Which Is Actually Healthier, Unreal Milk Chocolate Gems Or M&M's?
When you think of healthy food, chocolate candy probably isn't the first association, but life's far too short not to indulge in sweet treats, especially when we do so in moderation. Even though most consumers likely understand candy as an occasional snack, there's no denying that people are continuously seeking out healthier options for their sweets — and the brands are listening.
Unreal is one such brand that's catering to health-conscious consumers with its products, like the Unreal Milk Chocolate Gems, which are a spin on the classic Milk Chocolate M&M's. But is the Unreal version actually healthier? Yes, it is. By looking at these two candies you can immediately spot that they come in a variety of bright colors, and that's precisely where the two ingredient lists show the biggest difference.
The Unreal Milk Chocolate Gems are colored with three simple, natural items: turmeric, beet juice, and spirulina extract. The Milk Chocolate M&M's, on the other hand, contain quite the laundry list of synthetic, petroleum-based food colors: Blue 1 lake, yellow 6, red 40, yellow 5, blue 1, yellow 6 lake, red 40 lake, yellow 5 lake, blue 2 lake, and blue 2. In 2025, the FDA announced that it's actively working to eliminate these dyes from food items in favor of natural alternatives. The M&M's label also notes that the product contains bioengineered food ingredients, which the Unreal candies don't.
Unreal Milk Chocolate Gems are actually healthier than Milk Chocolate M&M's
Consumers widely appreciate the more natural composition of the Unreal chocolates, saying that it shows in both texture and color. "I love that the shells are sweet and subtly tangy due to the nature of where the colorings come from," writes one reviewer on the brand's website. Another says, "Your Milk Chocolate Gems are so close to M&Ms it's amazing. Better still, I like your gems better."
The two brands do have some nutritional differences, albeit minor. Both candies have 140 calories per comparable serving. The Unreal Gems are slightly higher in protein, packing in three grams per serving to M&M's single gram. In contrast, the Unreal candies have three more grams of fat — and they're also higher in sodium. That said, the M&M's have more added sugar, with 17 grams per serving to Unreal's 11 grams. And the Unreal brand provides more iron and calcium in their candies.
So, what does this mean for you? Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference on whether you're significantly bothered by the synthetic and bioengineered ingredients (which are certainly the subject of some myths) in the M&M's or whether you need to abide by a lower-fat or lower-sodium diet. But generally speaking, it's fair to say that the natural ingredient list of the Unreal candies, as well as the lower added sugar content, makes them a comparatively healthier choice.