Why One Type Of Granite Countertops Gives Homeowners Buyer's Remorse

Granite is one of the most popular kitchen countertop choices. The stone is incredibly scratch- and heat-resistant (even more so than quartz), plus it is easy to maintain. But while it isn't the most expensive option out there, granite can still be pricey. Cost-conscious homeowners may instead look toward modular granite, but you might want to think again, as these prefabricated options are giving homeowners serious buyer's remorse. 

Instead of having your counters measured and custom-cut, you simply purchase mini slabs of pre-cut granite to complete your project. The pieces are smaller and lighter than granite slabs, which means a homeowner could theoretically install modular granite without hiring a professional. But there are way more cons than pros. The small size of modular granite mini-slabs means a counter will have a lot of seams, increasing the chance that slabs could chip or crack after installation. The mini-slabs are also thinner than those available at a stone warehouse, so the chances that a slab might crack or break is much higher.

If you have an eye for design, you'll also be disappointed by the limited options available for modular granite mini-slabs. Very few suppliers offer modular granite as a countertop material, so you won't be able to shop around for colors and styles to match your aesthetic. Plus, because modular granite isn't widely available, it can be hard to find a reputable source and the mini-slabs will likely have to be shipped to you — which is an expense hassle and includes an additional breakage risk.

First and foremost, consider a granite slab from a local stone warehouse. Entry-level granite is not wildly expensive. It starts at about $95 per square foot. Skipping the exotic stones and unusual colors and instead opting for something more simple and widely available can help keep the costs down. When it's time to choose finishes, pick a basic edge profile like an eased edge (a 90-degree cut with slightly rounded corners) versus something intricate and decorative or a substantial mitered edge.

Looking for a more affordable but equally gorgeous granite alternative? While the price for quartz is fairly comparable to that of granite, you are often able to get a less traditional or more unique style at a lower price. As an engineered countertop material instead of a natural slab, those design elements can be added in the manufacturing process instead of needing to be found in nature.

If you're dreaming of a kitchen counter that makes a major impact and you have a freestanding kitchen island, remember that there's no rule saying the island has to match the rest of the kitchen. Select an eye-catching slab (which might come with a higher price tag) for your island, then choose a simple complementary slab for your wall countertops. You'll still get the drama, but won't have to shell out for a full kitchen's worth of pricey countertops.