Captain D's Vs Long John Silver's — Which Has Better Fried Fish?
There are plenty of fish in the sea, though not all are battered and fried to the high standard we might hope for. So, what should you do if offered a choice between Captain D's or Long John Silver's? If you're wondering which carries the better fried fish, our taste tester ranked the fish and chips from eight chain restaurants, finding the answer to be the first — though neither chain came out on top in the ranking. Still, Captain D's emerged as the superior option, placing seventh to LJS' eighth.
Our valiant correspondent ordered the 2-Piece Fish Basket from Long John Silver's and the 2-Piece Fish and Fries Combo from Captain D's. The former was off to a good start, with the fried fish being golden in color and respectably sized. However, the heaviness our critic detected upon picking it up was an ominous preview. "Inside, the white fish was densely packed instead of light and flaky," our reviewer wrote. Bland, disappointingly un-crispy breading didn't help, and the combination resulted in Long John Silver's poor ranking.
At Captain D's, our taste tester was surprised to find that the batter-dipped fillets (also Alaskan pollock) were unusually long and thick, rather than the flatter shape one might expect. While the fish was decent and the texture superior to that of Long John Silver's, the breading left some to be desired. Our reviewer concluded: "It's far too mushy and far too greasy to be enjoyed past just a few bites." Still, it beat the competition.
Not every fast food fan prefers Captain D's to Long John Silver's
While our critic was left unimpressed by both Captain D's and Long John Silver's, the latter's fried fish lacked the redeeming qualities of its competitor. Of course, we're not the only ones to pose these two seafood-oriented franchises against each other. On Reddit, one Long John Silver's fan keen to try Captain D's asked if anyone had some useful comparisons to share. One respondent replied succinctly: "Captain D's is what LJS would be with seasoning."
This wasn't the only positive comment in the victor's favor. Another Redditor who preferred it to its rival added, "I'd say Captain D's isn't as soaked in grease as LJS." However, Long John Silver's is not without its defenders — after all, some customers feel the seafood chain doesn't deserve all the hate. "My LJS will give a cup of crunchy batter pieces with my slaw. Mixing this together is heaven. Captain D's will not," wrote another Redditor on the same thread. "I did the math and prefer LJS." Another user agreed: "Captain D's fish always has an off taste, and the batter is never as good either."
If fried fish is your main concern, you may want to pay heed to our tester's assessment. On the other hand, when Tasting Table embarked upon a more expansive ranking of 19 seafood chain restaurants, Captain D's came in dead last — right behind LJS. Perhaps one ought to let personal preference be their guide.