Auntie Anne's May Be Popular, But Amish-Baked Soft Pretzels Are Worth A Trip To The Countryside
America loves Auntie Anne's for bringing warm, buttery soft pretzels to everyday folks across more than 1,400 U.S. locations, far beyond the brand's Pennsylvania beginnings. However, there is still something special about the traditional, handmade variety. When Tasting Table highlighted several Amish baked goods worth trying, our writer noted how locally made soft pretzels were well-worth the trip through Pennsylvania's Amish countryside, surpassing even those from the beloved pretzel chain.
Our reviewer stopped at Köm-Essa at the Lancaster Central Market in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, and sampled an Amish-baked soft pretzel described as "chewy, doughy, malted, buttery, and full of flavor." Auntie Anne's had previously been our writer's standard for a great soft pretzel, but this one altogether changed that perspective. It also earned these handmade pretzels a spot on the Amish baked goods roundup, alongside the likes of shoofly pie, pecan sticky buns, and whoopie pie.
Of course, this doesn't mean that Auntie Anne's is completely removed from Amish Country tradition. Founder Anne Beiler was raised in an Amish family in Lancaster County, where she learned generational recipes and traditions. In 1988, she launched the first Auntie Anne's pretzel stand at a local farmers market, eventually turning soft pretzels into an everyday phenomenon at malls and airports. Even so, they don't quite beat the Amish offering our reviewer deemed was "everything a soft pretzel should be."
Lancaster County harbors more than one memorable pretzel stop
In addition to our writer's experience at Köm-Essa, the Lancaster countryside harbors plenty of other opportunities to discover soft pretzels with Pennsylvania Dutch roots. In fact, Tasting Table's guide to finding the best soft pretzels in the U.S. highlights a few, including Immergut Hand-Rolled Soft Pretzels near Kitchen Kettle Village in Intercourse, Pennsylvania. These pretzels emerge from the oven with a chewy texture and are dipped in butter for a notably rich finish.
Another standout pretzel included in the guide comes from Busy Bee's Farm Market, perched just down the road in Ronks, PA. This stop was emphasized for offering potentially the best (or, at least, most intriguing) hand-twisted Dutch-style soft pretzel on the list, presenting with a subtly crispy exterior amidst loads of dripping butter. And don't sleep on America's first commercial pretzel bakery: Julius Sturgis Pretzel Bakery in Lititz, PA, which has been in operation since 1861.
Fortunately, you don't have to hit the highway every time a craving for authentic soft pretzels hits. Our traditional soft pretzel recipe makes it possible to recreate the pillowy magic at home using bread flour, yeast, beer, and butter, plus a baking-soda bath for the telltale browned exterior. To develop the most flavor, just let the dough rise overnight in your refrigerator. That said, true Amish-style hand-rolled pretzels aren't exactly a quick baking foray in the kitchen, as they will take a bit of practice and patience. But if you just can't wait, there's always Auntie Anne's.