The Pappy Van Winkle Red Flag To Know Before Buying It Online

Add Tasting Table on Google:
Google Discover

It can be hard enough finding a bottle of Pappy Van Winkle at a legitimate, brick-and-mortar liquor store. If you're buying online, that can add another level of stress — because counterfeit whiskey is a real thing. Along with $20 bills, olive oil, and Chanel bags, fake Pappy is out there. With prices for the especially rare Pappy expressions regularly reaching into the thousands of dollars on the secondary market, the brand has become the perfect target for scammers. Luckily, there are plenty of ways to spot a fake Pappy Van Winkle, so you don't end up buying a bottle of Jim Beam instead.

The biggest red flag is an online seller offering Pappy without a credible way to establish exactly where the bottle came from. A legitimate label, convincing packaging, and a high-quality product photo just isn't going to cut it anymore. These days, counterfeiters are actually using empty bottles of Pappy, so if you're shopping remotely, there's no opportunity to inspect the bottle or packaging before entering your payment information. 

The risk is so real that in 2017, Buffalo Trace and the Van Winkle family announced they had spent more than half a million dollars trying to combat online counterfeiting. The brand has also repeatedly warned consumers to never buy Van Winkle bottles on the secondary market. In fact, the company has even pursued legal action to shut down fake websites and contacted social media companies to request that scammer accounts be removed.

Avoid shopping for Pappy using online marketplaces and private sellers

While there are some visual clues that can help you spot a suspicious bottle, it's tricky to guarantee authenticity based purely on appearances. Buffalo Trace's brand director has highlighted mismatched labels and bottle capsules (the foil covering the top) as signs of a counterfeit whiskey, but it's not a perfect system, as capsules have been stolen from Buffalo Trace's bottling plant in the past.

Of course, not every online listing is fraudulent. Some licensed liquor retailers advertise rare bottles online, allowing customers to check availability or place an order. But be wary of unusually low prices, vague answers, or websites that promise to ship anywhere, regardless of state laws. Liquor laws are complex and vary from state to state, but private individuals typically cannot legally wrap up a bottle of whiskey and ship it to someone else. In the vast majority of cases, only properly licensed businesses shipping via FedEx or UPS can legally mail you "intoxicating liquor."

That's exactly why you should avoid shopping for whiskey on Craigslist, eBay, Facebook Marketplace, or any other sites that aren't established retailers. But not all hope is lost. There are still plenty of ways you can score a bottle of real Pappy Van Winkle, such as getting on a first-name basis with the manager of your local liquor store. The thing about Pappy Van Winkle is if it looks and sounds too good to be true, it probably is.

Recommended