Forget Pie: Add These 13 Store-Bought Pumpkin Desserts To Your Cart Instead

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

Pumpkin pie may be a popular and favorite fall treat for many, but there are plenty of other pumpkin desserts worth adding to the fold. If you like pumpkin as much as I do, you're likely aware of how many classic sweet options there are. Making something from scratch is one way to go, but there are a number of reasons why you might turn to a store-bought delight. Convenient, store-bought pumpkin treats are widely available, so let me walk you through which ones are worth reaching for. 

I based my recommendations on insights gleaned from online reviews, Tasting Table rankings, and my own experience. These reviews and outlets highlight rich flavors, captivating, layered textures, and generous size, among other things. You're in for a treat, as there is something for every occasion and taste bud — whether that's a dessert that's complex and creamy or spiced and crunchy.

Prices are as of the date of publication and may vary based on region.

Aldi is a top spot for some fascinating seasonal eats, but one of the best among them is the Bake Shop Pumpkin Cookie Sandwiches. For $4.99, you get 12 pumpkin spice sandwich cookies, which feature a cinnamon cream cheese filling for the perfect combination of autumnal essentials. They're peanut- and tree nut-free, making them accessible to a wider range of customers. 

The treats fared pretty well in a previous Tasting Table ranking of various fall products from Aldi. Our taster noted that the filling wasn't too intensely flavored and had both sweet and spicy notes. They are definitely delectable, and their small size makes them easy to eat — I mean, there are technically 24 cookies, but they're small enough that they still seem mini even when they are sandwiched together. Other reviewers note that they really enjoyed the Aldi bakery item and even went back to the store to buy a second container because they were devoured so quickly.

Next time you are walking the grocery store aisles, don't forget to pick up a can of Pillsbury Grands! Pumpkin Spice Rolls. They're proof that you don't have to make something from scratch for it still to taste good. The limited-edition item comes with five large pumpkin spice rolls with a pumpkin spice icing. It actually uses Cinnabon cinnamon to achieve a great and familiar flavor. This is available at many retailers, but it costs $4.69 at Target, where one reviewer gave it a "1000000/10." 

Others consider it an affordable product that isn't too sugary and makes a fantastic option for a fall breakfast. Walmart reviewers mention that they like to buy extra to stock in the freezer and enjoy them throughout the year, which is a strategic move since they are limited-edition. As you can imagine, many people even wish they were a year-round product. They're marvelously versatile since you can bake them as instructed, pop them in the air fryer, or get creative by placing a roll in a muffin tin.

Trader Joe's is known for introducing various seasonal products. I've tried a bunch of fall TJ's items, and particularly liked the Pumpkin Cream Cheese Croissants, which you can locate in the bakery area near the breads and other baked goods. They are kind of small, though, with two pastries per $3.99 pack, so it may take a keen eye to find them. However, this pumpkin dessert packs a memorable punch with its flaky, buttery exterior and rich pumpkin cream cheese center. They feel like something you'd get at a local bakery for a higher cost.

The spices — cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, and clove — are especially warming and pleasant. Other people seem to appreciate that they're not too sweet, which is something I noticed as well. We called them out as one of the top October 2026 products to get at TJ's, so know that they're worth purchasing on your next trip to the store. TJ's items are known to disappear at random, so get them while you can. 

Costco cheesecakes are iconic, so it makes sense that the pumpkin version would be just as good, perhaps even better than the original. This pumpkin item was deemed a worthy purchase by another Tasting Table writer in a roundup of fall desserts from Costco. The hefty Kirkland Signature Pumpkin Cheesecake with Whipped Topping costs $21.99, so it's on the higher end of the spectrum, but our writer said it is well worth the price tag. 

The cheesecake base has a mouthwatering texture, blending creamy and fluffy notes; some have described it as mousse-like. The flavor offers cream cheese tanginess but enough sweetness and pumpkin to make it interesting. "This was the best cake from [Costco]. I enjoyed every single bite," one person commented on Instagram. Others consider it one of the tastiest cheesecakes you can buy in a grocery store. The distinct layers set it apart from other standard cheesecake offerings, making it a memorable addition to the dessert table this season.

If you're not looking for something as enormous as a cheesecake that serves 16, opt for the Kirkland Signature Pumpkin Streusel Muffins instead. You'll get a pack of eight delightful muffins with paper muffin liners that make them look elevated. When our reviewer tried the muffins, they enjoyed their pleasant aroma, textural contrast, moistness, and satisfying streusel chunks. 

