The Absolute Best Banquet Frozen Meal On Store Shelves Is Not The Salisbury Steak

Add Tasting Table on Google:
Google Discover

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

One can only expect so much from pre-made frozen dinners. Still, not all frost-covered boxes are created equal, so to separate the "hits" from the "misses," Tasting Table ranked 11 Banquet frozen meals. In the ranking, the brand's Beef Pot Pie swept the competition, emerging as the tastiest offering and beating Banquet's Salisbury Steak, which came in second place. Don't expect a golden-brown crust piping with curling eddies of steam, but this pot pie definitely gets the job done.

Banquet's Beef Pot Pie is dotted with chunks of beef, potatoes, and vegetables swimming in a luscious gravy. As mentioned in the review, the sparse amount of actual meat and veggies in the mix was a letdown. However, the Beef Pot Pie delivered such an impressive, dimensional flavor that it still managed to cinch first place. The buttery, flaky, made-from-scratch crust doesn't taste at all like it came out of a box, and the standout gravy is rich, bold, and savory enough to satisfy. 

The same praise couldn't be extended to the brand's runner-up Salisbury Steak, which was comparatively lacking in the flavor department. Tasting Table's taste tester isn't the only one who digs the brand's Beef Pot Pie, either. Customer reviews echo our feedback. "This is one of my favorite comfort foods. It always tastes great. I just wish that it had more and/or larger pieces of beef," wrote a customer in their review on the Banquet website. 

Banquet's Beef Pot Pie sets the bar for satisfying frozen entrees

Walmart customers seem to agree, giving Banquet's Beef Pot Pie a 4.5 out of 5 star rating based on 14,000 reviews. Shoppers specifically praise the frozen entree's consistency and price point: "Yummy! I absolutely love pot pies! Beef or Chicken. Pot pies are comfort food. Especially in the colder months. They're so tasty. And extremely affordable," wrote one such customer. Indeed, a 7-ounce Banquet Beef Pot Pie currently costs just $1.00 at Dollar General. The pie also gets points for convenience. 

Banquet Beef Pot Pie can be microwaved in just five minutes, and the 8 grams of protein don't hurt. Elsewhere online, a Redditor raved, "Banquet beef pot pie. Very solid for the price." A commenter chimed in with their personal tip for nailing the reheat: "Gotta wrap the crust in tinfoil and put butter on the top to make it nice and golden." Another added, "Melted cheddar on top and add some garlic for the win!" 

All in all, Banquet's Beef Pot Pie offers a convenient option for busy weeknights. It's long-lasting in the freezer and cost-effective to stock up on. At the end of the day, expecting too much culinary prowess from a frozen dinner brand is an invariable exercise in disappointment. For a truly flavorful beef pot pie, home cooks with a little extra time might take a cue from Tasting Table's Beef Bourguignon Pot Pie recipe, which comes together with just 10 minutes of hands-on prep work.  

Recommended