These 3 Carrot Cake Mixes Outshine Betty Crocker And Duncan Hines (And They're Gluten-Free)

Add Tasting Table on Google:
Google Discover

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

Gluten-free baked goods have come a long way in terms of accessibility, and you can even find plenty of GF cake mixes in mainstream grocery stores today. Some of these even taste better than conventional, wheat-based products — and if carrot cake is your favorite, we have three great options for you. In our ranking of store-bought carrot cake mixes, gluten-free brands Mom's Place, Stellar Eats, and XO Baking outperformed the likes of Betty Crocker and Duncan Hines.

Mom's Place Gluten-free Carrot Cake Mix was the highest-ranking GF mix in our taste test, landing in second place overall. We loved the cake's balanced, classic flavor with notes of spice, but its perfectly moist, hearty texture was the highlight, especially for a gluten-free product. You do have to add your own shredded carrots to this mix, in addition to oil, eggs, and any other add-ins like nuts. However, the end result could go toe-to-toe with a wheat-based cake.

Stellar Eats' Carrot Cake and Muffin Mix came in third place overall. This grain-free, plant-based, and paleo-friendly cake does taste different from a traditional version, but we were satisfied with the flavor, and the texture wasn't odd or dense like you may expect. XO Baking's Carrot Cake Mix landed just behind in fourth place, with a nice, moist crumb but slightly plainer flavor. Meanwhile, Betty Crocker and Duncan Hines ranked just below XO Baking, as the former had an overly strong ginger flavor that we found distracting, while the latter had a downright off-putting taste with strangely bitter, burnt notes.

Our favorite gluten-free carrot cake mixes have plenty more fans

We're not the only fans of Mom's Place and XO Baking's carrot cake mixes. These brand names are frequently brought up in discussions about the best gluten-free carrot cakes. Reviewers note that the Mom's Place mix creates a carrot cake that's just as good as a traditional version, and though it requires more preparation steps than your average cake mix, the homemade flavor is worth it.

XO Baking's mix might have even more raves from home bakers, who love the pro bakery-level flavor and tender crumb of the carrot cake. The only common complaint is that the mix is a bit pricey, but fans say it's worth the cost. Though it seems to be lesser-known overall, Stellar Eats' boxed carrot cake has also surprised customers, with its moist texture a far cry from dry, dense GF baked goods. Fans also appreciate the lower-sugar, keto-friendly aspect.

No matter which mix you choose, you can make your GF carrot cake even better with the help of some extra baking tips. Firstly, sour cream creates soft and flavorful gluten-free cakes. The dairy ingredient is packed with moisture and also has binding, emulsifying qualities, helping your cake's crumb turn out tender and fluffy throughout. You can add ½ cup to one full cup of full-fat sour cream into one box of mix. To further improve your dessert, add in some ingredients to elevate carrot cake, like nutty browned butter, fruity crushed pineapple or flaked coconut, or citrusy orange juice.

Recommended