The spices and pumpkin are a classic combo and create a notable baked treat that you can enjoy with a cup of coffee for a morning pairing or save them for dessert. There's also a hint of butteriness that makes it even more comforting for autumn. There's no wrong time for a muffin, especially since this pack is only $6.99. 

Though they're delectable enough to eat straight from the plastic container, others suggest warming them for a few seconds, cutting them in half, and adding a pat of butter over top. But you could go the more decadent route and crumble one over a Costco ice cream cup from the food court.

You can find a delectable range of Alden's Organic ice cream flavors. I like the Banana Cookie Crumble for something more fruity and whimsical, but another writer ranked the Chocolate Chocolate Chip as the crème de la crème. Given that it has so many flavors, it's not surprising that its Pumpkin Spice Ice Cream is a stellar grocery store pumpkin dessert. 

Some reviewers say that the spices are reminiscent of eggnog and that the ice cream has a pleasant creaminess. The ice cream contains pumpkin, cinnamon, clove, as well as nutmeg and ginger extracts, so it really brings a warm, spiced flavor to every bite. You can find this limited-edition ice cream at retailers like Sprouts for $11.99. It's totally delightful on its own, but people also think it pairs well with apple crisp or when served in a cone or on top of waffles. It's the perfect flavor for those who like ice cream on cold days. One TikTok creator even made a video for turning this ice cream into a cold-foam topper for coffee. Sounds gourd to me.

Nestle Toll House is a powerhouse in the cookie world. The brand's Pumpkin Spice Cookies with White Morsels are a highly coveted seasonal staple that people think taste fantastic and have an interesting flavor that's not overwhelming. The latter can happen with pumpkin-spiced products. The white chocolate chips add a little bit of texture, some creaminess, and sweetness for a well-rounded experience. They were called out as a favorite in a Reddit thread asking about what the best pumpkin spice products are.  

It is the perfect treat to get when you want to feed a larger crew because each pack yields 20 cookies and can be ready in under 15 minutes. You can find these at Hy-Vee for $4.99, but they are also available at many other retailers during the fall season. Customers praise the cookie's gooeyness and the appropriate level of pumpkin spice; one person even compared it to a gingerbread cookie, possibly due to the inclusion of molasses and spices. That's to say they are richly spiced and a great alternative to standard cookie flavors. To elevate them further, try topping them with a cream cheese frosting.

Next time you're shopping at Walmart, don't overlook bettergoods Pumpkin Chai Cheesecake, which you can find with the frozen desserts. It is a wonderfully complex frozen treat made with kosher dairy. The creamy sweet has a pumpkin filling with chai spices, such as cardamom, cinnamon, ginger, black pepper, anise, and clove. This creates a delightfully multi-dimensional and rich option that you might not think came from the Walmart freezer aisle. Customer reviews think the spices pair really nicely with the thick cream cheese base. 

Though it's meant to be served thawed, reviewers say they like it somewhat frozen. Others appreciate the size, which comes with two cheesecakes weighing in at 8.04 ounces total. It costs $5.47, but with rave reviews praising its flavor, creaminess, richness, and depth, it could very well pass for something more expensive. This adds a little more intrigue to your average pumpkin spice product thanks to the range of spices. You might want to grab more than one box if freezer space permits.

I enjoy Entenmann's products because they are nostalgic and comforting. The Entenmann's Pumpkin Spice Donuts are appreciated by customers for their dynamic taste and rich texture. The glaze is particularly tasty and pairs well with the pumpkin-y donut; it is thinly applied so it doesn't overwhelm the donut. Plenty of customer reviews think they are fantastic and that they have an approachable sweetness. I also like them because the texture remains fresh for a couple of days after opening; they don't get stale in the blink of an eye.

People say they're moist, fresh, and tender, to the point that they almost melt in the mouth. Others praise the pumpkin flavor as well as the amount of spice. Customers share that it's a festive fall product, so it's worth adding to your cart next time you're at Albertsons, Walmart, or another retailer that carries them. "Better than most factory products," one Walmart reviewer said. Even those who aren't usually fans of pumpkin spice products say they really love this Entenmann's one. A pack of eight donuts costs $5.99 at Albertsons.

