Which Creamy Peanut Butter Is Actually The Healthiest?

Add Tasting Table on Google:
Google Discover

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

Peanut butter is one of the original plant-based protein spreads, so it seems like a no-brainer to always keep a jar in your pantry for convenient snacking and lunchtime sandwiches. But not all peanut butters are created equal. We asked Kelsey Kunik, the registered dietitian behind Graciously Nourished, to give us the 411 on how to pick out the healthiest creamy peanut butter. 

Your first step is to scan the ingredient label on the jar. "Creamy peanut butter that contains limited ingredients," Kunik explains, "such as only peanuts or peanuts and a small amount of salt, is often the healthiest choice." For that reason, she specifically recommends Crazy Richard's 100% Peanuts creamy peanut butter, as it has just one ingredient: peanuts. Many creamy peanut butters, especially certain ones from our childhood, contain added sugars, palm oil, and other stabilizers that quickly turn a simple food into a heavily processed spread. 

Kunik admits you'll have to stir most natural peanut butters well before using, but that's a small price to pay for cutting out those added ingredients. "It mixes well, tastes great, and doesn't have extra added sugars, fat, or sodium beyond what you'd find naturally in peanuts," she adds. A small amount of salt is perfectly reasonable if you want a more savory flavor, but unsalted varieties are available if you're watching your sodium intake. 

Try to avoid added sugars and oils

Many conventional peanut butters contain added sugars, molasses, and hydrogenated vegetable oils — arguably to appeal to children's palates. This makes for a sweeter spread with smoother consistency, but they're unnecessary, especially when natural peanut butter is nutritious in and of itself. We're not saying added sugar is the enemy, but try to save it for desserts, not your sandwich. "You don't have to avoid all added sugars," Kunik says, "but when you eat them ... in foods you don't expect sugar to be in, like peanut butter, you can easily eat more than you intend to throughout the day."

You will likely have to stir your natural peanut butter, as the layer of oil that collects on top is a normal result of not having added stabilizers. If this pains you, keeping it in the refrigerator will not only keep it fresher, it'll also prevent separation. Also note that we recently ranked eight peanut butter brands with no added sugars or oils, including some that don't require any stirring.

The good news is that the healthiest peanut butter isn't necessarily the most expensive or hard-to-find. Just follow Kunik's advice and always flip the jar around to read the ingredients. If the list only contains peanuts, or peanuts and salt, you've done all the homework you need.

Recommended