Swiss Miss Vs Starbucks: Which Hot Cocoa Mix Is Actually Healthier?
We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.
A steaming cup of hot cocoa instantly brightens any cold day and can easily be part of a healthy diet when enjoyed in moderation. That said, chocolate lovers watching their nutritional intake may still want to choose a product that is lower in fat, sugar, or calories. To help you make a decision, we compared two popular hot cocoa mix brands, Swiss Miss and Starbucks, and determined that Starbucks is the healthier choice.
Though one envelope of Swiss Miss Milk Chocolate Hot Cocoa Mix contains 39 grams of powder and one serving of Starbucks Classic Hot Cocoa Mix is 28 grams, you typically use the whole envelope to make a cup of cocoa, so we compared the nutrition facts directly. Swiss Miss is the ultimate nostalgic winter drink for many, while Starbucks cocoa feels more grown-up, with a slightly richer and less sweet taste. This difference is reflected in the nutritional profiles: Swiss Miss delivers 34 grams of carbs per serving, with 28 being sugar, while Starbucks' cocoa contains 22 grams of carbs, with 17 being sugar.
Additionally, Swiss Miss cocoa has 160 calories and 170 milligrams of sodium per serving, while Starbucks contains 100 calories and no sodium. Both mixes deliver 2.5 grams of fat, but Starbucks has more protein and fiber at 2 grams and 3 grams, respectively, whereas Swiss Miss contains 1 gram of protein and less than 1 gram of fiber. With less of the stuff that some people might avoid and a slightly higher amount of beneficial nutrients, Starbucks ultimately wins.
How to make your hot cocoa a bit lighter, no matter the brand
No matter which product you use, there are ways to prepare hot cocoa mix that make it a little lighter nutritionally. First of all, know the difference between hot cocoa and hot chocolate: The latter uses chocolate as opposed to cocoa powder, making it richer, heavier, and higher in calories and fat. If you're aiming for a lighter sweet treat, choose hot cocoa products over hot chocolate.
While debates rage on about whether milk or water is better for hot chocolate, water will definitely make for a leaner beverage, though it lacks the richer flavor and mouthfeel of milk-based hot cocoa. A good compromise is to use skim or low-fat milk, or unsweetened plant-based milks, which are often lower in calories, fat, and sugar than dairy. Lastly, changing up your toppings can let you have fun with your cocoa while sticking to your goals. Try using sugar-free marshmallows, making your own unsweetened whipped cream, or go for naturally sugar- and fat-free toppings like a dash of cinnamon.
On the other hand, you might prefer to enjoy a nice, rich cocoa on occasion, rather than a lighter cup on the regular. In that case, make your cocoa with whole milk or coconut milk — the ultimate dairy alternative for rich hot chocolate — and kick it up with hot cocoa upgrades from salted caramel to Nutella. After all, the beauty of cocoa mix is that you can prepare it in any way you like.