Aldi Shoppers Say This Gourmet Frozen Dessert Tastes Homemade

With the right frozen desserts, hosting won't require nearly as much effort. Focus on the apps, sides, and entrees and let Aldi fill in the blanks for a meal-capping sweet treat. This store is known for a variety of hidden gems and value pricing, but one product in its freezer section is an Aldi dessert that actually tastes homemade — and it may just fool your guests. Aldi shoppers say The Village Pie Maker pies have a comforting scratch-made taste, plus they're a cinch to prepare.

The Village Maker pies come frozen in classic flavors such as apple and strawberry rhubarb. They weigh around 3 pounds per pie and cost less than $15 each, depending on the specific Aldi location. The baking process detailed in the instructions takes about 70 minutes total in the oven and one hour to let the pie cool once it's done. Fans on the internet sing the praises of these convenient desserts.

One Redditor said, "Local bakery here charges $45+ for a strawberry rhubarb, so it's a great deal and timesaver for a delicious pie that tastes as good as homemade." Another Reddit user noted, "The village pie maker apple and pumpkin frozen pies are SO good. Not too sweet, flaky buttery crust," and encouraged shoppers not to "sleep" on the Aldi find. A commenter also mentioned, "We made one earlier in the year and froze a couple of pieces. I just ate them about a month ago, still delicious!"

With so many frozen dessert pie brands to choose from, discovering The Village Pie Maker at Aldi is a total game changer. It's difficult to find a store-bought option that tastes homemade, but fan feedback indicates these pies are up to the task. One Facebook user pointed out, "I know $13/14 is spendy for many of us, but I am splurging with these from Aldi because these are amazing and the holidays are coming." A reply in the comments enthused, "I can vouch that the strawberry rhubarb is amazing and can easily pass off as homemade."

Some shoppers recommend adding extra toppings like praline to give your pie more of a home-baked feel. Though it isn't the same as making your own spring picnic strawberry rhubarb pie, the Aldi find does get astoundingly close. Many Aldi aficionados also note that these pies can be tricky to find — so keep a close eye out for them at your local store.

When discussing the strawberry rhubarb flavor, one Redditor said, "I hated pie my whole life. Until I ate this pie. Now I know why people like them. This flavor is my holy grail. I've only gotten it once at my Aldi's. If I ever catch it again, I'm buying all of them. End of story." If you're short on time and want to impress your guests — even those who might not like pie — this Aldi dessert is an easy choice.