The Best Store-Bought Pecan Pie Comes From A Popular Chain Known For Its High-Quality Goods
We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.
There are some moments that just call for a gigantic, gooey pecan pie. The iconic American staple is a non-negotiable during the holidays, but it feels just as necessary after a Southern-style meal or at a cookout too. The one small issue is that bakery pies tend to be expensive and you usually have to order them in advance. There's always homemade, of course, but that can be another battle altogether. This is where store-bought comes in, and if you're looking for the best of the best, we suggest heading straight to Whole Foods.
A Tasting Table expert sampled and ranked six store-bought pecan pies and the Whole Foods one outshone the rest by a long shot. Its deep color and rich flavor more than impressed our tester, who loved the sticky center and buttery flavor. The texture was so gooey it almost clung to their teeth in the best way possible, while the crust had a cookie-like flavor that was reminiscent of a delicious shortbread.
Our tester was only able to find a half version of the pie in-store and it was more expensive than the others on the list but they thought it was worth it. If they didn't know it was store-bought, they would have believed it was from a Southern candy shop. It probably shouldn't have been surprising with Whole Foods' reputation for high-quality goods, but it was just so much more decadent and authentic than the pies from the likes of Walmart or Kroger.
The Whole Foods Market Pecan Pie
The Whole Foods Market Pecan Pie is made without hydrogenated fats, high-fructose corn syrup, or bleached flour. It's not exactly homemade but the ingredients list is pretty decent for a huge chain, and customers seem to have taken notice, if online reviews are anything to go by.
One Amazon reviewer wrote on the product page, "I will not buy it from conventional supermarkets or bakeries because of the unhealthy ingredients most of them use. Until I saw this at Whole Foods." Another said it was one of the best pecan pies they had ever tasted, adding, "I have purchased this pie five times within two weeks. Seriously addicting." The sentiment seems to be similar on social media. An Instagram user who posted about the pie said, "The crust is flaky and actually makes an impact on the overall pie ... It's so well baked and each part was executed well."
Some feel the pie is a little too sweet, while others have called it dry. However, these issues seem to fade away when whipped cream is added and customers appreciate that you can get a half or whole version. If you'd rather make your own pecan pie, we have a great recipe. If not, Whole Foods is a fantastic option, and there is a delicious bourbon cream in our maple pot de crème recipe that you can try with it.