Those looking for a frozen fall treat can find this delicious option on their next Target run. The Favorite Day Frozen Pumpkin Spice Ice Cream Bites are a chic addition to your freezer thanks to their dome-like structure — they look like they could be bonbons. This creation features silky pumpkin-spice ice cream and a chocolatey shell. Each pack comes with 12 morsels and is priced at $5.49. Reviews on the Target website discuss how balanced this treat is. The chocolate isn't too thin, and the interior isn't overwhelmingly spiced. 

People appreciate the creaminess paired with that crunchy shell, which makes for a captivating combination. I think they look quite nice and expensive; they could be a great option for a date night or just an afternoon treat. The number of reviews and high ratings make it an enticing pick for a store-bought pumpkin dessert. Target knows these are irresistible because the serving size is actually the entire 12-bite container, but reviewers say three is plenty to feel satisfied. The bite-sized individual portions in a tray make it convenient to take out of the freezer and serve to guests.

Don't worry; I didn't forget about the Sam's Club members out there. Member's Mark New York Style Pumpkin Cheesecake, which sells for $18.84, is an incredibly popular item with thousands of fans. That means it certainly isn't an underdog in the world of store-bought pumpkin desserts. This product uses a New York-style cheesecake swirled with pumpkin, so you get a little bit of both in each bite. There's a graham cracker crust and a whipped cream top for added complexity and a medley of textures.

Many shoppers praise this cheesecake, so you can rest assured that it's a worthy addition to your cart. It doesn't hurt that it's versatile, as people note that they enjoy it both frozen and thawed. "I would stock my whole freezer full of nothing but this if I could," one extremely satisfied reviewer said. Others appreciate its size, which makes it perfect for parties. One reviewer said they knew it was a hit at the gathering, so they went back to the store to get another one before it was out of season. The precut portions make it easy to serve, and it looks too elegant to have come from Sam's Club's freezer section. It's one of the top Sam's Club fall treats to get for good reason.

The Signature Select Pumpkin Coffee Cake Danish is available at Albertsons Companies stores, such as Vons and Albertsons, for $6.99. It features a wheat flour and malted barley flour base and a tasty pumpkin cream cheese filling. The icing swirled over top adds sweetness without making it overwhelming, and the pastry base isn't too sweet, which is something that reviewers appreciate. It's the ideal product to get that feels breakfast-y enough, but you could easily eat it for a random snack or post-dinner dessert. 

It's a convenient delight served straight out of the container and is the ideal grocery store item to get when you're entertaining a crowd. It'll be gone before you know it. I particularly appreciated the softness of the pastry coupled with the spiced, pumpkin-forward notes of the filling. "Wish this wasn't just seasonal," one reviewer noted on the product page on Albertsons' website. You might walk right past this, but it is worth looking around for while it's in stock; you won't regret it. The spiced notes would pair well with a cozy drink like a London fog latte or even a cocktail like a spiced chai old fashioned.

I love Tate's Bake Shop's crisp cookies because they have a more unique texture than other store-bought cookies. They feel fresh, like you just made them and waited for them to cool and firm up. Tate's Bake Shop Pumpkin Spice Cookies with White Chocolate Chips are packed with scrumptious, natural-tasting flavors that fans love. You can find them in stock at Albertsons for $6.99 and at other grocers during the fall season.

One reviewer says they were a bit hesitant to purchase them, but the limited-edition treats won them over. "My family unanimously considers them to have the best taste, crunch and sweetness," they said. Other people say they're happy the cookies are only available seasonally; otherwise, they'd eat them all the time; I totally get that because it's easy to eat several of these thin cookies at a time. The white chocolate chips offer a creamy reprieve from the otherwise crunchy cookie base. The flavors help it stand out from the classic chocolate chip Tate's cookie, making it a heavenly treat for the fall season.

I selected items that had glowing customer reviews or past Tasting Table reviews; I also included my insights when relevant, as I have tried some of the items or certain brands and have a deeper understanding of their offerings. I was looking for various pumpkin sweets that offered a range of flavors and textures; otherwise, cupcakes and muffins could have dominated the list. 

It was important to find diversity in the grocery store offerings as I didn't want any single retailer to dominate the list. I capped a single store's recommendations to two items. It was important to find reviews that praised various aspects of the baked goods to help make each option more well-rounded. I specifically sought out positive sentiments from customers regarding the store's bakery products and other larger name brands.