The Other Southern All-You-Can-Eat Buffet That Outshines Shoney's And Golden Corral

Add Tasting Table on Google:
Google Discover

The heyday of buffet chains may be behind us, but there are still a few out there kicking, including some serving down-home Southern comfort food. While Shoney's (based in Tennessee) and Golden Corral (based in North Carolina) are some of the biggest players, the smaller Western Sizzlin chain edged them out in our ranking of seven major all-you-can-eat buffet chains. According to our writer, the chain's buffet offerings include an "affordable" and "robust" selection of Southern comfort food, with favorites like steak tips, barbecue pork ribs, mac and cheese, and fruit cobblers.

Founded in 1962 in Augusta, Georgia, by Nick Pascarella, Western Sizzlin made its claim to fame with its signature Gold Dust steak seasoning and clever FlameKist grilling process that cooks the top and bottom of the steak at the same time. This was a winning formula, helping this iconic steakhouse chain take over in the '80s and expand into the buffet business in the 1990s under the names The Great American Buffet and Wood Grill Buffet. Today the chain is still hanging in there, albeit with a much smaller number of locations, mainly in the Southeast.

While our writer notes that "inconsistency seems to be an issue," Western Sizzlin still ranked ahead of Shoney's in our buffet-chain ranking, which drew complaints about limited selection and relatively high prices. And while Golden Corral still boasts hundreds of locations and over 150 items, our writer notes that its overall Yelp ratings are low, with customers complaining about a decline in food quality.

What diners really think of Western Sizzlin

While Western Sizzlin managed to beat out Southern competitors Golden Corral and Shoney's in our ranking, do others feel the same way? In social media threads putting the major buffets head to head, Shoney's appears to be a favorite, especially for its breakfast buffet, though Golden Corral also offers a massive weekend breakfast buffet. Only a couple of commenters called out Western Sizzlin as their go-to spot. Despite its generally poor Yelp ratings, many who've been going there for years remain loyal to the buffet chain.

One TikTok creator marveled over the selection at Western Sizzlin and declared it the best buffet in North Carolina. Another shared how they make the hour-and-40-minute drive to their nearest location, citing the food, service, and nostalgia as reasons they keep coming back. However, not everyone has had a great experience there. One TikToker said "the buffet overall kind of was a hit or a miss," with many of their favorite items not even available. A commenter added on to the post, saying "as a local, we stay away."

When it comes to Golden Corral, one TikTok creator shared how they wished they had a Western Sizzlin near them instead. All in all, Western Sizzlin's buffet experience may depend on which location you visit — but if you track down a good one, you might just find yourself going back for seconds.

Recommended