the two. After just a few bites of each, he practically claimed the rest of it for himself.

If it had been a bone-in ribeye that was a little more plump with a few more ribbons of fat, this could have been a different story. But as is, the filet stood at the top of The Cheesecake Factory food chain.

Recommended