Consumer Reports' Preferred Blackstone Grill Is Over 70% Cheaper Than Their Second Pick
We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.
Shopping for a flat-top grills gets pretty expensive, pretty quickly. That's especially true when advanced features enter the picture including larger cooking surfaces, extra burners, storage cubbies, and built-in accessories. But spending more doesn't always deliver better performance. In fact, among the Blackstone flat-top grills evaluated by Consumer Reports, the publication ranked a much more affordable option in its upper-echelon spots.
In this Consumer Reports comparison, the 28-inch Blackstone 1517, priced at $250, ranked higher than the substantially more expensive 36-inch Blackstone 1902 with a retail price of $1,100. That puts the cheaper grill at roughly 77% fewer dollars out of your pocket. That said, the two Blackstone flat-tops aren't identical, so it's always a matter of what you like and need in a grill.
The pricier 1902 provides a good bit more cooking space, twice as many burner controls, and several convenient features that the 1517 doesn't bring to your cooking arsenal. But if your main goal is a well-functioning flat-top grilling surface instead of a fully loaded outdoor cooking station, the less expensive model offers many of the essentials at a fraction of the cost.
Simple goes a long way with the Blackstone 1517
The Blackstone 1517 is a fairly straightforward two-burner flat-top grill, and its simplicity is one of its most attractive features — along with the $250 price tag, of course. Both those factors apparently worked in its favor when Consumer Reports ranked it ahead of the more elaborate Blackstone 1902.
The 28-inch grill uses two burners that are independently controlled and produce a total of 34,000 BTUs, facilitating individual temperature zones across the shared cooking surface of about 518 square inches. The separate burners let you sear burgers in a hotter zone while veggies cook more gently, or when firing up the grill for breakfast, 15 pancakes can warm on one side while up to 48 slices of bacon sizzle on the other. According to Blackstone, a remarkable 87 dogs grill to perfection at the same time on this model.
Other features of this affordable 1517 model include electronic ignition and two casters for easier movement, plus the brand's rear grease-management system that collects grease and food bits in a designated back area. What you don't get with this Blackstone is luxury or additional built-in features. It comes with a single powder-coated steel side shelf instead of the expansive workspace and storage of the more expensive 1902 model. You can buy this Blackstone 1517 now on Amazon for the $250 retail price.
The 36-inch Blackstone 1902 adds space, power, and plenty of extras
Though ranked lower by Consumer Reports than the smaller 1517 model, the Blackstone 1902 makes a much bigger statement in physical space as well as cost. This 36-inch model with hood carries a retail price tag of $1,100, roughly $850 more than the 28-inch 1517. Some of that premium price reflects the much more spacious cooking capacity of 765 square inches.
It also features four independently controlled main burners for a total output of 60,000 BTUs, about double the amount of heat zones for your grillmaster proclivities. That extra space and versatility could really matter if you're regularly cooking for a crowd on a Blackstone grill. Four burners also make it much easier to dedicate separate areas for different cooking needs and can maintain a high-heat searing, warming, and low, slow sizzle at once.
Then there's the full setup of this larger 1902 model. It's really more like a complete outdoor kitchen station with extras like magnetic tool bars, paper towel and garbage-bag holders, a cutting board, casters, and fold-down shelving on both sides. A front cabinet tucks away the propane tank, and pull-out stainless bins let you store cookware and supplies. All those goodies appeal to certain buyers, but the Consumer Reports rating still shows a clear price advantage for the highly functional, yet smaller and simpler, Blackstone 1517 model. Whichever grill you choose, be sure to check out these 13 grilling mistakes to avoid according to Blackstone and other tips and tricks for using a Blackstone griddle.