The Best Flavored Peanut Butter On The Market Outshines Jif And Justin's

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

If peanut butter is a staple in your household, chances are you have a go-to brand that you pick up every time your jar is empty. But when was the last time you tried a different brand? We get it: Changing things up can be hard, especially with something as subjective as peanut butter. But with so many options in the peanut butter aisle, it doesn't hurt to give a new one a try every once in a while. Besides, trying new foods is good for your brain. So, if you're feeling adventurous, we recommend beginning with Cocomo's Coconut Creamy Peanut Butter.

In our ranking of flavored peanut butters — which included products like Justin's Honey Peanut Butter and Jif's Peanut Butter and Chocolate Flavored Spread — we ranked Cocomo's Coconut Creamy Peanut Butter as number one. As the name suggests, it's made with roasted peanuts and not one, but three coconut-based ingredients: coconut syrup, coconut cream, and coconut oil.

Although this was one of the runniest peanut butters we tried, it has an incredibly smooth texture. The runniness also makes it work great as a topping; you can drizzle it directly over acai bowls or chia pudding cups without needing to thin it out first. And beyond its texture, Cocomo's peanut butter tastes excellent. The coconut and peanut combination is, quite simply, heavenly, making this a peanut butter we'll definitely buy again.

We're not the only ones who have ranked Cocomo's Coconut Creamy Peanut Butter highly. Fans have shared their praise online, in both the Amazon and Target product review sections.

One reviewer shared the view opinion on the peanut butter's runniness, noting that it has a "lovely drippy texture for drizzling over cottage cheese bowls." We hadn't even thought of that, but that sounds like a brilliant breakfast plan. If you're feeling hesitant about the product's runniness, another fan suggests storing it in the fridge "for a thicker consistency." This is certainly the easiest way to thicken runny peanut butter without adding anything.

Regarding the flavor of this Cocomo product, the majority of fans give it a 10 out of 10. It "tastes like you're on a tropical island," one fan noted. The flavor is "so unique," said another. If you've never had coconut-based peanut butter before, most fans agree that the flavor isn't overwhelming. It's "just enough for you to come back wanting more," one reviewer wrote.

Some folks have admitted to eating it by the spoonful, and we absolutely support that. Other reviewers said it works on a sandwich (coconut peanut butter and jelly, anyone?), drizzled over ice cream, with apple slices, and stuffed inside dates. However you choose to enjoy this peanut butter, we can guarantee that it won't be very hard to fall in love with it.