The Best S'mores-Flavored Treat In Stores Comes From An Iconic Ice Cream Brand

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

S'mores are a favorite and nostalgic summertime, campfire snack. And while it's hard to beat the experience of roasting marshmallows over an open fire, s'mores don't have to be a once a year treat. Dessert and snack brands have come out with a diverse list of s'mores flavored treat that'll satisfy your craving year round, no campfire necessary. In fact, the best s'mores-flavored product Tasting Table's taste tester sampled is an ice cream flavor from the iconic Ben & Jerry's brand. 

Who better to come up with a creative frozen take on s'mores than Ben & Jerry's? Known for some of the most unique and over-the-top ice cream flavors, our taste tester pitted the brand's Gimme S'more! Toasted Marshmallow ice cream up against solid snacks, and none of them came close in the flavor, texture, or ingenuity. Ben & Jerry's Gimme S'more! Toasted Marshmallow ice cream features a toasted marshmallow base full of chocolate cookie, graham cracker swirls, melt-in-your mouth fudge. 

According to our taste tester, all of the flavors and textures went together perfectly — assimilating the flavor of s'mores you know and love, but in the most inventive and unique way. They got the gritty crunch of graham cracker along with well-distributed fudge flecks, while the toasted marshmallow ice cream was as creamy as could be. Each element was perfectly executed, making the sum of its parts both decadent and nostalgic.

Target customers have give hundreds of 5-star reviews for Ben & Jerry's Gimme S'more! Toasted Marshmallow ice cream, with one review proclaiming it "hands down, my favorite smores ice cream in the world." Customers complimented the balance of flavors and textures. One stated, "The toasted marshmallow ice cream is creamy and sweet, while the chocolate cookie swirls and graham cracker pieces add a nice mix of texture and crunch." To that effect, customers also complimented how the cookie swirls maintained their crunch while the chocolate chunks melted in your mouth. 

The flavor and texture combination of Ben & Jerry's Gimme S'more! Toasted Marshmallow ice cream has been described as "absolutely divine." While a Rocky Road ice cream has actual marshmallows in it, the choice to make the ice cream base, itself, marshmallow-flavored really makes this Ben & Jerry's ice cream stand out. One Target customer stated, "Most ice creams with marshmallow will have a weird texture but this ones nice and creamy with all best chunks!" Most importantly of all, said another customer, "Each bite really captures that classic campfire smores taste."

If you can resist the urge to eat an entire pint in one sitting, you can transform this S'mores flavored ice cream into a decadent s'mores milkshake. If you wanted to bring out the marshmallow flavor even more, you could line the rim of your milkshake glass with marshmallow cream, pressing crushed graham crackers into it for an eye-popping presentation.