We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

Store-Bought Brownies Vs Brownie Mix: Which Is More Cost-Effective?

When it comes to satisfying a chocolate craving, brownies are a crowd-pleaser. But is it cheaper to grab a prepackaged tray of store-bought brownies or whip up a batch using a brownie mix? Here's how it stacks up.

Advertisement

Store-bought brownies, like those from the bakery section or prepackaged brands, typically cost around $7 and up for a tray of 4-18 brownies, depending on the brand and size. While convenient, the cost per serving can be higher than homemade alternatives. Brownie mix, on the other hand, offers a more wallet-friendly option. A box of mix usually costs between $1.50 and $3 and requires just a few pantry staples like eggs and oil. 

Even with the added costs of those ingredients if you don't already have them on hand, a pan of homemade brownies from a boxed mix often comes in under $5 — and you tend to get a larger batch. Plus, you can adjust the mix to your liking by adding extras like nuts or chocolate chips. So, when it comes to cost-effectiveness, brownie mix takes the cake (or brownie), especially if you bake often or enjoy experimenting with flavors. The only downside? A little extra time and effort are required.

Advertisement

Which type of brownie fits your lifestyle best?

So, now that we've cracked the numbers, let's talk about how store-bought brownies and brownie mix fit into your life. Because honestly, the right choice depends on your situation. If you're short on time — say you're heading to a last-minute gathering or juggling things on a busy weeknight — store-bought brownies are a lifesaver. They're ready to go, and you can mix and match for more options — some with nuts, some without — so there's something for everyone.

Advertisement

Convenience is king here. In fact, 77% of consumers said convenience is a key factor when making buying decisions, according to a Morgan Stanley consumer trends report, and store-bought brownies definitely deliver on that front. But if you have more time, boxed brownie mix opens up a world of possibilities. You can experiment with add-ins or toppings (peanut-butter chocolate brownies, anyone?), and easily cater to dietary preferences — whether you're looking for gluten-free, vegan, or keto (like this Duncan Hines keto-friendly box). It's a quick and customizable way to meet your needs and enjoy a sweet treat. 

You can also play around with pan sizes. If you're hosting a party, you could make a big batch in a 9x13-inch pan and cut it into plenty of pieces. But if it's a cozy gathering or just for yourself, opt for an 8x8-inch pan, and cut it into fewer, larger pieces. It's less about which option is better, as both can be cost-effective, and more about what works for you right now. Some days call for quick and easy, while others invite a bit of creativity and effort. Either way, the brownies are bound to be delicious.

Advertisement

Recommended

Advertisement