Skip The Cream For A Tomato-Based Manhattan Clam Chowder Ready In 40 Minutes

Add Tasting Table on Google:
Google Discover

Clam chowder is a quintessential New England delicacy that's made its way across the country over the past two centuries. It was first adapted by European settlers in the 1700s and was traditionally made with fish. New Englanders began taking advantage of the abundant clams, and versions like clearRhode Island chowder and Manhattan clam chowder started to appear. The latter is tomato-based and much lighter than its white counterpart, and it can be made in less than an hour.

Our recipe for Manhattan-style clam chowder is easy to try at home. Instead of relying on milk or heavy cream, this recipe calls for tomato paste and chopped tomatoes in the smooth broth. They add a little sweetness and acidity that brightens the dish and cuts through the salinity, while the usual chowder suspects (clam juice and bacon) ensure that the rich underlying flavor is still there. 

Tarragon also provides an aromatic finish that rounds everything out nicely. It's a totally different experience from a classic New England clam chowder, but it is equally as delicious and perfect for hot or cold days. The best part is that after all of the vegetables and bacon are sauteed, the potatoes and broth only need to boil for 15 minutes.

Making the best Manhattan-style chowder

Because Manhattan-style chowder doesn't rely on cream for decadence, making a flavorful broth is crucial. Use high-quality clam juice, don't skimp on the vegetables, and have your seasonings ready. Homemade vegetable stock will work best, as will a good seafood stock.

Cook the bacon first so that everything else picks up the flavor. We like to use fresh celery, carrots, onion, and garlic, but celery seed is another common addition. A little paprika can also add a hint of smokiness, while bay leaves can add depth. Add the tomato paste before the liquids to bring out the flavor, and feel free to deglaze with white wine instead of clam juice. Some folks also like to incorporate a pinch of chili flakes for a touch of heat.

Fresh clams will have more flavor, but canned clams are fine. As for the potatoes, use something sturdy, like the Russets or Yukon Golds recommended in our recipe. These will thicken the chowder slightly and hold up well in the soup. You can smash them slightly against the side of the pot for an even thicker finish. Top with bacon and oyster crackers for crunch and parsley for freshness.

Recommended