Please Don't Try To Cook A Hot Dog In A Toaster — Here's Why

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

The toaster is an incredibly versatile appliance. Capable of browning bread in seconds, toasters can also warm frozen waffles, crisp up savory pastries, and even soften sliced sweet potatoes. Certain foods, however, lend themselves better to toasting than others. Of the many items that should never be cooked in a toaster, hot dogs top the list. Although using the appliance seems like the ultimate hack for crafting smoky and char-marked links without a grill, toasting hot dogs has extremely dangerous consequences.

Whether you opt for beef, pork, or turkey-based renditions, cooking hot dogs in the toaster is never wise due to the fatty composition of the links. While this is what helps the links to stay plump and flavorful, an elevated fat content can pose a safety concern. After all, wieners tend to burst when exposed to high temperatures, prompting oils and juices to leak from the casing. When placed hot dogs are placed in a toaster, these greasy liquids can drip onto the appliance's heating element and warm to the point of ignition. Rather than risk a grease fire, it's simply best to refrain from cooking hot dogs in the toaster.

Beyond threatening safety, toasting hot dogs doesn't make much practical sense, either. Given that links are likely to splatter — even if placed in a toaster bag, beforehand — cooking them in a toaster is messy, making clean-up all the more taxing. If that weren't enough, it's worth mentioning that toasting also won't produce the best flavors, textures, or aesthetics.

Not only are there safer ways to cook the links, but other methods will also produce a better tasting and looking result. That said, grilling is pretty hard to beat as the flame-kissed technique gives hot dogs a deliciously smoky flavor along with a texturally crisp and visually appealing char. In the absence of a barbecue or in the interest of convenience, you can sear wieners on the stovetop using a cast iron skillet. Oven roasting (specifically, broiling) or air frying can brown the links beautifully all while being low-effort and low-mess options.

Alternatively, invest in a dedicated piece of equipment to cook hot dogs. For example, crafting perfectly cooked links is straightforward with the help of a small-scale hot dog roller. But, we also aren't opposed to toaster-adjacent options with built-in bun warmers. Regardless of the model, we advise seeking out features like temperature controls to effectively manage the cooking process. Opting for non-stick cooking surfaces is also wise. Of course, the right appliance should be easy to use and clean, too.

No matter the method you choose to cook hot dogs, there are a few other tricks to ensure a safe and tasty result. Along with using quality links, forgo slicing or spiraling to keep links from drying and shriveling. For extra flavor, you can even poach wieners, finishing them with a flash of heat — just don't ever place the hot dogs in the toaster!