Swirl This Classic Southern Condiment With Vanilla Ice Cream For Extra Flavor

Add Tasting Table on Google:
Google Discover

Chili crisp-topped vanilla ice cream has been a trend for a few years, with the cool, creamy ice cream serving as the perfect contrast to fiery, crunchy chili crisp, but there's a milder option for those who might be hesitant to try the pairing, and it's a standout Southern condiment known as pepper jelly.

Pepper jelly has a perfectly spicy-sweet flavor, with spicy pepper flakes and skins suspended in a sweet jelly condiment. You can make your own at home with our hot pepper jelly recipe, or simply pop out to the supermarket for a jar. As beloved as pimento cheese, pepper jelly and cream cheese is a classic Southern snack combo, typically served as an appetizer alongside crackers like buttery Ritz. The contrast of smooth, mild cream cheese compared to the slippery, sweet-yet-spicy pepper jelly makes the case that pepper jelly over ice cream is a truly logical pairing.

Sticky, sweet, spicy, and smooth

If you've ever tried sriracha and chocolate ice cream and been pleasantly surprised by the taste, you'd likely enjoy this similar combination of vanilla ice cream topped with pepper jelly. Depending on how it's made, pepper jelly can be mild and fruity to moderately fiery. The pepper used can range from mild bell peppers to moderate jalapeños and serranos all the way to intense habaneros. And because peppers vary in spice levels individually, even different batches of pepper jelly made with the same exact recipe can vary in heat, so always give your pepper jelly a quick taste before slathering it all over a scoop of vanilla ice cream.

In terms of texture, pepper jelly will add a slightly sticky, thick gloss to the ice cream in the best way possible. There may be flecks of peppers that lend a bit of chew, but for the most part the texture will remain smooth as it swirls into the vanilla ice cream as it gradually melts. In addition to the textural and flavor elements, pepper jelly is also a visually arresting contrast against the plain white ice cream. 

For those ice cream lovers who require a bit of crunch in their bowls of ice cream, chopped salted peanuts or almonds would add a great texture to the pepper jelly and vanilla ice cream combo. You could lean into the traditional Southern appetizer and spoon pepper jelly over cream cheese ice cream instead, topping it with crushed up Ritz crackers for an added salty and crunchy element.

Recommended