• 491


The 10 Best Burgers in NYC

Team TT's favorite patties from Brooklyn to the UES
10 best hamburgers in new york city

We love all kinds of burgers--from squishy fast-food styles to thick bistro beasts--but they've got to have a deep, beefy flavor and good bread that gives way to fresh, thoughtful toppings. Here, in no particular order, are our 10 favorites to eat right now:

? Whitehall in the West Village
This burger ($18) comes with some bonus Australian-style ingredients layered on the caramelized onions, cheddar and thick, juicy puck of meat: pickled beets and an over-easy egg with a nice runny yolk. Messy, but worth it.

? Minetta Tavern in Greenwich Village
The Black Label Burger ($28) is a celebrity among hamburgers, and it rose to fame for a reason: The funky dry-aged meat, griddled with clarified butter, is without equal. The crunchy caramelized onions are divine.

? Blue Collar in Williamsburg
Our vote in the fast food-style category is for the squishy, satisfying burger ($4.50) at this tiny Brooklyn joint. It's layered with tomato, lettuce, white onions and of course, a sticky slice of American cheese. Best eaten immediately.

? Costata in Soho
We forgive the square bread on this delicious, lunch-only steakhouse burger. The excellent White Label Burger ($19) is built with McClure's pickles, American cheese and a smear of bacon marmalade.

? Lafayette in Noho
This Frenchified cheeseburger at Andrew Carmellini's bistro involves a thick, juicy patty of brisket meat and comes with melted Raclette and caramelized onions ($19). It's only available at lunchtime, so treat yourself.

? Montmartre in Chelsea
Michael Toscano's dry-aged brisket and short rib burger ($19) is a rich and superb sandwich of crusty pain au levain draped in a cheesy conconction that involves reduced Béarnaise, tarragon, creamed spinach and sautéed onions. 

? J.G. Melon on the Upper East Side
The NYC institution still serves a fine burger ($10.25). It's a classic, made with onion and pickles on the side, thank you very much, and a plain bun. No need to mess around with a good thing.

? Rosette on the Lower East Side
Housemade pain au lait bread sounds fancy, but it's soft like a burger bun should be. It sandwiches a dry-aged beauty grilled in beef fat, a confit tomato slice and aged cheddar with tons of umami ($17).

? Petey's Burger in Astoria
Until we New Yorkers are afforded our God-given right to an In-N-Out Burger, this Queens spot will have to do. The super soft bun with a thin patty, melted American cheese and lettuce that's never wilting ($4.50) is everything a fast-food-style burger should be.

? Diner in Williamsburg
Of course, Diner's meat is 100% grass-fed beef, ground fresh each day at the butcher shop next door. The crunchy pickles are made in house. The buns are straight from the spectacular SheWolf Bakery. The burger ($15) is also expertly cooked, perfectly charred and full of flavor.

Whitehall 19 Greenwich Ave. New York NY 10014 212-675-7261 Minetta Tavern 113 Macdougal St. New York NY 10012 212-475-3850 Blue Collar 160 Havemeyer St. Brooklyn NY 11211 347-725-3837 Costata 206 Spring St. New York NY 10012 212-334-3320 Lafayette 380 Lafayette St. New York NY 10003 212-533-3000 Montmartre 158 8th Ave. New York NY 10011 646-596-8838 J.G. Melon 1291 3rd Ave. New York NY 10021 212-744-0585 Rosette 171 E Broadway New York NY 10002 212-933-1176 Petey's Burger 30-17 30th Ave, Astoria NY 11102 718-267-6300 Diner 85 Broadway Brooklyn NY 11249 718-486-3077
Want the inside scoop?
get the latest recipes, news and hacks from tasting table
Please check your inbox to verify your email address.

Try Tasting Table's Burger Recipe

Next Step

Field Trip: Rockaway Taco

Keep Reading

Around the Web

Get the Tasting Table newsletter for adventurous eaters everywhere