Your Vintage Baking Recipes Are Off Because Cake Mixes Have Gone Through A Sizable Change Since The '60s

Add Tasting Table on Google:
Google Discover

No, you're not imagining it. There really is something wrong these days with your grandmother's recipe for boxed chocolate cake. The problem isn't you, though. And it's certainly not the steps scratched down on the notecard that's been passed down through generations. What's wrong is that, since the 1960s, the boxed cake mixes that form the backbone of so many cherished family recipes have suffered from a rather dramatic case of shrinkflation. You've probably even noticed it yourself: The boxes on the shelf in the grocery store don't feel as heavy as they used to, and when you dump the cake mix into your bowl, it doesn't seem as full as you remember. 

That's because, back in the day, most boxed cake mixes contained around 18 ounces of dry ingredients. And the recipes from that era were all designed around that common, immutable figure — a number as unchanging as the hours in the day. Fast-forward to today, though, and things aren't so simple. To offset rising costs and save a few pennies in profit, many modern boxed cake mixes have reduced the amount of mix in the box. Duncan Hines' devil's food mix is 15.25 ounces. Same with the company's classic yellow cake mix. Betty Crocker's vanilla cake mix? 13.25 ounces. Across the board, boxed cake mixes have shrunk to anywhere between 13 and 16 ounces, which is a fairly sizable change mathematically (a roughly 15% to 25% decrease) that can have an even bigger impact on those vintage recipes.

How to adjust for the shrinking size of modern cake mixes

Because odds are that these boxed mixes are not suddenly going to get larger again, you have a few choices on how to deal with this modern cake mix shrinkflation when working from older recipes. First, there's the mad scientist option. Invent a time machine, go back to the 1960s, buy up all the classic boxed cake mixes you can fit into your DeLorean or TARDIS, and bring them to the present day. Honestly, this seems like a little bit of overkill, but if you've got that skill set, go for it.

Second, there's the economist's solution: wait until the mix you use most often goes on sale, buy in bulk, pour out multiple mixes into an air-tight storage container, and measure out a perfect 18 ounces whenever you're working from a pre-recession recipe. This involves the least amount of math and tinkering, so it's probably the easiest solution. Also, considering most boxed cake mixes will only run you a couple bucks on sale, it's not cost-prohibitive.

Third, if you'd prefer to do the math, you can figure the percentage differences and adjust the vintage recipe's ingredients accordingly — meaning slightly less egg, slightly less oil, and slightly less 7-Up or bourbon whiskey or whatever else grandma liked to add into the mix. You could also switch it up and add back the missing bulk by using plain all-purpose flour. It's not a perfect solution, but it will work. And let's all remember here that no matter what, there's really no such thing as bad cake.

Recommended