Not Silk Or So Delicious: This Is The Best Dairy-Free Yogurt In Stores

Yogurt is the ideal choice for discerning diners who like a little culture in their food, and the many non-dairy options currently available make yogurt accessible to even more appetites and dietary needs. Though Silk and So Delicious are two brands practically synonymous with non-dairy products, neither one managed to break the top three in Tasting Table's rankings of dairy-free yogurt brands. This unique honor belongs to none other than Siggi's.

Known primarily for its dairy-based offerings, Siggi's is a big-name yogurt brand with dairy-free options that shoppers seem to love. Per Tasting Table's assessment, the best thing about Siggi's dairy-free yogurt is its selection of fulfilling flavors, crave-worthy consistency, and impressive protein content. At around 10 grams per serving, this makes it especially beneficial for those who need to bulk up their mealtime.

Fan feedback for the dairy-free products from Siggi's is generally positive and notably enthusiastic. One Redditor shares, "Best dairy free yogurt is hands down Siggi's." They also indicate a particular fondness for the peach and strawberry flavors. Another commenter mentions, "I've been getting the big tubs of the vanilla flavor (I personally like the vanilla cinnamon though too) I totally agree, it's the best and decently cheap if you get the big tub!"

Amid fanfare for Siggi's dairy-free yogurt, there are, of course, some detractors. One Redditor shares, "I tried this [exact] flavor and hated it ... I like thick, sour Greek yogurt and this was like no bueno." Other replies allege a burnt and sour taste with a watery consistency. Nonetheless, the majority of dairy-free devotees appear to find the yogurt at least mildly tolerable, with one Reddit user noting, "By itself it's not mind blowing but I had it in a breakfast bowl with some granola, chopped apple and a little almond butter and it was really good."

Bucking the trend of Silk and So Delicious, one Redditor points out, "I always used to be Silk dairy free yogurt girl but switched to both Siggi's or Cocojune recently to get in more protein." Elsewhere on Reddit, a commenter says, "Out of the few I've tried, Siggi's plant based is the best. it's a little sweet but still has that "tangy" flavor that a lot of nondairy yogurt is lacking."

For those who don't adhere to an exclusively dairy-free diet, you'll also be pleased to know that Siggi's Whole Milk yogurt and nonfat yogurt placed third and seventh, respectively, in Tasting Table's rankings of high-protein yogurts. Given the brand's popularity among dairy-based offerings as well as being selected the best in dairy-free varieties, there's a lot to enjoy from Siggi's.