The Underrated Ingredient That Gives Pumpkin Pie A Creamy Protein Boost
Cottage cheese likely isn't the first thing that comes to mind when you're prepping pumpkin pie, but dietitian Kelsey Kunik, the registered dietitian behind Graciously Nourished considers it an underrated ingredient. "Because cottage cheese blends so smoothly, it can easily replace heavy cream or evaporated milk in desserts while adding a big protein boost," she said. It's a smart swap, and you don't have to give up any of the familiar spiced pumpkin flavors to make it all work together.
If you're working with a classic pumpkin pie recipe, Kunik shared advice on how to replace the sweetened condensed milk in the recipe with cottage cheese: "substitute half the amount of cottage cheese and half the amount of milk, then blend the cottage cheese and milk together until silky smooth." Cottage cheese naturally has creamy curds, so you'll want to whirl them in a high-speed blender to create a thick, smooth filling before you add the pumpkin puree, spices, and eggs.
This recipe isn't just about protein-maxxing, although it's certainly a big perk. Cottage cheese can also reduce fat content, "especially if you're using it in place of heavy cream, while also boosting calcium and B vitamins," said Kunik. That's a lot of pros for a slice of pie.
Use full-fat cottage cheese for a richer, creamier filling
The exact amount of protein you'll actually add to the pie will depend on the brand and how much cottage cheese you use, but rest assured, it'll certainly boost its nutritional benefits. Beyond that, you'll also want to choose a cottage cheese brand with high-quality ingredients. Your pie (and you) deserve it.
For the creamiest filling, make sure you thoroughly blend the cottage cheese into the pumpkin pie filling. Simply stirring it won't work, or you'll have to explain to your guests why your pie has little white curds floating throughout. Full-fat cottage cheese is also recommended, as it will obviously give it the richest taste and creamiest texture.
Once you pop the pie in the oven, be sure not to overbake it. Like the traditional pumpkin, it's a custard pie, so it can become tough or grainy. The center should still have a little jiggle when you take it out; it'll set once it cools on the counter. Finally, remember to store that precious pie in the fridge, as it has both dairy and eggs in it. No doubt, cottage cheese is everywhere in 2026. Why not add it to your pumpkin pie?